Originally published 2021-01-07.

On 4 January 2021 a London judge refused the United States' request to extradite WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange. District Judge Vanessa Baraitser ruled that sending him to face trial in America would be oppressive because of his mental health and the high risk that he would take his own life in a US prison. It was a dramatic win for Assange, but a narrow one: on almost every other point the judge sided with the US, and her decision was overturned on appeal later that year.
Here is what the ruling said, why it mattered, and how a case that dragged on for more than a decade finally ended in 2024.
What the judge decided, and what she rejected
The hearing took place at the Central Criminal Court in London, better known as the Old Bailey. The US had charged Assange with 18 offences: 17 under the Espionage Act and one of conspiring to commit computer intrusion. Together they carried a theoretical maximum of 175 years in prison.
Assange's lawyers argued that the prosecution was political, that it attacked press freedom, and that he would not get a fair trial. Judge Baraitser rejected those arguments. She found that his alleged conduct went beyond ordinary investigative journalism, and she saw no convincing evidence that the case was driven by pressure from the Trump administration or that he would be denied a fair hearing.
Instead she blocked extradition on one ground alone. Under UK extradition law a court can refuse to send someone abroad if their physical or mental condition makes it unjust or oppressive. She described Assange as a depressed man with the intelligence to get around suicide-prevention measures and said she was "satisfied that the risk that Mr Assange will commit suicide is a substantial one." She also pointed to the severely restrictive conditions he would likely face in US custody.
The medical evidence behind the ruling
Much of the case turned on psychiatric testimony. Michael Kopelman, an emeritus professor of neuropsychiatry at King's College London, had examined Assange repeatedly in Belmarsh prison. He told the court that Assange had experienced auditory and bodily hallucinations, that he had a long history of hearing music that was not there, and that he had made plans to end his life.
Other experts gave evidence that Assange had autism spectrum disorder, a diagnosis the judge accepted. She concluded that the combination of severe depression, autism and isolation in a US maximum-security setting would make suicide a real danger, whatever precautions were taken.
The judge herself acknowledged that the legal threshold for oppression is high, and UK courts rarely block an extradition on health grounds alone. That is why the decision drew so much attention, and why the US focused its appeal on the medical question.
Freed from extradition, but not from prison
The win did not set Assange free. On 6 January 2021, two days after the ruling, the same judge refused him bail, saying he might abscond while the US appealed. He went back to HM Prison Belmarsh, the high-security jail in south-east London where he had been held since his arrest in April 2019.
Supporters marked the ruling outside court and online. Kristinn Hrafnsson, the WikiLeaks editor-in-chief, spoke for the campaign, while Assange's partner Stella Moris used the moment to repeat serious allegations against US intelligence.
Kristinn Hrafnsson from @WikiLeaks, final statement on #Assange case victory. “Enough is enough.”
— Don't Extradite Assange (@DEAcampaign) January 4, 2021
The fight is not over. pic.twitter.com/0oGIckDFBp
The statement above, shared by the Don't Extradite Assange campaign on the day of the ruling, shows Hrafnsson welcoming the result while warning that the fight was not over. He proved right: the US filed its appeal within two weeks.
Stella Moris: US agents plotted to kill Julian #Assange on British soil. #FreeAssange @StellaMoris1 pic.twitter.com/tPeVIr3nhb
— Don't Extradite Assange (@DEAcampaign) January 4, 2021
In this second clip, Moris alleges that US agents had plotted to kill Assange on British soil. The claim related to evidence heard during the extradition hearings about surveillance of Assange inside the Ecuadorian embassy. Later reporting said that senior CIA officials had discussed kidnapping or killing him in 2017, after WikiLeaks published leaked CIA hacking tools; the US government has not confirmed those accounts.
Why the US wanted him
Assange founded WikiLeaks in 2006 as a platform for publishing leaked documents. Its biggest disclosures came in 2010, from material provided by US Army intelligence analyst Chelsea Manning. They included hundreds of thousands of military field reports from Iraq and Afghanistan, a vast archive of diplomatic cables, and files on detainees at Guantanamo Bay.
