Rami Aman: Gaza Activists Charged by Hamas Over Zoom Call

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-26.

In April 2020 a young Gaza activist named Rami Aman hosted an online video call with Israelis to talk about peace. Within days he was in a Hamas jail. By September, Hamas military prosecutors had charged him and two fellow organisers with "weakening revolutionary spirit", and in October a military court handed down sentences before releasing them. The case became a small but telling example of how risky ordinary dialogue across the Gaza border can be.

Here is what happened, why Hamas treated a Zoom call as a crime, and how the story ended.

Gaza Peace Activists' Detention After a 2020 Video Call

Photo: Hamas security forces in Gaza, June 2020. Said Khatib / Agence France-Presse via Getty Images.

The call that led to arrests

Aman founded the Gaza Youth Committee in 2010 to connect young people in the blockaded strip with the outside world through the internet. From 2015 the group ran a project called "Skype With Your Enemy": small video chats where Palestinians in Gaza and Israelis could talk about daily life, fears and hopes. In 2019 he had already been arrested once, after helping organise a cycling event in which Israeli and Gazan riders took part on opposite sides of the border fence.

On 6 April 2020, during the first pandemic lockdowns, the committee held a larger session on Zoom, lasting about two hours. Accounts of the size differ: Associated Press described dozens of participants, while other reports put the number at more than 200. Some Israeli participants later shared a recording of the discussion online. A Gaza journalist publicly criticised the event and tagged Hamas officials, and an uproar followed.

Hamas security forces detained Aman and seven members of his committee. Aman turned himself in at the Internal Security headquarters in Gaza City on 9 April. Five of those held were released within days; Aman and others stayed in custody for months.

The charges and why Hamas brought them

In late September 2020, The New York Times reported that military prosecutors had charged Aman and two other organisers with "weakening revolutionary spirit", an offence reportedly drawn from the old revolutionary penal code still applied by Hamas military courts. Associated Press later described the charges as treason. The Times reported that a conviction could bring years in prison with hard labour.

The underlying issue is what Palestinians call normalisation: any activity that treats relations with Israel as normal while the occupation and the Gaza blockade continue. Hamas, which has governed Gaza since 2007 and does not recognise Israel, considers meetings with Israelis outside narrow channels, such as medical treatment or legal matters, a betrayal. Many Palestinians who reject Hamas also oppose normalisation, which is partly why the Zoom call caused anger well beyond the movement's own ranks.

From Hamas's point of view, any sign of softness toward Israel weakens the Palestinian bargaining position. From Aman's point of view, nothing would ever change unless ordinary people on both sides could see each other as human beings first.

How rights groups responded

The prosecution drew sharp criticism. Omar Shakir, then Israel and Palestine director at Human Rights Watch, called it outrageous and described the case as "part of a pattern of Hamas authorities arbitrarily arresting activists for their peaceful free expression". He added that bringing charges after more than five months of detention made the injustice worse.

Raji Sourani, director of the Palestinian Centre for Human Rights in Gaza, objected above all to the use of a military court for civilians. His comment was short: "The natural court for civilians is a civilian court. Period." His organisation went on to represent Aman.

In September 2020 a coalition of about 70 non-governmental organisations filed a complaint with the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, asking for his release.

Rami Aman's case for dialogue

Aman never hid what he was trying to do. His argument was that leaders on both sides talk about peace while ordinary Palestinians and Israelis hardly ever meet. Video calls offered a way to compare everyday struggles, from electricity cuts and unemployment to fear of the next war, and to build trust person by person.

Critics in Gaza saw that as naive at best, given the blockade and repeated wars. Supporters saw it as one of the few hopeful projects coming out of the strip. Both sides agree on one thing: in Gaza, this kind of activism carries real personal danger.

The cost to Aman went beyond prison. He had married in early 2020. In August, while detained, he signed divorce papers after being told he would be released the next day; he stayed in jail. He later said he believed the divorce had been forced, and his former wife told Associated Press that she, too, had been pressured.

The wider political moment

The arrests and charges came during a turbulent year for the region. In August and September 2020, Israel agreed to normalise relations with the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain, deals signed at the White House on 15 September. Read our earlier report on the Israel–Bahrain agreement for background. Palestinian leaders across factions condemned the deals, arguing that Arab governments were abandoning them without any progress toward a Palestinian state.

One correction to a common claim from that time: Israel did not carry out its threatened annexation of large parts of the West Bank in 2020. The plan was postponed as part of the agreement with the UAE. Settlement building, which most of the world considers illegal under international law, continued, and Palestinians widely feared that annexation had only been delayed.

Against that backdrop, Hamas had little interest in tolerating Gazans who talked directly with Israelis, even about peace.

How the case ended

On 26 October 2020 the Permanent Military Court in Gaza sentenced the defendants but suspended the rest of their one-year terms, counting the time already spent in detention. Aman, then 39, returned home after roughly six and a half months in custody, and his family confirmed his arrival while declining to comment further.

Aman has lived in Egypt since December 2021. The story remains a useful reference point for anyone trying to understand the limits on civil society in Gaza, and the gap between official peace diplomacy between governments and the much harder work of contact between ordinary people.

Sources: Original reporting and quotes: The New York Times, 24 September 2020; Ynetnews / AP, 26 October 2020; Wikipedia: Rami Aman; Wikipedia: Abraham Accords. Photo: Said Khatib / AFP via Getty Images.

COMMENTS