Poland's 2020 Abortion Ruling Protests: What Happened and Why

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-11-01.

In late October 2020 Poland saw its largest street protests since the fall of communism. The trigger was a ruling by the Constitutional Tribunal on 22 October 2020 that abortion for severe or fatal foetal defects was unconstitutional. Because that was the legal ground for almost all lawful abortions in the country, the decision amounted to a near-total ban. Police estimated that around 430,000 people joined more than 400 protests on a single day, 28 October, and huge crowds marched in Warsaw two days later. The ruling took effect in January 2021, and the fight over it has shaped Polish politics ever since.

Poland's 2020 Demonstrations Over Abortion Restrictions

Here is what the court decided, why it caused such an outcry, how the government and president responded and where the law stands now.

What the Constitutional Tribunal ruled

Since 1993, Polish law had allowed abortion in only three situations: when the pregnancy threatened the woman's life or health, when it resulted from a crime such as rape or incest, and when prenatal tests showed a severe and irreversible foetal impairment or an incurable, life-threatening illness. Abortion on request, available in most of the European Union, was not permitted.

In 2019, 119 members of parliament, mostly from the governing Law and Justice party (PiS) together with the far-right Confederation and a smaller group, asked the tribunal to review the foetal-impairment ground. On 22 October 2020 the court ruled 11 to 2 that it violated the constitutional protection of life.

The practical effect was enormous. Of roughly 1,100 legal abortions recorded in Poland in 2019, about 1,070 were carried out because of foetal defects. After the ruling, only the other two grounds remained, covering a tiny fraction of cases. Critics also questioned the court's independence, since several of its judges had been appointed in disputed circumstances after PiS came to power in 2015.

The biggest protests in a generation

The reaction was immediate. Protests began the evening of the ruling and spread to cities, towns and villages across the country, from Warsaw, Kraków and Gdańsk to Białystok, Poznań, Wrocław, Toruń, Szczecin, Myślenice, Gorlice and Jasło. The movement was coordinated largely by the All-Poland Women's Strike (Ogólnopolski Strajk Kobiet), led by activists including Marta Lempart and Klementyna Suchanow, and its red lightning-bolt symbol appeared on placards, windows and face masks everywhere.

On 28 October, police chief Jarosław Szymczyk estimated that about 430,000 people took part in 410 separate protests. On 30 October a march in Warsaw drew around 100,000 people by some counts, with other estimates higher. Many demonstrators were young, and the protests drew in people who had never been politically active before. They took place during a pandemic, which made the turnout all the more striking.

Most gatherings were peaceful. There were scuffles with nationalist counter-groups who said they were protecting churches, and some protesters disrupted Sunday masses or sprayed slogans on church buildings, which deepened the anger of conservatives. Police detained dozens of people over the following weeks and in November used pepper spray on demonstrators in Warsaw, including members of parliament.

How the government and president responded

The ruling party's leader, Jarosław Kaczyński, gave a video address on 27 October urging supporters to defend churches "at all costs". Many commentators saw it as escalating the conflict rather than calming it.

President Andrzej Duda, who was aligned with PiS but sensed the scale of public anger, tried to find a middle path. Speaking on radio, he said he believed the law should still allow termination when a foetus had fatal defects, telling listeners: "In the case of lethal defects, the death of the child is inevitable." On 30 October he sent parliament a bill that would have restored abortion for defects incompatible with life, while ruling it out for conditions such as Down syndrome. He also condemned protesters who had entered churches or insulted religious feelings. His bill was never passed.

Faced with mass opposition, the government delayed publishing the ruling, which it needed to do for the judgment to take legal effect. It missed the expected deadline in early November 2020, saying more dialogue was needed.

When the ban took effect

The ruling was finally published in the official Journal of Laws on 27 January 2021, which brought it into force that day. Protests returned to the streets of Warsaw, Wrocław, Poznań, Kraków and other cities, though on a smaller scale than in October.

Since then, abortion in Poland has been legal only when the pregnancy endangers the woman's life or health, or when it results from a crime. Doctors' uncertainty about when the health exception applies has been blamed for delays in care, and the deaths of several pregnant women from septic shock after treatment was delayed led to fresh protests under the slogan "Not one more." Many women travel abroad, notably to Germany, the Czech Republic and the Netherlands, or obtain abortion pills by post. Estimates of the number of unregistered abortions vary widely, from about 10,000 to as many as 200,000 a year.

A wider culture war

The protests were about more than one ruling. Poland is a deeply Catholic country, and the Church has strong influence in public life. At the same time, younger and urban Poles have become far more secular and socially liberal. The 2020 decision sharpened that divide and became a symbol of broader concerns about PiS's record, including its overhaul of the courts and its pressure on independent media, which brought it into repeated conflict with the European Union.

Many analysts believe the abortion issue helped mobilise young voters, and especially young women, in the October 2023 parliamentary election, which PiS lost. A coalition led by Donald Tusk took power, promising to ease the restrictions.

Where the law stands now

Changing the law has proved difficult. In July 2024 the lower house of parliament, the Sejm, narrowly rejected a bill to decriminalise helping someone obtain an abortion, by 218 votes to 215, after some coalition members voted against it. In August 2024 the government issued guidance encouraging doctors to interpret the existing health exception more broadly, including for mental health.

On 20 October 2026, Polish lawmakers voted to restore abortion in cases of foetal abnormalities and to decriminalise assisting an abortion, according to Reuters. The measure is expected to be vetoed by President Karol Nawrocki, who succeeded Duda in 2025 and opposes liberalising the law. A separate proposal to allow abortion on request up to 12 weeks remains in parliamentary committees.

Six years after the tribunal's decision, then, the core question raised by the October 2020 protests is still unresolved, and Poland remains one of the most restrictive countries in Europe on abortion.

Sources: Wikipedia: October 2020 Polish protests; Wikipedia: Abortion in Poland; Notes from Poland, 27 January 2021: Protests return as anti-abortion ruling goes into force; Reuters via The Star, 21 October 2026: Polish lawmakers vote to ease abortion ban.

COMMENTS