Originally published 2020-11-02.
On Halloween night, 31 October 2020, a man dressed in a medieval-style costume and armed with a katana-style sword attacked passers-by in Old Quebec, the historic heart of Quebec City. Two people were killed, François Duchesne, 56, and Suzanne Clermont, 61, and five others were wounded. Police arrested Carl Girouard, 24, from Sainte-Thérèse near Montreal, within hours. In May 2022 a jury convicted him of first-degree murder despite his defence that he was psychotic; in March 2026 Quebec's Court of Appeal overturned that verdict and ordered a new trial.
This page sets out what is known about the attack, the people affected, the investigation and the long legal process that followed, and why the mental-health question has been at the centre of the case.
Old Quebec, where the attack took place on 31 October 2020, on a Halloween evening when Covid-19 restrictions had left the usually busy streets quieter than normal.
What happened on Halloween night
The attacks began at about 10:30 p.m. near the Parliament Building, home of Quebec's National Assembly, and continued through several streets of the old town. The victims did not know their attacker and, according to police, were chosen at random. Because Quebec was under pandemic restrictions, there were fewer people out than on a normal Halloween, which may have limited the number of casualties.
Quebec City police chief Robert Pigeon told reporters the next day that the suspect had come to the city with the intention of doing the most damage possible
. Police said he had travelled from the Montreal area by car, had prepared his costume in advance and had containers of gasoline in his vehicle.
Officers found him a short time later near the Espace 400e area on the St. Lawrence waterfront. He was reported to be lying on the ground, barefoot and suffering from the cold when he was arrested.
The victims and the community's response
François Duchesne and Suzanne Clermont were both from the Quebec City region. Five other people, men and women, were injured, some seriously. In the following days residents left flowers and candles in Old Quebec in memory of the victims.
Political leaders across Canada responded the next morning. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau addressed the people of Quebec City directly and named both victims.
To the people of Quebec City, and to all Quebecers: Canadians across the country are with you. Our hearts go out to the families of François Duchesne and Suzanne Clermont, and to everyone affected by this terrible tragedy. https://t.co/3Cxgxdh48z
— Justin Trudeau (@JustinTrudeau) November 1, 2020
Jagmeet Singh, leader of the federal New Democratic Party, also sent condolences to the families and thanked first responders.
It's hard to comprehend the senseless violence that occurred in Quebec City, last night.
— Jagmeet Singh (@theJagmeetSingh) November 1, 2020
My thoughts are with friends and family who lost loved ones.
For the injured, I wish for a speedy recovery and I express gratitude for the courage of first responders.
What police said about the suspect
From the outset, police said there was no indication the attack was linked to terrorism or any extremist group, and they said his motive was unknown. They revealed that the suspect had a history of mental-health problems and that about five years earlier he had told a doctor he had thoughts of carrying out a similar attack.
Early reports, including the first version of this page, described that history as a previous conviction for an attack "in a medical context". Police accounts later reported on Wikipedia and in court reporting describe it instead as threats expressed to a doctor, not an earlier assault.
In June 2021 prosecutors used a direct indictment, a procedure that sends a case straight to trial without a preliminary hearing.
The trial: psychosis or planning?
Girouard's trial took place before the Superior Court of Quebec in 2022. He did not deny the attacks. His lawyers argued that he was in a psychotic, delusional state that night and could not tell right from wrong, which under Canadian law would make him not criminally responsible.
Prosecutors argued the opposite. They pointed to the weeks of preparation, the costume, the choice of location and moments during the attacks when he appeared to hesitate, saying these showed a man who understood what he was doing. Expert evidence about his state of mind was central to the case.
On 20 May 2022, after five days of deliberation, the jury found him guilty of two counts of first-degree murder and five counts of attempted murder. On 10 June 2022 he received the mandatory sentence for first-degree murder in Canada: life imprisonment with no eligibility for parole for 25 years. His lawyers had already said they would appeal.
The 2026 appeal ruling
On 31 March 2026 Quebec's Court of Appeal overturned the guilty verdicts and ordered a new trial. A new trial does not mean the accused is cleared: a fresh jury will hear the evidence again, including the question of criminal responsibility.
The detailed reasons were not available in the coverage we could consult, so this page does not speculate about them. Appeals of this kind in Canada usually turn on legal questions, such as how a judge instructed the jury, rather than on whether the attack happened.
Mental illness and violence: what the evidence says
Cases like this one often prompt the assumption that mental illness explains violence. Researchers caution against that. Most people living with a mental illness are never violent, and they are considerably more likely to be victims of violence than perpetrators. Where serious illness such as untreated psychosis does raise the risk, factors such as substance use, past violence and a lack of treatment usually play a large part.
That is why courts treat criminal responsibility as a specific legal question, not a diagnosis: the issue is whether a person, at the moment of the act, could understand what they were doing and that it was wrong. Anyone worried about their own thoughts of harming others, or about someone close to them, should talk to a doctor or a crisis service, and in an emergency call 911.
Sources: Wikipedia: 2020 Quebec City stabbing; JURIST: Jury finds Quebec City sword attacker guilty of first-degree murder (May 2022); CTV News: Court of Appeal overturns Old Quebec sword attack guilty verdict (31 March 2026); BBC News (original report, November 2020). Embedded posts: Justin Trudeau and Jagmeet Singh on X (1 November 2020).

COMMENTS