Originally published 2020-12-31.

In Gallup's year-end poll for 2020, 18% of Americans named Donald Trump as the man they admired most, ahead of Barack Obama on 15%. That ended Obama's run of 12 straight years at the top, which had tied Dwight Eisenhower's record. Michelle Obama was named the most admired woman for the third year in a row, with 10%.
The result caused plenty of argument online, much of it based on a misunderstanding of what the poll measures. Below is how the survey works, the full top ten for men and women, why Trump moved ahead, and what the numbers can and cannot tell you.
How Gallup's "most admired" poll works
Gallup has asked Americans this question almost every year since 1946 for men and 1948 for women. It is open-ended: interviewers do not read out a list of names. Instead, respondents are asked which man and which woman, living anywhere in the world, they admire most, and Gallup combines first and second mentions.
The 2020 survey was carried out by telephone from 1 to 17 December 2020 with 1,018 adults across all 50 states and Washington, DC. The margin of sampling error is plus or minus 4 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. That means Trump's true support could plausibly have been anywhere from about 14% to 22%, and Obama's from about 11% to 19%, so the gap between them was not large.
Because the question is unprompted, winning percentages are usually small. A fifth or more of respondents typically give no answer at all, and in 2020, 21% had no opinion on the man question.
The 2020 results for men
The full top ten for most admired man in 2020 was:
- Donald Trump, 18%
- Barack Obama, 15%
- Joe Biden, 6%
- Anthony Fauci, 3%
- Pope Francis, 2%
- Elon Musk, Bernie Sanders, Bill Gates, LeBron James and the Dalai Lama, 1% each
Fauci and LeBron James made the list for the first time, a sign of how the Covid-19 pandemic and the year's protests shaped who people had in mind. Another 11% named a relative or friend instead of a public figure.
The 2020 results for women
For most admired woman, the top ten was:
- Michelle Obama, 10%
- Kamala Harris, 6%
- Melania Trump, 4%
- Oprah Winfrey, 3%
- Angela Merkel, Hillary Clinton, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Queen Elizabeth II, 2% each
- Amy Coney Barrett and Greta Thunberg, 1% each
Harris, newly elected vice-president, finished second on her first appearance in the top ten. Some summaries of the poll at the time mixed the men's and women's lists together, but they are separate questions, so it is the 10% for Michelle Obama, not the men's figures, that she should be compared with. A further 16% of respondents named a woman they know personally.
Why Trump moved ahead of Obama
Trump's 18% was not a sign of a sudden jump in his popularity. His job approval rating at the time was 39%, close to the 36% and 40% he had in 2017 and 2018, when he finished second to Obama.
The bigger change was on the Democratic side. Among Republicans, 48% named Trump, and no other man received more than 2%. Among Democrats, Obama's share fell to 32% from 41% a year earlier, as many named Biden (13%) or Fauci (5%) instead. Independents were split evenly, with 11% each for Trump and Obama. In other words, Republican voters concentrated on one name, while Democratic admiration was spread across several people in an election year.
Sitting presidents usually win
Gallup has asked the most admired man question 74 times, and the sitting president has come first in 60 of those years. That makes the exceptions interesting. Presidents who did not top the list in some years include Harry Truman, Lyndon Johnson, Richard Nixon, Gerald Ford, Jimmy Carter and George W. Bush, usually during wars, scandals or economic trouble. Trump was beaten by his predecessor in 2017 and 2018. In 2020, his last full year in office, he took first place outright.
Only a handful of men who were neither president nor former president have ever won, including General Douglas MacArthur, Henry Kissinger and Pope John Paul II.
Record holders over the years
The evangelist Billy Graham holds the record among men, with 61 top-ten finishes during his lifetime. Ronald Reagan has 31, Jimmy Carter 29, Pope John Paul II 27 and Bill Clinton 26. Among women, Queen Elizabeth II made the top ten 52 times, ahead of Margaret Thatcher with 34, Oprah Winfrey with 33 and Hillary Clinton with 29.
Trump's 2020 finish was his tenth appearance in the top ten. Four of those came long before he entered politics: from 1988 to 1990 and again in 2011, when he was known mainly as a businessman and television personality.
What the poll does and does not tell you
The most admired list is a snapshot of who is on Americans' minds at the end of a year, and how strongly each political camp unites behind a single figure. It is not an approval rating, an endorsement of a person's policies, or a popularity contest decided by a majority. With an 18% winning score, more than four in five respondents named someone else or nobody at all.
One of the most quietly telling numbers in the poll is the share of people who chose someone from their own life. In 2020, 11% named a male friend or relative and 16% a woman they know, a reminder that admiration often starts much closer to home than the headlines suggest.
Sources: Gallup: Donald Trump, Michelle Obama Most Admired in 2020.

COMMENTS