Originally published 2020-09-09.

Two widely shared videos from the first weekend of September 2020 showed protest groups confronting people eating outdoors: one outside a restaurant in downtown Pittsburgh, the other in Rochester, New York, where tables were flipped and glasses smashed. In Pittsburgh, police later charged three people. Both incidents drew condemnation, including from people who supported the protests, and both were exceptions to a summer in which the great majority of Black Lives Matter demonstrations were peaceful.
Here is what the footage shows, what police and local reporters established afterwards, and the wider context of the 2020 protests.
What happened outside Sienna Mercato in Pittsburgh
On Saturday 5 September 2020, during a downtown march billed as "Civil Saturday", a small group broke away and stopped at the outdoor tables of Sienna Mercato, an Italian restaurant on Penn Avenue. Video posted the next day shows a man with a megaphone shouting at the diners, many of them older and white, and another man leaning in to yell an expletive-filled tirade blaming "white people" for the system he was protesting.
A woman in the group then picked up an elderly couple's beer and drank it. She later told local station KDKA the couple had given permission. The couple, who asked to stay anonymous, said they had not, and that she threw the glass on the ground afterwards. They said they had stayed quiet so things would not escalate.
PITTSBURGH PA pic.twitter.com/PxZGxpJIca
— Next POTUS - Dr RollerGator PhD Rt'd by DJT (@drrollergator) September 6, 2020
The couple's reaction was notable. They told reporters they support Black Lives Matter and did not want anyone jailed. What they wanted was accountability, an apology and the mess cleaned up. In their view, the group that harassed them did not represent the movement.
The McDonald's confrontation and the charges that followed
A second clip from the same afternoon, posted on Twitter on 8 September, showed members of the group arguing with a manager inside a McDonald's on Liberty Avenue. The manager, who is Black, stood his ground. That post has since been removed.
Pittsburgh has fallen.
— DEB-PLORABLE 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸 (@DebHaslam) September 8, 2020
BLM doesn’t care about black lives, as you can see here at this McDonald’s restaurant where they assaulted the manager...who is black.
Note how this manager doesn’t back down though either.#BLMTerroristThugs #EnoughIsEnough
pic.twitter.com/B4XeVEESg3
(This post is no longer available on X.)
Early reports said no one had been arrested, but that changed within days. Pittsburgh's Public Safety department called the videos embarrassing and opened an investigation, and police later charged three activists. According to court papers reported by KDKA, the charges included disorderly conduct, harassment, conspiracy, criminal mischief, trespass and, in the case of the woman who drank the beer, theft. Police also alleged that one man had struck a cyclist with the megaphone and that another had pounded a table hard enough to shatter a glass. As with any criminal case, those were allegations to be tested in court.
Rochester: tables flipped on Alexander Street
The Rochester incident happened a day earlier, on the night of 4 to 5 September. Protesters marching through the city's East End stopped at restaurants on Alexander Street. At Swan Dive, a protest organiser addressed the diners and told them to pay and leave. Across the street, at Ox and Stone, some people in the crowd flipped tables and smashed glasses in the outdoor dining area, sending customers scrambling.
(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)
Several East End restaurants closed early the next night ahead of further demonstrations. Notably, Ox and Stone, Swan Dive and another nearby business posted messages of support for the community afterwards, saying that the anger and hurt in the city could not be denied.
That same night police said they held back until bottles and rocks were thrown at officers, then used pepper spray, pepper balls and, for the first time in the Rochester protests, tear gas. Eleven people were arrested and three officers were hurt over the course of that night, according to Wikipedia's timeline of the protests.
Why Rochester was protesting: the death of Daniel Prude
Rochester's protests began on 2 September 2020, when Daniel Prude's family made public police body-camera footage from that March. Prude, a 41-year-old Black man in a mental health crisis, had been restrained naked in the street by officers on 23 March, with a "spit hood" over his head. He stopped breathing, was declared brain dead and died on 30 March. The county medical examiner ruled the death a homicide caused by complications of asphyxia in the setting of physical restraint, with excited delirium and acute PCP intoxication as contributing factors.
The months-long delay before the video came out fuelled anger. On 8 September the police chief and several senior commanders stepped down or were demoted. In February 2021 a grand jury declined to indict the officers involved.
How peaceful were the 2020 protests overall?
Clips like these spread fast, which can give a distorted picture. The best large-scale data come from the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project (ACLED), which ran a US monitoring project with Princeton University's Bridging Divides Initiative. Between 26 May and 22 August 2020 it recorded more than 7,750 demonstrations linked to Black Lives Matter in over 2,440 places across all 50 states and Washington, DC.
- More than 93% involved no violence or destructive activity by demonstrators.
- Violent incidents were concentrated in fewer than 220 locations.
- ACLED counted clashes, vandalism, looting and blocking roads with barricades as violent or destructive, even where police or others started the violence.
In other words, the Pittsburgh and Rochester videos document real misconduct, and the people targeted deserved better. But a short clip shows what a few people did, not the motives or behaviour of everyone at a larger demonstration. In both videos, other protesters can be seen arguing with those causing trouble.
The wider backdrop of summer 2020
The protests had grown after the murder of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer on 25 May 2020. Over the summer they were fed by further cases, including Daniel Prude's death and the police shooting of Jacob Blake in Kenosha, Wisconsin, on 23 August. Two nights later, during unrest in Kenosha, 17-year-old Kyle Rittenhouse shot and killed Joseph Rosenbaum and Anthony Huber and wounded Gaige Grosskreutz. He argued self-defence and was acquitted of all charges in November 2021.
With a presidential election weeks away, images of confrontation became political ammunition on all sides. That is a good reason to check the date, place and full context of any viral protest video before sharing it, and to look at what police and local reporters found once the dust settled.
Sources: KDKA/CBS Pittsburgh: three protesters charged after clash with diners on Penn Avenue; KDKA/CBS Pittsburgh: couple in viral video speaks out; WHEC News10NBC: Rochester protest turns violent overnight; WHEC News10NBC: Rochester restaurants close after damage; Wikipedia: Killing of Daniel Prude; ACLED: Demonstrations and political violence in America, summer 2020; Wikipedia: Kenosha unrest shooting. Videos: Twitter users @drrollergator and @DebHaslam.

COMMENTS