Woman Tased at Ohio School Football Game After Refusing a Mask

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-27.

The 2020 Ohio Football-Game Arrest Over a Mask Dispute

On the evening of Wednesday 23 September 2020, a woman who refused to wear a face mask at a school football game in Logan, Ohio, was tased by a police officer, handcuffed and led out of the stadium. The woman, later identified as Alecia Kitts, the parent of a visiting player from Marietta, was charged with criminal trespassing and resisting arrest. A year later she entered a plea in Hocking County Municipal Court and was fined. Videos of the confrontation were viewed hundreds of thousands of times and became one of the most argued-over clips of the pandemic.

Below is what the record shows, how the school and police explained their actions, how the case ended, and why the clip divided people so sharply.

What happened at the stadium

The game was a seventh- and eighth-grade contest between Logan and Marietta middle schools, played at Logan High School's stadium. Early reports, including the first version of this article, described it as a high school game, but local news and NBC News later made clear it was a middle school fixture.

A school resource officer from the Logan Police Department approached Ms Kitts in the stands and asked her to wear a mask, which the venue required. She told him she had asthma and would not put one on. When she declined to leave, he moved to arrest her. In the footage she can be heard insisting she had done nothing criminal and shouting Get off of me! I will not put my hands behind my back. After a struggle, the officer used his Taser on her back, handcuffed her and walked her out.

Viewers noted that a mask appeared to be tucked in her back pocket as she was escorted away. Another woman in the stands was charged with obstruction. Some reports also claimed that she and a companion were the only spectators without masks in a crowd of a few hundred, a detail that could not be independently confirmed.

Why masks were required

At the time, Ohio had a statewide order requiring face coverings in indoor public places, and outdoors where people could not keep their distance. It had been in force since 23 July 2020, and a separate state health order covering schools took effect on 4 August. Like most mask orders of that period, Ohio's allowed exceptions for some medical conditions, which is why disputes like this one often turned on a claimed exemption.

Logan-Hocking Superintendent Monte Bainter said the spectator had been asked to follow Ohio High School Athletic Association and facility rules, refused, and was then asked to leave; the officer stepped in after she resisted. An athletic director quoted by the Marietta Times, Theresa Schultheiss, reportedly said that everyone entering had been reminded of the mask rule at the gate, over the public address system and through signs.

The charges and how the case ended

The Logan Police Department stressed that she was not charged for refusing a mask. The original charge was criminal trespassing, for refusing to leave a school facility after being told to, and she was released at the scene. Police said further charges were pending, and she was later also charged with resisting arrest. She declined medical treatment. In its statement the department called it an unfortunate incident for everyone involved.

On 21 September 2021, a week before her trial date, Ms Kitts entered a plea to both charges in Hocking County Municipal Court; local reports described it as a no contest plea. She was fined $200 for resisting arrest and $150 for criminal trespassing, plus court costs.

A clip that split the country

The footage, filmed by spectators, spread across Facebook, YouTube and Twitter within hours. One Facebook upload passed 440,000 views by the following day, according to NBC News.

Reactions followed the same lines as the wider mask debate. Some viewers saw a parent being punished far too harshly over a piece of cloth, and asked why a Taser was needed at a children's game. Others saw someone who refused a simple rule that everyone else was following, then refused to leave and resisted arrest. Political commentators used the video to make broader points about pandemic restrictions.

The anger did not stay online. The day after the game, Logan-Hocking schools were placed on lockdown because of threats that police believed were linked to the incident, a reminder of how quickly viral outrage can affect people who had nothing to do with the original event.

What the video can and cannot tell us

A short phone clip captures a moment, not the whole story. It shows the confrontation and the use of force, but it cannot establish a person's medical condition, what was said before filming began, or whether the force used met police policy. Those questions belong to the courts and to any review of the officer's conduct.

Some lessons do hold up:

  • Rules at private and school venues are enforceable through trespass law. Being asked to leave and refusing is a separate issue from the rule that prompted the request.
  • Escalation rarely helps anyone. Leaving when asked, then challenging the rule or the officer's conduct through a complaint or the courts, avoids injury and extra charges.
  • Medical exemptions are best sorted out in advance. Anyone who believes a health condition affects what they can wear or do should talk to a doctor and contact the venue before the event.
  • Use of force deserves scrutiny. Many people questioned whether a Taser was proportionate in a crowded stand with children present. That debate is legitimate whatever one thinks of masks.

Common myths about the case

"She was arrested for not wearing a mask." Police said the charges were for refusing to leave and for resisting arrest, not for the mask itself.

"It was a high school game." It was a middle school game held at a high school stadium.

"Nothing came of it." The case went to court, ending in fines about a year later.

Years on, the clip still circulates without context. Knowing the date, the rules in force and how the case was resolved makes it easier to judge fairly, whichever side of the argument you were on in 2020.

Sources: NBC News: Woman tasered after refusing to wear face mask at Ohio school football game; WSAZ: Marietta woman pleads in mask refusal case. Videos via YouTube uploaders as embedded.

COMMENTS