First published September 9, 2020.

The El Dorado Fire was started on the morning of 5 September 2020, when a smoke-generating pyrotechnic device set off during a gender-reveal photo shoot at El Dorado Ranch Park in Yucaipa, California, lit the dry grass around it. The family tried to put the flames out and called 911, but the fire escaped into the foothills of the San Bernardino Mountains. Over the next ten weeks it burned roughly 22,700 acres, destroyed homes, injured a dozen people and killed a veteran wildland firefighter, Charles Morton.
In the first days after ignition, news reports described a fire of about 8,600 acres, more than 3,000 evacuated residents and several hundred firefighters backed by aircraft. Those numbers were only the opening chapter. Below is the full story: what happened, how the case ended in court, why such small devices are so dangerous in a Californian September, and how to celebrate safely.
What happened at El Dorado Ranch Park
Yucaipa sits at the foot of the San Bernardino Mountains, east of Los Angeles. In early September 2020 Southern California was in the middle of a severe heat wave, and the grassland in and around the park had been dry for months. A couple and their family had gone there to take photos announcing the sex of their expected baby. The device they used produced coloured smoke; it was not a firework in the aerial sense, but it burned hot enough to ignite the grass.
According to Cal Fire, the group tried and failed to put the flames out, then called for help and cooperated with investigators. Captain Bennet Milloy of Cal Fire told reporters the family had hoped to remember the day differently, calling it "a tragedy". A neighbour put the problem in plainer terms to local television: the field was a meadow of dead, brown grass, and anything that produces heat there can start a fire.
How big the El Dorado Fire became
Within a day, evacuation orders covered Yucaipa, Oak Glen, Mountain Home Village and Forest Falls, and by 7 September they had reached parts of Riverside County. Governor Gavin Newsom declared a state of emergency. The fire climbed out of the foothills into the San Bernardino National Forest, south of Big Bear Lake, where steep terrain and heavy fuel made it hard to contain.
- Area burned: about 22,744 acres, or close to 36 square miles, across San Bernardino and Riverside counties.
- Buildings: five homes and 15 other structures destroyed, according to prosecutors.
- Injuries and deaths: a dozen or so injuries and one firefighter killed.
- Cost: more than $42 million to suppress.
- Duration: it reached its full size at the end of September but was not declared out until 16 November 2020. Some Forest Service areas stayed closed until April 2022.
Highway 38, the scenic route up to Big Bear, was closed for weeks. For residents of Angelus Oaks and Forest Falls, the evacuation lasted much of September.
The firefighter who died: Charles Morton
On 17 September 2020, flames overran a remote area where crews were cutting fire breaks. Charles "Charlie" Morton, 39, the squad boss of the Big Bear Interagency Hotshot Crew, was killed. He had spent 18 years as a firefighter, most of them with the US Forest Service.
Hotshot crews are the elite hand crews of American wildland firefighting. They hike into terrain that engines cannot reach and dig the containment lines that eventually stop a fire. Morton's death turned a story that had been widely shared as a bizarre accident into a case about criminal responsibility.
Charges, pleas and sentencing
In July 2021 the San Bernardino County District Attorney charged the couple, Refugio Manuel Jimenez Jr. and Angela Renee Jimenez, with involuntary manslaughter and a long list of other felony and misdemeanour counts linked to the fire and the damaged property. Both pleaded not guilty. Defence motions to dismiss were mostly rejected over the next two years.
The case ended with plea agreements in February 2024. Refugio Jimenez pleaded guilty to one felony count of involuntary manslaughter and two felony counts of recklessly causing a fire to an inhabited structure. He was sentenced to one year in county jail, two years of felony probation and community service. Angela Jimenez pleaded guilty to three misdemeanour counts of recklessly causing a fire to property and received one year of summary probation and community service. The couple were ordered to pay about $1.79 million in restitution.
The outcome matters beyond one family. It confirmed that in California, carelessly starting a wildfire can lead to manslaughter charges when someone dies fighting it, even when nobody meant any harm.
Not the first gender-reveal wildfire
The best-known earlier case is the Sawmill Fire in Arizona. In April 2017 an off-duty US Border Patrol agent, Dennis Dickey, shot at a target packed with the explosive Tannerite and blue powder at a gender-reveal gathering in Coronado National Forest, south of Tucson. The blast lit the grass and the fire burned about 47,000 acres before it was contained a week later. Around 400 people were evacuated, and suppression cost about $8.2 million.
That case is often misreported. Dickey pleaded guilty to a misdemeanour of starting a fire without a permit and received five years of probation, but the restitution he was ordered to pay was $220,000, not the full $8 million cost of fighting the fire.
Other gender-reveal stunts have killed people directly: an exploding device in Iowa in 2019, a homemade device in New York in 2021, and small planes that crashed during reveals in Mexico in 2021 and 2023. Jenna Karvunidis, the blogger often credited with starting the trend in 2008, has said she regrets how extreme it became and, after the El Dorado Fire, asked people to stop holding these events.
Why people start most wildfires
It is easy to treat this fire as a freak event, but it fits a clear pattern. A study led by Jennifer Balch of the University of Colorado Boulder, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences in 2017, analysed two decades of US wildfire records and found that people started 84% of wildfires. Human ignitions also tripled the length of the fire season, because they happen in months and places where lightning rarely strikes. The figure of about 80% often quoted for California fits that national picture.
Most of these fires are accidents: sparks from vehicles and equipment, dragging chains, power lines, campfires, debris burning and fireworks. In late summer, after months without rain, dead grass can ignite from a few seconds of contact with something hot. A smoke canister does not need to explode to be dangerous; its heat alone is enough.
Celebrating without starting a fire
Nothing about a reveal requires a flame. Some simple ways to keep the surprise and lose the risk:
- Use a cake, coloured balloons, confetti cannons powered by compressed air, or a painted sign.
- Check local fire restrictions before using any pyrotechnics, including smoke devices and sparklers. In dry seasons they are often banned outright on public land.
- If something does catch fire, call emergency services immediately rather than spending minutes trying to beat it out.
- Remember liability: in the US, the person who starts a fire can be billed for the cost of fighting it and prosecuted if people are hurt.
The family in Yucaipa called for help and stayed to cooperate, and the result was still a death, lost homes and years in court. That is the most useful lesson of the El Dorado Fire: in fire weather, the safest celebration is one with no ignition source at all.
Sources: Wikipedia: El Dorado Fire; FOX 11 Los Angeles / AP: couple charged with involuntary manslaughter (July 2021); Wikipedia: Sawmill Fire (2017); Wikipedia: Gender reveal party; University of Colorado Boulder: Balch et al., PNAS 2017, on human-started wildfires; ABC7 Los Angeles: local reaction.

COMMENTS