Nagorno-Karabakh 2020: Why Armenians Feared Ethnic Cleansing

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-09.

Armenians Fear Ethnic Cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh, 2020

Armenians, members of the local Armenian committee and Greek supporters rally at the White Tower in Thessaloniki, Greece, on 3 October 2020, a week into the war over Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh). Photo: Nicolas Economou/NurPhoto via Getty Images.

In the autumn of 2020, Armenians around the world feared that the roughly 120,000 Armenians of Nagorno-Karabakh could be driven from their homes. The fear came from three things at once: a sudden Azerbaijani offensive that began on 27 September 2020, open military backing for Azerbaijan from Turkey, and the long memory of the 1915 genocide. The 44-day war ended in an Azerbaijani victory on 10 November 2020. Three years later, in September 2023, almost the entire Armenian population of the region did flee, which is why those warnings are still discussed today.

What Nagorno-Karabakh is and why it was fought over

Nagorno-Karabakh is a mountainous region in the South Caucasus that Armenians call Artsakh. Under international law it was recognised as part of Azerbaijan, but for centuries its population had been mostly Armenian and Christian. As the Soviet Union collapsed, the local Armenians voted to break away, and a war in the early 1990s left Armenian forces in control of the region and of several surrounding Azerbaijani districts. Hundreds of thousands of people on both sides were displaced in that first war, and a fragile ceasefire held, with frequent clashes, for more than 25 years.

The self-declared Republic of Artsakh was not recognised by any UN member state, including Armenia itself, yet it depended on Armenia for security, trade and its link to the outside world. Its residents had long complained of hostility from Baku and wanted unification with Armenia, while Azerbaijan regarded the Armenian-held territories as occupied land that it intended to take back.

The 2020 war in brief

Fighting broke out along the whole front line on 27 September 2020. On the very first day, Azerbaijan began shelling Stepanakert, the regional capital, with rocket artillery and cluster munitions. Families spent weeks in crowded basements and bunkers, with power and phone lines frequently cut, and COVID-19 cases reportedly rose among people sheltering together. We covered the strikes on the city at the time in our report on cluster bombs falling on Stepanakert.

Civilians suffered on both sides. Armenian missile strikes on the Azerbaijani city of Ganja also killed civilians, and Amnesty International concluded that both armies committed war crimes. Neither Armenia nor Azerbaijan has signed the treaty banning cluster munitions, and both used them.

Three ceasefires brokered by Russia, France and the United States collapsed within days. The final agreement, signed on 9 November and in force from 10 November 2020, was brokered by Vladimir Putin. Azerbaijan kept the ground it had won, including the historic town of Shusha, Armenian forces withdrew from the surrounding districts, and about 2,000 Russian peacekeepers deployed along the remaining line and the Lachin corridor, the only road linking the region to Armenia.

Official figures put military deaths at about 3,800 on the Armenian side and about 2,900 on the Azerbaijani side. Armenian authorities reported that around 90,000 people, more than half the region's population, had been displaced by late October, while Azerbaijan said about 40,000 of its citizens had been forced from their homes by shelling.

Why Armenians spoke of genocide

For Armenians, Turkey's role made the war feel like more than a border dispute. Between 1915 and 1923 the Ottoman Empire carried out the Armenian Genocide, in which up to 1.5 million Armenians were killed through massacres and death marches. It is one of the best-documented atrocities of the twentieth century. As of 2026 more than 30 states recognise it as genocide, including the United States, whose Congress voted in 2019 and whose president used the word in April 2021. Turkey still rejects the term and describes the deaths as a wartime tragedy.

In 2020 the same state that denies 1915 was supplying Azerbaijan with military advisers and the armed drones that proved decisive on the battlefield. Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan framed the war in existential terms in early October, saying of the forces attacking Artsakh: "Their key target is the Armenian nation."

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, for his part, presented the war as Azerbaijan taking back its land and declared: "Armenia must withdraw from the places it occupies." To Armenians that sounded like a demand that people whose families had lived in Karabakh for generations should leave or live under a government they did not trust.

The Syrian fighters

A further source of alarm was the arrival of Syrian fighters. Reports from journalists, monitoring groups and several governments said Turkey had helped transfer members of the Syrian National Army, including the Hamza Division, to fight for Azerbaijan. Baku denied using foreign fighters, but the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights documented at least 541 Syrian fighters killed in the war. Military analysts described them as expendable first-wave assault troops. We reported on the claims made by France's President Macron and Syria's government as they emerged. Several of these factions had been accused of abuses against civilians in northern Syria, so Armenians feared what would happen if such groups reached Armenian villages.

What happened next: the 2023 exodus

The 2020 ceasefire did not settle the conflict. In December 2022 Azerbaijan began blocking the Lachin corridor, leaving about 120,000 residents short of food, fuel, electricity and medicine for months. On 19 September 2023 Azerbaijan launched a new offensive. The local authorities accepted a ceasefire mediated by Russian peacekeepers the next day and agreed to disarm.

What followed was one of the fastest population movements in recent European history. By 3 October 2023 Armenia had registered more than 100,000 refugees, close to the entire Armenian population of the region. At least 170 people died in a fuel depot explosion near Stepanakert as families queued for petrol to leave. On 28 September the region's president, Samvel Shahramanyan, signed a decree to dissolve its institutions by 1 January 2024, although he later questioned its validity from exile.

Armenia and genocide-prevention groups such as the Lemkin Institute described the exodus as ethnic cleansing, and some experts argued the months-long blockade already met the definition of genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention. Azerbaijan rejected these claims and said Armenians were free to stay as citizens. In November 2023 the International Court of Justice ordered Azerbaijan to allow the safe return of anyone who wished to go back and to protect those who remained.

Reading the 2020 warnings today

Looking back, the fears voiced in October 2020 were not simply wartime rhetoric. They rested on a real history of mass violence, on a hostile neighbour's open support for the offensive, and on the vulnerability of a small, landlocked population with one road to safety. They did not come true in the form of mass killings in 2020, but within three years the Armenian presence in Karabakh, which had lasted for many centuries, had all but ended.

For readers trying to make sense of the conflict, a few points help:

  • Both peoples have suffered. Azerbaijanis were expelled from Karabakh and the surrounding districts in the 1990s, and Azerbaijani civilians died in 2020. Recognising that does not erase what happened to Armenians.
  • Genocide denial matters. Turkey's refusal to acknowledge 1915 shaped how Armenians read every Turkish statement in 2020.
  • Ceasefires are not settlements. The 2020 deal ended the shooting but left the most important question, the security of Karabakh's Armenians, unanswered.
  • Displacement can be quiet. Ethnic cleansing does not always involve massacres; a blockade followed by a brief offensive emptied the region in about a week.

Sources: Wikipedia: Second Nagorno-Karabakh War; Wikipedia: 2023 Azerbaijani offensive in Nagorno-Karabakh; Wikipedia: Armenian genocide recognition; WorldAtlas: What happened to Nagorno-Karabakh?; statements by Nikol Pashinyan (3 October 2020) and Recep Tayyip Erdoğan as reported by The American Conservative. Photo: Nicolas Economou/NurPhoto via Getty Images.

COMMENTS