AKP's Ömer Çelik on Answering Greece 'on the Battlefield'

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-15.

Turkish Party Spokesperson's 2020 Remarks Raised Tensions With Greece

Ömer Çelik, spokesman of Turkey's governing Justice and Development Party (AKP).

In October 2020 Ömer Çelik, the official spokesman of Turkey's ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP), said Turkey wanted its disputes with Greece settled through diplomacy, but that it would respond "on the battlefield" to those who used talks as cover to build alliances against it. Coming from the governing party during a tense stand-off in the Eastern Mediterranean, the remark was widely reported in Greece as an open threat of force against a fellow NATO member.

This page explains what Çelik said, the crisis in which he said it, how other governments were reacting to Turkish policy at the time, and what happened afterwards.

What Ömer Çelik said

Çelik, a former Minister of Culture and Tourism (2013–2015) and Minister for EU Affairs (2016–2018), made the remarks in mid-October 2020 in a briefing for political editors, shortly after Turkey sent the survey ship Oruç Reis back to sea following maintenance. He began by insisting that Turkey had the diplomatic experience to see through partners who, in his view, used negotiations to lock in situations created by force. He said that intimidation would achieve nothing and that Greece needed to understand this.

The key sentence, as reported in English by Greek City Times, was his statement that Turkey wanted every issue in the Aegean and the Eastern Mediterranean resolved through diplomacy, "but those who use diplomacy to take a breath and form alliances against Turkey, we have to answer on the battlefield."

He also rejected the description of Turkey as a source of instability in the region, quoted Atatürk's motto "Peace at home, peace in the world", and said Turkey had the power to answer both at the negotiating table and on the battlefield. He also dismissed the so-called Seville map, which Greece and the EU use as a reference for maritime zones around the small Greek island of Kastellorizo, as worthless paper, and insisted that the ship was working on Turkey's own continental shelf. Read in full, the statement mixed an appeal to diplomacy with a clear warning, and it was the warning that made headlines.

The crisis behind the words

Greece and Turkey have argued for decades over maritime boundaries, airspace and the status of some Aegean islands. In 2020 those disputes sharpened around one practical question: who has the right to search for oil and gas in the Eastern Mediterranean.

  • November 2019: Turkey signed a maritime boundary memorandum with Libya's Tripoli-based Government of National Accord. Greece, Cyprus and Egypt rejected it, saying it ignored the island of Crete.
  • August 2020: Greece and Egypt signed their own agreement on a partial exclusive economic zone. Days later Turkey sent its seismic survey ship Oruç Reis, with a naval escort, into waters Greece considers part of its continental shelf. During the stand-off that followed, a Greek frigate and a Turkish warship escorting the survey reportedly collided.
  • September 2020: Oruç Reis returned to port, and the two countries began NATO-hosted talks on avoiding military incidents.
  • October 2020: Turkey announced that Oruç Reis would return to waters south of Kastellorizo. Greece called this a serious escalation, and Germany, which had been mediating, also criticised the move.

Çelik's comments came in the days after that announcement. At almost the same time President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan said Greece would get the answer it deserved over the Eastern Mediterranean.

Why the remarks drew such strong reactions

Words like these carry extra weight between two NATO allies that came close to armed conflict as recently as the Imia/Kardak crisis of 1996. In 1995 Turkey's parliament declared that it would regard any extension of Greek territorial waters to 12 nautical miles in the Aegean as a "casus belli", a cause for war, and Ankara has never withdrawn that position. For Greeks, the language of "the battlefield" from the governing party therefore sounded like a continuation of that policy rather than a slip.

The remarks also landed during Turkey's wider confrontations elsewhere. Turkey had launched military operations in northern Syria and supported armed Syrian opposition groups, and it backed the Tripoli government in Libya's civil war. In the Kurdish-majority region around Hasakah, local authorities and aid groups accused Turkey and the Syrian factions it supports of repeatedly cutting water supplies from the Alouk pumping station during 2020, affecting hundreds of thousands of people; Turkey denied deliberately interrupting the supply.

At home, press-freedom groups such as the Committee to Protect Journalists have for years listed Turkey among the countries that jail the most journalists, and human rights organisations reported the detention of opponents and the blocking of online content critical of the government.

Macron's "red line" and the Nagorno-Karabakh war

Two weeks before Çelik spoke, war had broken out between Armenia and Azerbaijan over Nagorno-Karabakh, known to Armenians as Artsakh. France, Russia and others said Turkey had helped bring Syrian fighters to the front on Azerbaijan's side; Turkey and Azerbaijan denied it.

At an EU summit in early October 2020, French President Emmanuel Macron said France had information that Syrian jihadist fighters had passed through Turkey to reach Azerbaijan. He told reporters: "A red line has been crossed, which is unacceptable," and called on NATO partners to face up to the behaviour of a fellow member. Taken together with the Aegean dispute, this left Turkey in open disagreement with several of its own allies at once.

Separating rhetoric from facts

Some reports from the time called Erdoğan Turkey's "de facto" president. That is inaccurate: he became president in an election in 2014 and was re-elected in 2018 under the presidential system approved in the 2017 referendum, and again in 2023. Criticism of his government's policies is common in Greece, Cyprus and across Europe, but his office itself is not in doubt.

It is also worth keeping in mind that party spokesmen speak for their party, not for Turkey's armed forces, and that strong rhetoric does not by itself mean a decision to use force. That is exactly why statements like Çelik's matter: they raise tension and make accidents more likely, even when no attack follows.

What happened next

Oruç Reis continued surveying until late November 2020, and the European Union discussed sanctions against Turkey at its December 2020 summit, agreeing only limited measures. Greece and Turkey resumed direct exploratory talks in January 2021 after a gap of almost five years. The disputes themselves remain unresolved, and the occupation of northern Cyprus by Turkish troops since 1974 continues to shape the relationship between Ankara, Athens and Nicosia.

For Greek readers in particular, the October 2020 remarks are a reminder that the dispute is not only about maps and gas fields. It is also about the language leaders use, and how quickly that language can move from the negotiating table to threats.

Sources: Greek City Times, 15 October 2020; Greek Reporter, 14 October 2020; France 24, 2 October 2020; Enab Baladi, April 2020; Committee to Protect Journalists; Ömer Çelik (Wikipedia); Aegean dispute (Wikipedia).

Related on this site: Assad and Macron's claims about fighters sent to Artsakh.

COMMENTS