Austin Stevens Case: Father Convicted of Killing Baby Zara Scruggs

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-12.

Pennsylvania Father Charged in Death of His 10-Month-Old Daughter

Austin Stevens, a 29-year-old father from Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, was arrested in October 2020 and charged with sexually assaulting and killing his 10-month-old daughter, Zara Scruggs. In March 2022 a jury found him guilty of first-degree murder and involuntary deviate sexual intercourse after deliberating for about 90 minutes, and a judge sentenced him to life in prison the same day.

The case drew national attention because of what investigators found on his phone: before calling for help, he had searched online for how to tell whether a baby is dead. Below is a clear account of what happened, what the evidence showed in court, and how the case ended.

What happened to Zara Scruggs

Zara was in her father's care at his apartment in Collegeville, a borough in Montgomery County outside Philadelphia, over the weekend of 3 and 4 October 2020. Stevens and Zara's mother, Erica, shared custody of the baby.

On 4 October, Stevens called 911 to say his daughter was unwell. Paramedics responded, but Zara could not be saved. Doctors and later an autopsy found serious head trauma and signs of sexual abuse, injuries that did not fit the explanation Stevens gave.

Stevens told detectives Zara had fallen and hit her head in the bathtub. Investigators did not believe that account, and he was charged with murder, rape of a child and related offences. He was held on $1 million bail.

The phone searches and the delay in calling 911

Phone records became central to the case. According to prosecutors, Stevens searched phrases such as "what if baby stops breathing" and "how do you know if baby is dead" before he called emergency services. Data from his phone suggested he waited up to an hour between noticing something was badly wrong and dialling 911.

That gap mattered. For an injured infant, minutes can make the difference between life and death, and prosecutors argued that his failure to seek help was part of what killed her. Montgomery County District Attorney Kevin Steele, announcing the charges, said: "This case is deeply disturbing." He described the combination of an assault on an infant and a father's failure to act as the cause of her death.

Reporters who covered the arrest, including Christie Ileto of 6abc, highlighted those court records at the time, and the story spread quickly across national media.

Who Austin Stevens was

Before his arrest, Stevens was known locally as the owner of a small construction business and as a youth football coach in Lower Providence Township. People who knew him in those roles expressed shock, and the coaching link prompted questions from parents in the community.

Prosecutors told the court that when detectives interviewed him hours after Zara's death, he seemed calm and showed little emotion. That impression, while not proof of anything on its own, formed part of the picture the jury heard.

The trial and verdict

The case went to trial in Norristown in early March 2022, prosecuted by First Assistant District Attorney Edward McCann, who called Zara's death "a new level of horror."

The prosecution relied on three main strands of evidence:

  • Medical evidence from the autopsy, showing significant head trauma and sexual abuse.
  • His own account, which did not match those injuries.
  • Digital evidence from his phone, including the searches and the timing of the 911 call.

Stevens's defence lawyer, Evan Kelly, argued that there was no clear evidence of sexual assault and that Zara's death was a tragic accident. The jury rejected that argument within about an hour and a half, convicting him of first-degree murder and involuntary deviate sexual intercourse.

Montgomery County Court of Common Pleas Judge William Carpenter sentenced him to life in prison immediately after the verdict. Under Pennsylvania law, a first-degree murder conviction for an adult carries life without the possibility of parole. Stevens did not address the court.

Zara's family and the community

Zara's mother, Erica, wrote on social media soon after her daughter's death that she was not okay and had no words, and that she wanted him to answer for what he had done. Relatives set up a GoFundMe page in Zara's name to cover funeral costs and to support her mother through her grief, and within days it had raised tens of thousands of dollars.

The fundraiser described Zara as a beautiful little girl who deserved to grow up, and it asked people to remember her rather than the man who harmed her. That is worth repeating here: Zara Lynn Scruggs was ten months old, loved by her mother and her wider family, and her life should be the focus whenever this case is mentioned.

Recognising abuse and getting help

Cases like this are rare, but child abuse is not. Most harm to infants comes from someone they know, often a caregiver under stress, and babies cannot tell anyone what is happening to them. Some practical points that child-protection organisations stress:

  • Take injuries seriously. Bruises on a baby who is not yet crawling, unexplained swelling, or a story that does not fit the injury should be checked by a doctor.
  • Call emergency services first. If a baby is limp, not breathing normally or unresponsive, call 911 (or your local emergency number) straight away. Do not search online or wait to see if things improve.
  • Report concerns. In the US, the Childhelp National Child Abuse Hotline (1-800-422-4453) takes calls around the clock, and every state has a child-protection reporting line. You do not need proof to make a report.
  • Ask for help before reaching breaking point. Parents who feel overwhelmed can put a baby safely in the cot, step away, and call a friend, family member or helpline.

Nothing can undo what happened to Zara. The conviction means the man responsible will spend the rest of his life in prison, and her case remains a reminder that a delayed call for help can cost a child everything.

Sources: The Philadelphia Inquirer: Austin Stevens found guilty of murdering his daughter (4 March 2022); original report by Christie Ileto, 6abc; GoFundMe: Zara Lynn.

COMMENTS