Face Transplant Recipient Cameron Underwood's Remarkable Recovery

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-06-12.

A Face-Transplant Recipient's Recovery Reported in 2022

In January 2018, surgeons at NYU Langone Health in New York gave Cameron Underwood, a 26-year-old man from Yuba City, California, a new face in an operation that lasted about 25 hours. Less than a year later, the hospital reported that he had returned home, was living independently with monthly check-ups and had shown no signs of rejection. His case set several records and shows how far face transplantation has come since the first partial procedure in 2005.

Who is Cameron Underwood?

In June 2016 Underwood survived a self-inflicted gunshot wound that destroyed much of his lower and middle face. Earlier reconstructive operations saved his life but could not rebuild what was lost: he had no nose, was missing most of his lower jaw and had only one tooth left. Eating, speaking clearly and simply going out in public had become daily struggles.

He was accepted into the face transplant programme led by plastic surgeon Dr Eduardo Rodriguez and placed on the national waiting list in July 2017. A suitable donor was found about six months later, which NYU Langone described as one of the shortest waits on record.

If you are struggling with thoughts of suicide, please reach out. In the United States you can call or text 988 to reach the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline; elsewhere, contact local emergency services or a crisis line in your country.

The donor: William Fisher

The new face came from William Fisher, a 23-year-old Manhattan resident who studied at Johns Hopkins University and was, according to the hospital, a chess champion and an aspiring writer and filmmaker. He had registered as an organ donor in his teens. After his death, his mother agreed to the face donation, and his heart, liver, kidneys and eyes were donated as well.

The New York organ procurement organisation LiveOnNY identified Fisher as a possible donor on 31 December 2017. For his family, the surgical team made a 3D-printed mask so that his appearance could be restored for his funeral, a first in face transplantation.

Underwood later spoke warmly of the gift. Thanking the family, he said: "Will and his family made an incredible sacrifice to give back to me what had been lost."

Inside the 25-hour operation

The surgery began on 5 January 2018 and continued into the next day, involving more than 100 doctors, nurses and other staff. The team rehearsed it beforehand using 3D computer models of both men's skulls. During the operation they relied on custom 3D-printed cutting guides, navigation systems that track instruments in real time, and CT scans taken in the operating room to check that bones lined up as planned.

Underwood received a great deal more than skin. The transplant included:

  • the upper and lower jawbones, complete with all 32 teeth and gums;
  • the roof and floor of the mouth;
  • the lower eyelids, cheeks, nose and parts of the nasal passages.

His own tongue stayed in place, though it needed reconstruction, and his upper eyelids were preserved. According to NYU Langone, the operation took more than 11 hours less than Rodriguez's first face transplant in 2012.

Recovery after eleven months

Underwood left hospital on 16 February 2018, weeks ahead of schedule, and moved to a nearby apartment for outpatient physical, occupational and speech therapy, plus several months of orthodontic work. He flew home to California on 29 March. His total hospital stay was 37 days, down from 62 for the hospital's previous face transplant patient.

When NYU Langone presented his progress in November 2018, he had not had a single rejection episode. He still travels to New York every month for follow-up checks, and he will need anti-rejection medicines for life.

Transplant surgeon Dr Bruce Gelb credited a new donor-matching approach and drug regimen, saying: "We are thrilled that Cameron is responding so well to the transplant." The hospital also highlighted the roughly 18 months between injury and transplant, the shortest such gap in the US at the time; Rodriguez has said acting earlier spares patients a long psychological burden.


A short history of face transplants

Face transplantation is still rare. Roughly 50 have been performed worldwide. Some milestones:

  • 2005, France: Isabelle Dinoire received the first partial face transplant (nose, lips and chin) in Amiens.
  • 2008, United States: Connie Culp received a near-total face transplant at the Cleveland Clinic.
  • 2010, Spain: surgeons in Barcelona carried out the first full face transplant.
  • 2012 and 2015: Rodriguez led transplants for Richard Norris in Maryland and for former firefighter Patrick Hardison at NYU Langone, the latter long described as the most extensive on record.
  • 2017: Katie Stubblefield, who had also survived a gunshot wound, became the youngest US recipient at 21 after a 31-hour operation at the Cleveland Clinic.

Risks, costs and the psychological side

A face transplant is not cosmetic surgery. Recipients must take immunosuppressive drugs for the rest of their lives, which raises the risk of serious infections, kidney damage and some cancers. Rejection remains a constant possibility, and at least four recipients worldwide have died from complications linked to the procedure.

The emotional adjustment can be just as hard. Living with a face that once belonged to someone else raises questions about identity, and teams screen candidates carefully and provide long-term psychological support. Researchers still debate how best to measure quality of life after the operation, and many argue that patients' own experiences should guide the field.

Money matters too. Most early US face transplants were funded by research grants, largely from the Department of Defense, because of interest in treating wounded soldiers. Underwood's case was notable because much of the cost was covered by his private, employer-based health insurance.

Why organ donation matters

None of this is possible without donors and their families. Fisher's decision as a teenager helped several people, and his family's agreement to the face donation gave Underwood a chance to eat, speak and live without constant stares. If you would like to become a donor, you can register through your national donor registry and, just as importantly, tell your family about your wishes. Questions about your own health or eligibility are best discussed with a doctor.

Sources: NYU Langone Health press release (November 2018); IFLScience; Face transplant (Wikipedia).

COMMENTS