Originally published 2020-10-16.
On 10 October 2020, at a night-time ceremony in Pyongyang marking 75 years since the founding of the Workers' Party of Korea, Kim Jong Un did something North Korean leaders almost never do in public: he said sorry. Midway through his speech he took off his glasses and wiped his eyes, telling citizens that his efforts had not been enough to lift the hardships in their lives. Cameras also caught soldiers and spectators in the square in tears.

What Kim Jong Un said in the speech
The address was unusual less for its length than for its tone. Kim's big set-piece speeches usually dwell on military strength and foreign threats. This time, by the count of South Korean analysts, roughly a third of the text was taken up with thanks to ordinary people and with apology.
Kim said the public had placed trust in him "as high as the sky and as deep as the sea", and admitted he had not always lived up to it. He invoked his grandfather Kim Il Sung and his father Kim Jong Il, the founders of the dynasty, and conceded that his work had fallen short of freeing people from their daily difficulties.
He then turned to the institutions around him. The party, the government and the armed forces, he said, would be told to demand more of themselves and to work harder for the population. Near the end he sent sympathy to people abroad who were fighting Covid-19 and expressed hope that the two Koreas might one day be reunited. He also repeated the official claim that North Korea had not recorded a single coronavirus case.
The three hardships behind the tears
Kim framed 2020 around what state media came to call three blows at once: international sanctions, the pandemic and natural disasters.
- Sanctions. United Nations measures imposed over the nuclear and missile programmes had already squeezed exports of coal, textiles and seafood, the country's main sources of foreign currency.
- The closed border. To keep the virus out, Pyongyang sealed itself off early in 2020, which choked even the limited trade with China that the economy depends on.
- Storms and floods. Heavy summer rain was followed by a run of typhoons. After Typhoon Maysak struck in early September, Kim toured damaged areas, sacked a provincial party chief and promised to punish officials blamed for failing to protect residents.
Put together, these pressures meant food shortages and economic strain that even a tightly controlled state could not fully hide. The apology can be read as an acknowledgment of a reality people were already living.
How experts read the emotional moment
Observers in Seoul did not take the tears as a simple sign of weakness, nor as pure theatre. Hong Min, who heads North Korea research at the Korea Institute for National Unification, told The Korea Times that the language Kim chose pointed to a leader under real pressure. He highlighted phrases in the speech about "grave challenges" and "disasters unprecedented in history", and noted that Kim closed by asking for the people's full support. In Hong's view, the speech showed concern about public mood and about the stability of the regime itself.
Others saw a deliberate change of image. Columnist and author Donald Kirk, quoted in the same report, said Kim was presenting himself as a feeling human being rather than a remote figure reading out statements, aiming both at domestic listeners and at foreign audiences. Analysts broadly agreed on the purpose: to rally loyalty during a national crisis by sharing the blame, at least in words.
Apology on stage, missiles on parade
The softer tone did not last the night. The same parade unveiled a new, very large intercontinental ballistic missile carried on an 11-axle launcher, later known as the Hwasong-17. Kim was filmed smiling broadly as it rolled past. Harry Kazianis of the Center for the National Interest commented that the weapons programme would keep moving forward whatever the hardships, and that a parade packed with unmasked crowds risked becoming a super-spreader event.
That contrast is worth keeping in mind. Tears and apologies can be sincere and politically useful at the same time, and a recording cannot tell us which weighed more. What it does show is that the leadership felt it had to speak openly about suffering that state media normally plays down.
Rumours, succession talk and the pressure at the top
The speech came after a year of speculation about Kim himself. In April 2020 he vanished from public view for around three weeks, missing the anniversary of his grandfather's birth, and some outlets reported that he was gravely ill or even dead. He reappeared, and no clear evidence of a health crisis emerged. Later that summer, South Korean intelligence reportedly said he had handed some responsibilities to his sister, Kim Yo Jong, which fed fresh talk about claims that he was in a coma and that she was about to take over.
It is easy to imagine North Korea's leader as all-powerful, and formally he is. In practice, any ruler there also depends on the loyalty of the party elite and the military. An apology that spreads responsibility to officials, while keeping the leader at the centre as the one who cares most, is a familiar way of holding that coalition together in hard times.
Why so little is known from inside North Korea
Judging a moment like this is hard because outside information is so limited. Freedom House gave North Korea a score of 3 out of 100 in its 2020 report, among the lowest in the world, with zero for political rights. All domestic media are run by the state, and radios and televisions are fixed to official channels. A handful of foreign agencies, including Kyodo, Xinhua and Agence France-Presse, have kept bureaus in Pyongyang, but their access is closely managed, and crews have been expelled over their reporting.
North Korea is often described as "the most unfree nation on Earth". The rankings put it at or near the bottom, alongside a few other territories, so "one of the least free countries in the world" is the more accurate description.
For readers, the practical lesson is to treat both the official footage and the most dramatic rumours with care. Speeches, parades and state photographs are carefully staged, while stories of deaths and coups have repeatedly proved wrong. The most reliable picture usually comes from patient analysts who compare many small signals over time.
Sources: The Korea Times: analysis of Kim's anniversary speech; Wikipedia: Hwasong-17; Wikipedia: Kim Jong Un; Freedom House: North Korea, Freedom in the World 2020.

COMMENTS