Originally published 2020-06-04.
At the end of May 2020, during protests in Louisville, Kentucky, over the police killing of Breonna Taylor, local photographer Tim Druck photographed a row of white protesters, many of them women, standing shoulder to shoulder between officers and Black demonstrators. The picture spread fast because it showed, in one frame, an idea that was being argued about across the country: that people with less to fear from police could physically use that position to protect others.
This article explains what the photo shows, how the line came about, why Louisville was protesting, and what later happened in the cases that drove so much of the anger that summer.
How the human barrier formed
According to Druck's account, the line formed after Chanelle Helm, an organiser with Black Lives Matter Louisville, called on white demonstrators to step forward and put themselves between the police and the Black protesters around them. Druck said people did not need persuading; they moved into place almost at once.
When he shared the image online, his caption described the row as white people forming a barrier between Black protesters and the police, and ended with two lines that became part of the story: This is love. This is what you do with your privilege.
In a later interview with the Louisville Courier-Journal, he described the response as willing and enthusiastic, saying the request was simply for white participants to use their bodies as a buffer.
The photograph was soon shared by local and regional outlets, including Kentucky Now, whose post is embedded below.
What one photo can and cannot tell us
A single image freezes a few seconds of a long night. It cannot tell us every person's motive, how long the line held, or what happened elsewhere in the crowd. What it does document is a deliberate, organised tactic. Similar "white allies to the front" lines were reported at other protests in 2020, and they drew both praise and criticism. Supporters saw a practical act of solidarity. Some activists argued that such gestures can turn attention toward white participants rather than the Black protesters whose safety and demands were the point. Both views help explain why the picture still sparks discussion.
(The Facebook post originally embedded here is no longer available.)
(The Facebook post originally embedded here is no longer available.)
Who Breonna Taylor was and how she died
Breonna Taylor was a 26-year-old emergency room technician at University of Louisville Health and a former emergency medical technician. Shortly after midnight on 13 March 2020, Louisville Metro Police officers forced their way into her apartment while serving a warrant connected to a drug investigation. The main target of that investigation was a former boyfriend of hers, Jamarcus Glover, who did not live there. No drugs were found in the apartment.
Taylor's boyfriend, Kenneth Walker, said he heard no announcement and believed intruders were breaking in. He fired one shot, hitting Sergeant Jonathan Mattingly in the leg. Officers returned 32 rounds. Taylor was struck by five or six bullets; her death certificate lists five gunshot wounds. Charges against Walker were dropped in May 2020 and later dismissed permanently.
This is Breonna Taylor.
— Kristen Clarke ☎️866-OUR-VOTE (@KristenClarkeJD) May 12, 2020
She was a beloved Louisville EMT and a nurse who was fatally shot by police in her own home. She was hit 8X after cops entered w/o announcing themselves. A frontline worker, she was just 26 yrs old. Her family deserves justice.#SayHerName #BreonnaTaylor pic.twitter.com/oMrYUDQfR9
The tweet above, from civil rights lawyer Kristen Clarke, reflects how the case was described in early coverage. Some details shifted as investigations went on. Taylor is often called a nurse, but her job was ER technician. Reports of eight hits were also common at first, while the official record points to five.
Two common misunderstandings
"Police went to the wrong address." This was widely repeated, but it is not accurate. The warrant named Taylor's apartment. The deeper problem, according to federal prosecutors, was that the affidavit used to obtain it contained a false claim that a postal inspector had verified suspicious packages going there.
"It was a no-knock raid." A judge had approved a no-knock warrant, but reporting by The New York Times found the officers were told to knock and announce instead. Police say they did so; Walker said he heard nothing of the kind. That dispute is why many people still describe it as a no-knock case, and why no-knock warrants became the focus of reform.
Ben Crump, the lawyer for Taylor's family, framed Walker's shot as an act of self-defence against what he believed was a burglary, and asked in a USA Today opinion piece whether Black Americans can count on the same right to defend their homes that others take for granted.
A post shared by Muchacha Fanzine (@muchachafanzine) on
Why the country was already on edge
Louisville's protests grew alongside the national wave that began in Minneapolis on 26 May 2020, the day after George Floyd was murdered by a police officer. Another case had already shocked many Americans that month: the killing of Ahmaud Arbery.
Arbery, a 25-year-old Black man, was out running near Brunswick, Georgia, on 23 February 2020 when three white men chased him down. Gregory McMichael and his son Travis pursued him in a pickup truck, and a neighbour, William "Roddie" Bryan, joined in and filmed Travis McMichael shooting him. No one was arrested until the video went public on 5 May, more than two months later.
(The Instagram post originally embedded here is no longer available.)
Polls in the summer of 2020 suggested that somewhere between 15 and 26 million people in the US took part in demonstrations at some point, which would make it one of the largest protest movements in the country's history. Crowds were noticeably mixed in race and age, and many people joined marches against police brutality for the first time.
A movement that crossed borders
Solidarity protests spread to more than 2,000 towns and cities in over 60 countries, despite the risks of gathering during the coronavirus pandemic. There were large rallies in London and Paris, and demonstrations outside US embassies in several countries, including Greece, where a march in Athens ended with clashes near the embassy.
It is also worth correcting a common impression from that summer. Some protests did turn destructive, and those scenes dominated a lot of television coverage. But the Armed Conflict Location and Event Data Project estimated that about 93% of US demonstrations between late May and late August 2020 were peaceful and caused no damage.
What happened in the Taylor and Arbery cases
Policy changes in Louisville. On 11 June 2020, the Louisville Metro Council unanimously passed "Breonna's Law," which banned no-knock warrants in the city and requires officers to have body cameras running while serving warrants. In September 2020, the city agreed to pay Taylor's family $12 million, without admitting wrongdoing.
The officers. A state grand jury indicted only one officer, Brett Hankison, and only for shots that went into a neighbour's apartment; he was acquitted of those charges in March 2022. No one was charged by the state with causing Taylor's death. In August 2022 the US Justice Department brought federal civil rights charges against Hankison and against officers involved in obtaining the warrant. One of them, Kelly Goodlett, pleaded guilty to conspiracy. After a first trial ended in a mistrial, a federal jury convicted Hankison in November 2024 of violating Taylor's civil rights, and in July 2025 he was sentenced to 33 months in prison. Myles Cosgrove, the officer who fired the fatal shot, was fired by the department in January 2021.
The Arbery killing. On 24 November 2021, a Georgia jury convicted all three men of murder. The McMichaels were sentenced to life without parole and Bryan to life with the possibility of parole after 30 years. In February 2022, a federal jury also found all three guilty of hate crimes.
Why the photo still matters
The Louisville image endures because it shows protest as a choice made by ordinary people in the moment. Whether you see it as a model of allyship or as a reminder of how unequal the risks of protest can be, it captures a real question from 2020: what people who are less likely to be harmed by police owe to those who are more likely to be.
If you want to go further, the most useful steps are local ones: following how your own police department handles warrants and use of force, attending city council meetings where those policies are set, and reading primary sources such as court records rather than relying on viral summaries.
Sources: Photo by Tim Druck; Kentucky Now (embedded post); Wikipedia, Killing of Breonna Taylor; Murder of Ahmaud Arbery; George Floyd protests.
COMMENTS