Why Facebook Removed Trump's Post Comparing Covid-19 to the Flu

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-08.

Facebook's Removal of a Trump COVID-19 Post in 2020

On 6 October 2020, Facebook deleted a post by then-President Donald Trump that said Covid-19 was less lethal than seasonal flu for most people. Twitter left the identical tweet online but hid it behind a warning and stopped people from sharing it normally. Both companies said the claim broke their rules on harmful health misinformation. Trump answered by demanding that Congress scrap Section 230, the law that shapes how online platforms handle what their users post.

The episode came only hours after Trump left hospital following his own Covid-19 infection, and less than a month before the 2020 presidential election. That timing explains why a single post drew so much attention, and why it became a test case for how social networks treat false health claims made by a head of state.

What the post said and how each platform responded

Trump's message argued that flu kills many people every year, in some years more than 100,000 by his count, yet the country does not shut down for it. He suggested Americans would learn to live with the coronavirus in the same way. The full text is preserved in the embedded tweet below.

Facebook acted shortly before 11 a.m. Eastern time. A company spokesperson told reporters: "We remove incorrect information about the severity of Covid-19, and have now removed this post." Removal was the strongest step available to it, and Facebook rarely used it against a sitting president.

Twitter took a different route. The tweet had been visible for more than three hours when the company placed a notice over it saying it violated the rules on misleading Covid-19 information. Readers could still click through, because Twitter decided that public interest justified keeping a president's words accessible. Retweets, likes and replies were restricted, which sharply limited how far the message could travel.

The split shows two philosophies. Facebook treated the claim as dangerous content to delete. Twitter treated the author as newsworthy and chose to label rather than erase what a world leader had said.

Is Covid-19 really less deadly than the flu?

No, not across the population as a whole, and the figures available at the time were already clear. When the post went up, Johns Hopkins University counted more than 7.4 million confirmed US cases and over 210,000 deaths in roughly seven months. For the entire 2019–2020 flu season, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimated about 38 million flu illnesses and around 22,000 deaths.

Trump's figure of more than 100,000 flu deaths a year also does not match recent US data. The CDC estimates that between 2010 and 2025, flu caused between 6,300 and 52,000 deaths annually. Even the harsh 2017–2018 season, the deadliest in recent memory, killed an estimated 61,000 people.

Fatality rates tell the same story. The World Health Organization puts the overall death rate for seasonal flu at typically below 0.1% of infections. Estimates of the US Covid-19 infection fatality rate in 2020 ranged from roughly 0.5% to just over 1%, several times higher.

Where the comparison gets complicated

Age matters enormously for both diseases. For children and young adults the risk of dying from Covid-19 in 2020 was low, and in some younger groups it was comparable to the risk from flu. For older adults and people with conditions such as heart disease, diabetes or obesity, Covid-19 was far more dangerous. A claim about most of the population therefore hid the groups where the danger was greatest, and those groups were exactly the people public health advice was trying to protect.

There was another catch. The 2020 Covid death toll accumulated while schools, offices and travel were heavily restricted and many people wore masks. Flu seasons in earlier years ran without any of those measures. Comparing raw totals without that context makes the coronavirus look milder than it was.

Trump's own illness in the background

The post appeared the day after Trump returned from Walter Reed National Military Medical Center. He had announced in the early hours of 2 October that he and First Lady Melania Trump had tested positive, and he was admitted to hospital later that day.

During three nights there, his doctors gave him an experimental antibody cocktail made by Regeneron, a course of the antiviral remdesivir and the steroid dexamethasone, which is usually reserved for patients whose oxygen levels drop. Reports conflicted over whether he received supplemental oxygen; his medical team was reluctant to give a clear answer. He returned to the White House on the evening of 5 October while still under treatment, a decision some doctors called risky.

Back at the White House, Trump urged Americans not to let the virus dominate their lives. Many survivors and families of people who had died found that message painful, and the flu post the next morning extended the same theme. Critics argued that he was downplaying the danger to support reopening the economy before the November vote, an interpretation his campaign rejected.

"Repeal Section 230": what the law actually does

Shortly after the platforms acted, Trump tweeted "REPEAL SECTION 230!!!" The target was a short passage of the Communications Decency Act, passed in 1996 as part of the Telecommunications Act.

Section 230 does two main things. First, it says websites and apps are generally not treated as the publisher of material their users post, so a platform usually cannot be sued over a user's defamatory comment the way a newspaper could be sued over its own article. Second, a "Good Samaritan" clause protects platforms when they remove or restrict content in good faith that they consider objectionable. Legal writer Jeff Kosseff titled his book on its core sentence The Twenty-Six Words That Created the Internet.

That second clause is what allowed Facebook and Twitter to act against Trump's post without fear of a lawsuit. Ironically, repealing the law outright would likely push platforms to remove even more contested speech, not less, because they would face legal risk for whatever they left up.

Trump's wider campaign against the law

The flu post was not the start of the fight. In May 2020, after Twitter fact-checked his tweets about mail-in voting, Trump signed an executive order on what he called online censorship that sought to narrow Section 230's protections. In December 2020 he vetoed the annual defence spending bill partly because it did not repeal the law. Congress overrode that veto on 1 January 2021 without touching Section 230. President Joe Biden revoked the executive order in May 2021, and the law remains in force.

What the episode means for readers today

The October 2020 removal is a useful case study whenever a viral post compares a new threat with a familiar one. A few practical checks help:

  • Look for the time frame. A full flu season and a few months of a new pandemic are not the same measuring period.
  • Ask who is at risk. Averages can hide the groups facing the greatest danger, such as older people.
  • Check official numbers. Agencies like the CDC and WHO publish their estimates and explain how they are calculated.
  • Notice the label. A warning screen does not mean a post was deleted, and a deletion does not settle the underlying science. Both are decisions by a private company.

For questions about your own health, including vaccines and treatment, the safest step is always to talk to a doctor.

Platform policies on Covid-19 content have changed several times since 2020, and both Facebook and Twitter later suspended Trump's accounts after the January 2021 attack on the US Capitol. The flu post remains an early, clear example of the tension between letting leaders speak and limiting health misinformation.

Sources: CNBC, 6 October 2020; NPR via Public Radio East, 6 October 2020; CDC: About estimated flu burden; Wikipedia: White House COVID-19 outbreak; Wikipedia: Section 230. Header photo: Reuters/Facebook.

COMMENTS