Originally published 2020-10-02.
For centuries, a hillside cemetery beside the Aras River at Julfa (Djulfa, or Jugha in Armenian) held the largest collection of Armenian cross-stones ever recorded. Today nothing of it is visible. Between 1998 and December 2005 the monuments were broken up and removed, and by 2006 the site had been turned into a military shooting range. Researchers who spent decades photographing the region say the loss goes far beyond one graveyard: dozens of churches and tens of thousands of carved stones across Nakhichevan, the Azerbaijani exclave between Armenia, Iran and Turkey, have disappeared.

Left: medieval khachkars at Julfa, photographed by Argam Ayvazyan. Right: Ayvazyan, who spent years documenting Armenian monuments in Nakhichevan, beside a cross-stone (photo: Simon Maghakyan).
What a khachkar is and why Julfa mattered
A khachkar, literally "cross-stone", is a carved stone memorial bearing a cross, usually set above a rosette or sun disc and framed by vines, pomegranates and intricate interlace. The first true khachkars appeared in the ninth century, and the art form reached its height between the twelfth and fourteenth centuries. In 2010 UNESCO added khachkar symbolism and craftsmanship to its list of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity.
Julfa was a prosperous Armenian trading town on the routes between Persia and the wider world. Its cemetery grew over roughly seven centuries, with the oldest stones dating to the ninth or tenth century and burials continuing until 1605, when Shah Abbas I ordered the town emptied and its people deported to Persia. Many of the surviving markers were richly carved sixteenth-century stones for merchant families. When the French Jesuit Alexandre de Rhodes passed through in 1648, he reported around 10,000 well-preserved khachkars. Some 5,000 were still standing in the early 1900s.
How the cemetery was destroyed, step by step
The record of the destruction is unusually well documented, much of it filmed from across the river in Iran:
- 1998: About 2,700 khachkars remained. Armenia first raised the alarm after the Armenian filmmaker Arpiar Petrosyan recorded bulldozers working among the stones. UNESCO and ICOMOS appealed for the destruction to stop.
- 2002: A second wave of demolition left perhaps 2,000 stones intact. Armenian historians and archaeologists lodged a formal complaint that December.
- December 2005: Video shot by Bishop Nshan Topouzian of the Armenian diocese in Iran showed men in uniform smashing the remaining stones with sledgehammers and loading the pieces onto trucks; the fragments were reportedly dumped in the Aras.
- 2006: A journalist from the Institute for War and Peace Reporting found no visible trace of the cemetery, and photographs from the Iranian side showed a rifle range on the site.
- 2010: The American Association for the Advancement of Science compared satellite images from 2003 and 2009 and concluded the cemetery had likely been destroyed and later levelled by earth-moving equipment.
Attempts at independent inspection were repeatedly blocked. Members of the European Parliament were refused access in 2006, a planned visit by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe was cancelled in 2007, and in 2011 the US ambassador to Azerbaijan, Matthew Bryza, was not allowed to visit the site.
The wider loss across Nakhichevan
Julfa is the best-known case because it was so large and because the final stage was caught on camera. But a February 2019 investigation by Simon Maghakyan and Sarah Pickman, published in the art magazine Hyperallergic, described a much broader campaign between 1997 and 2006.
Their baseline came from Argam Ayvazyan, a Nakhichevan-born researcher who photographed and catalogued the region's Armenian heritage at his own expense between 1964 and 1987. His archive recorded 89 Armenian churches, 5,840 khachkars and 22,000 horizontal tombstones. According to the investigation, essentially all of them have since vanished. A 522-page encyclopedia of Nakhichevan's monuments issued in 2008 does not mention them at all.
It is worth being precise about these numbers, because they are often blurred together online. The 89 churches, 5,840 khachkars and 22,000 tombstones refer to the whole of Nakhichevan as documented by Ayvazyan, not to the Julfa cemetery alone; the cemetery itself held a few thousand stones by the 1990s. The destruction also happened mainly between 1997 and 2006, not in 2019, which is simply when the detailed investigation was published.
Azerbaijan's position
Azerbaijan has consistently rejected the accusations. In 1998 an official dismissed them as a lie spread by Armenians, and in April 2006 President Ilham Aliyev described the reports as false and slanderous. Officials have also argued that Armenians never lived in Nakhichevan, or that the monuments belonged to the ancient Caucasian Albanians rather than to Armenians. Historians point to the Armenian inscriptions on the stones, the town's well-recorded Armenian merchant community and centuries of travellers' accounts, and international heritage bodies have treated the stones as Armenian.
The researcher who made it his life's cause
Simon Maghakyan, an Armenian-American heritage researcher, has spent most of his adult life piecing together what happened in Nakhichevan using Ayvazyan's photographs, satellite imagery, travellers' records and testimony. Speaking to the Los Angeles Times in November 2019, he described the work in personal terms: "It's not a job, but it is my lifelong cause."
He compared the silence around Nakhichevan with the international outrage that followed the Taliban's dynamiting of the Bamiyan Buddhas in Afghanistan in 2001 and the destruction of sites by ISIS in Iraq and Syria in the mid-2010s, telling the paper: "This is worse than what ISIS did." He also linked it to the long denial of the Armenian Genocide of 1915, in which around 1.5 million Armenians were killed in the Ottoman Empire. With Nakhichevan, he said, there are photographs, satellite images and video: "Denial is not because they are unaware. They know what happened."
Why it still matters
This article first appeared in October 2020, when war over Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh to Armenians) had broken out again. Since then, the fear that Armenian churches and monuments in areas under Azerbaijani control could share Julfa's fate has only grown, particularly after Azerbaijan took full control of Nagorno-Karabakh in September 2023 and almost its entire Armenian population fled to Armenia. In December 2021 the International Court of Justice, in a case brought by Armenia, ordered Azerbaijan as a provisional measure to prevent and punish vandalism and desecration of Armenian cultural heritage.
Cultural heritage is more than stone. Gravestones carry names, dates, prayers and the artistic language of a community; erasing them erases evidence that people lived, worked and were mourned in a place. That is why scholars use the term "cultural genocide" for campaigns like this, and why careful documentation such as Ayvazyan's photographs, the 2005 video and the satellite studies matters so much. When the physical record is gone, the archive becomes the memory.
For readers who want to see what was lost, the photographs gathered by the Julfa Project and the khachkars that survive in Armenia itself, such as the large field at Noratus near Lake Sevan, give a sense of the craftsmanship that once covered the Julfa hillside.
Sources: Simon Maghakyan and Sarah Pickman, Hyperallergic, 18 February 2019: A Regime Conceals Its Erasure of Indigenous Armenian Culture; Wikipedia: Destruction of the Armenian cemetery in Julfa; Wikipedia: Khachkar. Photos: Argam Ayvazyan and Simon Maghakyan.

COMMENTS