In April 2010 WikiLeaks also released a video it titled "Collateral Murder". It showed a US Apache helicopter attack in Baghdad on 12 July 2007 in which a number of people were killed, among them two Reuters news staff. The footage became one of the most widely viewed images of the Iraq war.
US prosecutors argued that Assange had not simply published material but had helped Manning obtain it, and that the releases put named informants at risk. Supporters, including many press-freedom groups, warned that prosecuting a publisher under the Espionage Act could threaten journalists everywhere.
Sweden, the embassy and the arrest
Assange's legal troubles in Britain began with Sweden, not the US. In August 2010 Swedish prosecutors opened a preliminary investigation into allegations of sexual offences made by two women. Assange denied wrongdoing and said he feared Sweden would hand him to the United States.
After losing his fight against extradition to Sweden, he breached his British bail in June 2012 and walked into Ecuador's embassy in London. Ecuador granted him political asylum on 16 August 2012, and he lived in the small flat for almost seven years.
The Swedish case faded over time. Some allegations expired under the statute of limitations in 2015, and the remaining rape investigation was dropped in 2017, reopened in 2019 and closed for good in November 2019. Prosecutors said the evidence had weakened over the long time that had passed, while stressing that they still found the complainant credible. No charges were ever filed.
His relationship with Ecuador soured after a change of government. On 11 April 2019 Ecuador withdrew his asylum and the Metropolitan Police carried him out of the building. The US unsealed its first charge against him the same day and added the Espionage Act counts weeks later.
The politics around the case
WikiLeaks became a political lightning rod in 2016, when it published emails stolen from the Democratic National Committee and from Hillary Clinton's campaign chairman, John Podesta. US intelligence agencies concluded that Russian military hackers had stolen the material, an account WikiLeaks disputed. Donald Trump praised WikiLeaks during that campaign, and some supporters hoped he would pardon Assange before leaving office in January 2021. He did not.
Mexico's president, Andrés Manuel López Obrador, offered Assange political asylum immediately after the January 2021 ruling. The incoming Biden administration nevertheless pressed ahead with the US appeal.
How the case finally ended
The US appeal succeeded. In December 2021 the High Court overturned the block after the US offered diplomatic assurances about how Assange would be held, and in June 2022 the then home secretary, Priti Patel, approved his extradition. Assange kept fighting, and in 2024 the High Court allowed him a full appeal.
Before that appeal was heard, a deal was struck. On 24 June 2024 Assange was granted bail and left Belmarsh after 1,901 days, flying out of Stansted Airport. In a US federal court in Saipan, in the Northern Mariana Islands, he pleaded guilty to one Espionage Act charge of conspiring to obtain and disclose classified national defence information. He was sentenced to time already served, the other 17 charges were dropped, and he landed in Canberra on 26 June 2024. Two days later the High Court in London quashed the extradition order and formally closed the proceedings.
Sources for this section: Jersey Evening Post (PA), 25 June 2024: Julian Assange leaves UK after reaching plea deal with US; Express & Star (PA), 28 June 2024: Decision to approve Julian Assange's extradition quashed after release.
Why the January 2021 ruling still matters
Judge Baraitser's decision is often remembered as the moment Assange won, but the detail is important. By rejecting the free-speech and political arguments, she left the core of the US case intact, and the appeal court later overturned her on the health question after the US gave assurances about how he would be treated. The ruling is still cited in debates about two separate issues: how far mental illness should limit extradition, and whether publishing classified information can be prosecuted as espionage.
The case ended without a court ever ruling on that second question. Assange's guilty plea to a single conspiracy charge meant no US jury heard the evidence, and the question of how the Espionage Act applies to publishers remains open.
Sources: Al Jazeera, 4 January 2021: UK judge blocks US request to extradite Assange; AP News, January 2021: UK judge refuses US extradition of WikiLeaks founder Assange; Express & Star (PA), January 2021: US lawyers lodge appeal against block on Assange's extradition; Wikipedia: Julian Assange. Embedded posts: Don't Extradite Assange campaign (@DEAcampaign) on Twitter.

COMMENTS