Originally published 2020-10-11.

In October 2020 the commander of US Transportation Command (TRANSCOM), Army Gen. Stephen R. Lyons, announced that his command would work with SpaceX and a small engineering firm, Exploration Architecture Corp., to study whether rockets could deliver military cargo anywhere on Earth in about an hour. It was not a contract to build a "military rocket". It was a no-cost research agreement to test an idea: that a reusable rocket such as SpaceX's Starship might one day do in minutes what a cargo plane does in half a day.
The idea has moved forward since then, but slowly and with plenty of unanswered questions. Here is what was actually agreed, how rocket cargo would work, which popular claims about it were wrong, and where the programme stands now.
What TRANSCOM and SpaceX agreed in 2020
Lyons made the announcement on 7 October 2020 at an event of the National Defense Transportation Association, as reported by Air & Space Forces Magazine (then Air Force Magazine). The agreements were cooperative research and development agreements, known as CRADAs. Under a CRADA, the government and a company share data and expertise, but no money changes hands.
The goal was to work out the technical and cost issues, as well as the "legal, diplomatic, statutory and regulatory" hurdles, of using space as a transport route. Lyons summed up the ambition in one line: "Think about moving the equivalent of a C-17 payload anywhere on the globe in less than an hour." He also suggested a first demonstration might be possible as early as 2021, a date that turned out to be far too optimistic.
SpaceX was the obvious partner. Founded by Elon Musk in 2002, it had become the first company to land an orbital rocket's first stage back on Earth, with a Falcon 9 in December 2015, and began re-flying landed boosters in 2017. Reusability is what makes the rocket cargo idea thinkable at all, because throwing away a rocket for each delivery would be absurdly expensive.
How point-to-point rocket delivery would work
The concept is sometimes called point-to-point transport. A rocket would launch from one site, climb above the atmosphere on a sub-orbital arc, and come back down near its destination, landing on its own engines. Starship, the vehicle the military had in mind, is designed to land vertically, so in theory it would not need a runway.
The speed advantage comes from the trajectory. Once a vehicle is above most of the atmosphere, there is very little air resistance, so it can travel several kilometres per second. That is why planners talk about crossing an ocean in roughly half an hour. Back in 2018, then Air Mobility Command chief Gen. Carlton Everhart described cargo drops in about 30 minutes instead of 10 hours.
In practice, delivery time would be longer than flight time. Cargo has to be loaded, the rocket fuelled and checked, a launch window secured, and a safe landing zone prepared at the other end. A rocket that crosses the Pacific in 40 minutes still depends on a lot of work on the ground.
Rocket versus C-17: checking the numbers
Many articles in 2020 compared rockets with the Boeing C-17 Globemaster III, the backbone of US military airlift. Some of those comparisons were off, so here are the figures from reliable references:
- Payload. A C-17 can carry up to about 77.5 tonnes (170,900 lb), not the 35 tonnes often quoted. SpaceX says Starship's reusable design is meant to lift 100 to 150 tonnes to low Earth orbit, though a sub-orbital cargo version's real capacity has not been demonstrated.
- Speed. A C-17 cruises at about 520 mph (830 km/h). A flight from California to Japan takes around 11 to 12 hours, depending on winds and refuelling.
- Flexibility. The C-17 can land on short, rough runways and has flown since 1991, with 279 built. Its reliability is proven over decades; a rocket cargo service is not.
The honest summary is that rockets could be dramatically faster on long routes, but aircraft remain cheaper, more flexible and able to carry bulky loads without exotic infrastructure.
Common myths about rocket cargo
"Rockets don't need anyone's permission to fly over other countries"
This was widely claimed but is not settled. International law has never clearly defined where airspace ends and outer space begins, and a sub-orbital flight passes through national airspace on the way up and down. That is exactly why TRANSCOM listed legal and diplomatic questions among the hurdles to study. Launching a large rocket towards another country's territory also raises an obvious risk of it being mistaken for a missile.
"They would be impossible to shoot down"
A vehicle at high altitude and speed is hard to intercept, but it is most vulnerable during landing, when it is slow and predictable. The landing site itself would need protection, which adds to the logistics burden.
"Musk was handed a huge military contract"
In 2020 there was no money involved. Funding came later and on a modest scale by defence standards, as described below. Critics are right that public money should be spent carefully at a time of economic pressure; the fair debate is about value and priorities, not a sudden windfall.
What has happened since
In June 2021 the Air Force Research Laboratory (AFRL) made Rocket Cargo one of its high-priority "Vanguard" programmes, working with the Space Force and TRANSCOM. In January 2022 AFRL awarded SpaceX a five-year contract worth $102 million to collect data from commercial launches and landings, design a cargo bay that fits military containers, study landing on different types of ground and demonstrate heavy cargo launch and landing. Program manager Greg Spanjers called it a "big-bet" science and technology investment.
Other companies joined the effort. TRANSCOM signed similar no-cost agreements with Blue Origin, Sierra Space and Rocket Lab. By 2024 the work was moving to the Space Force as a prototype effort called Point-to-Point Delivery, with a small first budget of $4 million in the fiscal 2025 request. Planners were focusing on ways to release cargo from a spacecraft by airdrop, rather than only landing the whole vehicle.
Starship itself had a bumpy road. Its first full test flight in April 2023 ended in an explosion, but by October 2024 SpaceX had caught a returning booster with the launch tower arms. A working cargo service still requires a reliable, frequent ship that can land where the military needs it.
Why the military wants this, and the open questions
The appeal is simple: in a crisis, hours matter. Rapid delivery of medical supplies, spare parts or disaster relief kits to a remote location could save lives, and defence officials have said they are considering longer-term arrangements for rapid emergency response alongside military logistics. Officials have also talked about eventually buying rocket delivery as a commercial service, much as the Space Force already buys launches.
The open questions are just as clear. How much would each flight cost compared with an aircraft? Can a rocket land safely near a front line or a disaster zone? Who grants permission for the flight path? Until those are answered, rocket cargo remains a promising experiment rather than a delivery service, and the C-17 is not going anywhere soon.
Sources: Air & Space Forces Magazine, 7 October 2020: DOD, SpaceX may soon prove the military can ship cargo through space; Defense News, 20 January 2022: AFRL partners with SpaceX to explore rocket cargo potential; Breaking Defense, March 2024: Rocket cargo moves closer to the launch pad; Wikipedia: Boeing C-17 Globemaster III; Wikipedia: SpaceX Starship; Wikipedia: Falcon 9. Gen. Stephen R. Lyons quoted from his 7 October 2020 remarks.

COMMENTS