COVID Vaccine Passport Apps: CommonPass and What Came Next

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-01-06.

Vaccine-Passport App Proposals in Early 2021

At the turn of 2021, with the first COVID-19 vaccines just being rolled out, technology groups, non-profits and airlines were racing to build smartphone apps that could show whether a traveller had tested negative or been vaccinated. The best known was CommonPass, developed by the Geneva-based non-profit The Commons Project together with the World Economic Forum. The idea was that one digital pass could satisfy the entry rules of many countries, airlines and venues.

Within months the idea became reality in a different form: governments, not apps from private consortia, ended up issuing the passes most people used, led by the EU Digital COVID Certificate in July 2021. Here is what was being built, the arguments for and against, and what happened next.

What CommonPass and similar apps were designed to do

CommonPass was run through an initiative called the Common Trust Network. A user would upload a COVID-19 test result and, later, proof of vaccination from a trusted lab or health provider. The app would check those records against the entry requirements for the user’s itinerary and produce a QR code saying “meets requirements” without showing the underlying medical details to airline or border staff.

According to CNN’s reporting in December 2020, airlines involved in the network included Cathay Pacific, JetBlue, Lufthansa, Swiss, United Airlines and Virgin Atlantic, along with hundreds of US health systems and the government of Aruba. The airlines had an obvious interest: international travel had collapsed, and a reliable way to show health status looked like a route back to full flights.

CommonPass was not alone. IBM was building a Digital Health Pass for employers and venues to set their own entry conditions, and the airline association IATA was developing its Travel Pass app. Each used slightly different technology, which is where the next problem came in.

Why developers compared it to a yellow fever card

The comparison was with the paper yellow fever certificate that travellers to some countries have long carried. Thomas Crampton of The Commons Project put the logic simply to CNN: “You can be tested every time you cross a border. You cannot be vaccinated every time you cross a border.” A test is a snapshot; a vaccination record is meant to last, so it needs to be portable.

Portability depends on standards. Brian Behlendorf, executive director of the Linux Foundation, which was working with a group of more than 300 people from dozens of organisations on shared rules for vaccine credentials, said such records “should be interoperable in the same way that email is interoperable.” Without that, a certificate issued in one country could be meaningless at the next airport. In March 2021 the standards body Ecma International announced it would work on international standards for vaccine passports, a sign of how unsettled the field still was.

Privacy and fairness worries

Critics raised several concerns, and they were taken seriously by the developers themselves, who stressed user consent and data minimisation.

  • Surveillance: a pass checked at borders, offices and concerts could, if badly designed, reveal where a person goes and when.
  • Sharing of health data: medical records moving between companies and governments, some with poor human-rights records, raised fears of misuse.
  • Exclusion: in early 2021 vaccines were scarce, and people without smartphones, without access to vaccines or unable to be vaccinated for medical reasons risked being shut out.
  • Fragmentation: several competing apps meant confusion for travellers and staff.

Israel’s Green Pass, which let fully vaccinated people attend concerts, eat indoors and travel, showed how quickly these debates could turn real. Soon after it launched, the Knesset passed a law allowing local authorities to receive data on residents who had not been vaccinated, which privacy advocates criticised.

The scientific question: did vaccines stop transmission?

A pass based on vaccination only makes sense for infection control if vaccinated people are less likely to pass the virus on. In December 2020 that was unknown. Stanford infectious disease specialist Julie Parsonnet told CNN: “We still don’t know if vaccinated people can transmit infection or not.” She added that until that was clear, it would be hard to say whether passports worked.

Later evidence gave a mixed answer. Vaccines were very good at preventing severe illness and death, and early studies suggested they also cut the chance of spreading the virus. That protection against infection faded over time and was weaker against later variants such as Omicron, which is one reason many countries moved back towards testing or dropped entry requirements altogether. Anyone with questions about their own vaccination should talk to a doctor.

What came into use: the EU Digital COVID Certificate

The most widely used system was not a private app but the EU Digital COVID Certificate, which took effect on 1 July 2021. It took the form of a QR code, on paper or in an app, holding one digitally signed claim: a vaccination, a recent negative test, or recovery from COVID-19. Apart from that claim it contained only the holder’s name and date of birth. With it, people could move between EU countries without quarantine.

The certificate was a big practical success. Member states had issued more than two billion of them by December 2022, and dozens of non-EU countries and territories connected to the system. The EU rules expired on 30 June 2023, when the emergency phase of the pandemic was over.

Elsewhere, governments built their own passes, including Israel’s Green Pass and several US state apps, while airline tools such as IATA Travel Pass were used to check documents before boarding. CommonPass itself became one of many routes rather than the single global pass its backers hoped for.

Lessons for the next health emergency

  • Standards first: a credential is only useful if it is recognised everywhere you need it. The EU’s shared format worked because 27 countries agreed on it early.
  • Keep the data small: showing a simple yes/no or a single signed claim protects privacy better than sharing full records.
  • Match the tool to the science: passes were most useful while evidence suggested vaccination reduced spread, and became less relevant as variants changed that picture.
  • Plan for people left out: paper options and exemptions for those who cannot be vaccinated matter as much as the app.

Today no general COVID vaccination pass is required for most travel, but the experience of 2021 shaped how digital health credentials, and the arguments about them, are likely to work in future.

Sources: CNN Business: vaccine passport apps (December 2020); Wikipedia: EU Digital COVID Certificate; Wikipedia: Vaccination certificate; Paperjam: EU kicks off Covid travel pass (July 2021).

COMMENTS