Originally published 2020-09-28.

In late September 2020, Syria's foreign minister Walid Muallem used his country's address to the 75th UN General Assembly to accuse Turkey of sponsoring terrorism in Syria and the wider region. He said Turkey was occupying parts of northern Syria, that it had let tens of thousands of foreign fighters cross into the country, and that by restricting civilians' access to water in towns under Turkish control it was committing "a war crime and a crime against humanity."
The speech set out the position of President Bashar al-Assad's government; it was not a finding by the United Nations. To make sense of it you need to know who was speaking, what Turkey had done in northern Syria, how Ankara justified it, and how much has changed since. Muallem died less than two months after the speech, and the government he represented fell in December 2024.
What Muallem told the General Assembly
The 2020 session was held largely by video because of the COVID-19 pandemic, so most leaders and ministers sent recorded statements. Muallem's address, as reported by Duvar English and other outlets on 27 September, made several claims about Turkey:
- Occupation. He described Turkish forces in northern Syria as an illegitimate occupation and promised Damascus would spare no effort to end it.
- Water. The phrase "war crime and a crime against humanity" was aimed specifically at interruptions to water supplies in areas held by Turkey and its allied Syrian militias, which affected hundreds of thousands of people in the north-east.
- Foreign fighters. He said Turkey had allowed tens of thousands of foreign militants into Syria and still supported Jabhat al-Nusra, the former Syrian branch of al-Qaeda, and similar groups.
He made similar complaints about the presence of US troops in Syria and repeated the government's commitment to recovering the Golan Heights, which Israel captured in 1967 and later annexed in a move most of the world does not recognise.
Who Walid Muallem was
Muallem, born in Damascus in 1941, was a career diplomat. He spent most of the 1990s as Syria's ambassador in Washington during the on-and-off peace talks with Israel, became foreign minister in 2006 and was also deputy prime minister from 2012. During the civil war that began in 2011 he was one of the government's most familiar faces abroad, defending its conduct at press conferences and leading its delegation at the 2014 Geneva II talks in Switzerland.
He was also personally sanctioned. In 2012 the European Union put him on its sanctions list, saying that as a minister he shared responsibility for the government's violent repression of civilians. That background matters when weighing his words. His accusations against Turkey were not invented, but they came from a government that was itself accused of mass atrocities.
Why Turkish troops were in northern Syria
Turkey launched a series of cross-border operations from 2016 onwards. The one fresh in everyone's mind in 2020 was Operation Peace Spring, which began on 9 October 2019, days after the United States announced it was pulling troops back from north-eastern Syria. Turkish forces and the allied Syrian National Army attacked the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) and took a strip of territory around Tell Abyad and Ras al-Ayn.
Ceasefire deals with the US on 17 October and with Russia in Sochi on 22 October 2019 halted the main fighting. By then more than 300,000 people had been displaced, according to the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights.
The Kurdish-led forces had been the main ground partner of the US-led coalition against ISIS, and after the group's territorial defeat they ran a large self-governing region in the north-east. Ankara saw that region, and the YPG militia at its core, as an extension of the PKK, which has fought an insurgency inside Turkey since 1984.
What rights groups and investigators reported
Muallem was speaking to a wider set of concerns. Amnesty International reported evidence of war crimes and summary killings by Turkish-backed forces during the 2019 offensive. The most notorious case was the killing of Hevrin Khalaf, a Kurdish politician and secretary general of the Future Syria Party, who was executed at a roadside checkpoint along with others; open-source investigators traced the killings to Ahrar al-Sharqiya, a Turkish-backed group.
In September 2020, the same month as the speech, a UN Commission of Inquiry report described abuses by Turkish-backed armed groups in areas such as Afrin and Ras al-Ayn, including looting, seizure of property and abductions. Our report on the UN findings on abuses against Kurds in northern Syria covers that report in more detail. Residents and Kurdish groups also complained that olive groves in Afrin had been cut down or seized.
A further worry concerned the population of the area. President Erdoğan had said he wanted a "safe zone" roughly 30 km deep along the border, where some of the 3.6 million Syrian refugees in Turkey could be resettled. Since most of those refugees are Arabs and the border region is largely Kurdish, critics warned this would amount to demographic engineering or ethnic cleansing.
Turkey's side of the argument
Turkey rejected the accusations. In his own address to the same General Assembly, President Erdoğan said Turkey had played a decisive role in fighting ISIS, that it was hosting around four million Syrian refugees, and that it wanted a permanent political solution to the conflict. Ankara has consistently described its operations as counter-terrorism aimed at the PKK and its affiliates, and says its presence protects its border and allows refugees to go home.
It is worth keeping both points in view. Turkey has carried a huge share of Syria's refugee burden, and PKK attacks inside Turkey have killed many civilians. At the same time, documented abuses by Turkish-backed militias are a matter of independent record, not just Syrian government rhetoric.
What happened next
The UN speech was one of Muallem's last major public appearances. He died in Damascus on 16 November 2020, aged 79, after reported heart problems.
In 2020 it looked as though Assad had won the civil war, with the opposition confined to the north-west and the country in ruins. By 2022 the war had killed an estimated 580,000 people, and the Syrian Network for Human Rights attributed more than 90 per cent of civilian deaths to pro-government forces. Then, in late 2024, a rapid offensive led by Hay'at Tahrir al-Sham, alongside other factions including the Turkish-backed Syrian National Army, swept south. Damascus fell on 8 December 2024 and Assad fled to Moscow, where Russia granted him asylum. HTS leader Ahmed al-Sharaa later became Syria's president.
That outcome reshaped the relationship Muallem had attacked. Turkey, which had long supported parts of the opposition, became one of the most influential foreign powers in post-Assad Syria. Reading the 2020 speech today is a reminder that UN addresses record what a government wants the world to hear at a particular moment, and that each claim deserves to be checked against independent evidence.
Sources: Duvar English, 27 September 2020; AP via PBS NewsHour, 16 November 2020; Wikipedia: Walid Muallem; Wikipedia: 2019 Turkish offensive into north-eastern Syria; Wikipedia: Fall of the Assad regime.

COMMENTS