Why Kim Jong Un Apologised for Killing a South Korean Official

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-27.

Kim Jong Un Apologises for Killing of South Korean Official

Left: masked North Korean soldiers at Panmunjom on 16 September 2020 (Getty Images/Park Tae-hyun-Korea). Right: North Korean leader Kim Jong Un (Getty Images/Pyeongyang Press Corps).

In September 2020 North Korean troops shot dead a South Korean fisheries official who had drifted into Northern waters, and then burned either his body or the float he was clinging to. Three days later Kim Jong Un sent a rare apology to South Korea, saying he felt deeply sorry for the disappointment the killing had caused President Moon Jae-in and the South Korean people. It was one of the very few times a North Korean leader had openly said sorry to Seoul.

This article explains what happened at sea, how the two Koreas' accounts differed, why the apology was so unusual, and what followed.

What happened in the Yellow Sea

The victim was a 47-year-old official of South Korea's fisheries ministry, not the minister himself as some early reports said. He worked aboard a government patrol vessel near Yeonpyeong Island, close to the disputed western sea border known as the Northern Limit Line, where his job was to keep fishing boats from straying north and to watch for illegal fishing.

He was reported missing on Monday, 21 September 2020. His shoes, wallet and notebook were left on the patrol boat, but his phone was gone. The next day, South Korean officials said, he was spotted floating in North Korean waters wearing a life jacket.

According to the South Korean military, North Korean sailors questioned him from a distance for several hours. That evening, troops wearing gas masks arrived and, after what Seoul described as an order from a superior authority, shot him dead.

Two different accounts

The two governments told different stories about what happened next.

South Korea's version

Seoul said North Korean troops poured oil on the man's body and set it alight in the water. It also said intelligence suggested he had told the North Koreans he wanted to defect, and that he may have been in financial trouble. His brother rejected this, insisting he was not the sort of person who would defect.

North Korea's version

Pyongyang's statement said soldiers had found an unidentified man who first said he was from the South, then stopped answering and seemed to try to escape. On the boat captain's orders, they fired about a dozen rounds. They said they then found blood but no body, and burned the floating object he had been on under emergency quarantine rules. The statement mentioned neither the defection claim nor any burning of a body.

The gap was never fully resolved, and the body was not recovered.

Kim Jong Un's unusual apology

On Friday, 25 September 2020, South Korea's national security director, Suh Hoon, read reporters a message from North Korea's United Front Department, the body that handles relations with the South. In it, Kim said he felt "deeply sorry" for giving President Moon and South Koreans a huge sense of disappointment, and called the incident unexpected and disgraceful.

That was remarkable. North Korea rarely admits fault for deadly incidents. It denied sinking the South Korean warship Cheonan in 2010, which killed 46 sailors, and has usually blamed others for clashes along the border. Seoul's office said the message was a prompt answer to its formal requests for an explanation, an expression of regret and a promise that it would not happen again.

The apology came shortly after a rare exchange of letters. Moon had written to Kim on 8 September and received a reply four days later, the first letters between the two leaders in around six months.

Why the pandemic mattered

North Korea claimed throughout 2020 to have no COVID-19 cases, a claim outside experts doubted. It sealed its border with China, through which almost all of its trade passes, and imposed some of the strictest quarantine rules in the world. Reports at the time said border units reportedly had orders to shoot people who crossed without permission.

Many analysts believe fear of the virus shaped what happened at sea. A man floating in from the South was treated as a potential source of infection, not just as an intruder, and the decision to burn whatever was left followed the regime's own quarantine logic. That does not excuse the killing, but it helps explain why soldiers chose such a brutal response to an unarmed person in the water.

Commentators such as British analyst Tom Fowdy, writing for the Russian state broadcaster RT, argued that the apology reflected how weak North Korea's position was: an economy squeezed by sanctions and the closed border, and little capacity to cope with an outbreak. Other analysts suggested Pyongyang wanted to keep the door open with Moon, who had championed reconciliation, and was waiting to see who would win the November 2020 US election.

Context: a tense border and a cooling relationship

The killing was believed to be the first time North Korean forces had killed a South Korean civilian since 2008, when a tourist was shot dead at the Mount Kumgang resort after wandering into a restricted area. That shooting led the South to suspend tours to the resort, and they never resumed.

Relations had warmed in 2018 and 2019, when Kim held summits with Moon and with US President Donald Trump. But by 2020 talks had stalled. North Korea carried out more than a dozen missile and rocket launches, and in June 2020 it blew up the joint liaison office in Kaesong that had symbolised the thaw.

Very little reliable information comes out of North Korea, which human rights groups consistently rank among the least free countries in the world. That information vacuum fuels constant rumours. Earlier in 2020, false reports even claimed Kim had died and that his sister was taking over.

What happened afterwards

The apology did not end the matter. On 30 October 2020, North Korea's state news agency said the blame rested first with the South for failing to control its own citizen, while repeating that Pyongyang had said sorry. Seoul's calls for a joint investigation reportedly went unanswered.

Inside South Korea the case became a political storm. Conservatives accused Moon's government of being too soft on the North and of rushing to label the victim a defector. After a change of government in 2022, South Korean authorities reversed the earlier conclusion that he had tried to defect, and the case led to investigations of former security officials, a sign of how contested the episode remained.

For the man's family, the most basic questions were never fully answered: why he went into the water, what he said to the North Korean sailors, and exactly how he died.

Sources: NPR: North Korean troops shoot dead South Korean man believed attempting to defect; NPR: Kim Jong Un says he's sorry that North Korean troops killed a South Korean man; Al Jazeera: North Korea blames Seoul for killing of fisheries official; photos by Getty Images.

COMMENTS