Did Covid Vaccines Need Shark Squalene? The 500,000 Sharks Claim

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-28.

The 2020 Estimate of Sharks Potentially Used for Vaccine Ingredients

In September 2020, the US-based conservation group Shark Allies warned that a Covid-19 vaccine could cost the lives of up to half a million sharks. The reasoning was simple: some vaccine adjuvants contain squalene, an oil traditionally harvested from shark livers, and the world was about to need billions of doses.

The estimate was a projection, not a count. It assumed that shark-derived squalene would be used in vaccines given to the whole world. In practice, the vaccines that carried most of the global rollout, including the mRNA shots from Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna, contain no squalene at all. Only a few squalene-adjuvanted Covid-19 vaccines were ever authorised, and they played a small part. The warning still raised a fair question about relying on wild animals for medicine.

Where the 500,000 figure came from

Shark Allies calculated that giving one dose of a squalene-adjuvanted vaccine to everyone on Earth would require roughly 250,000 sharks. Because many Covid-19 vaccines were expected to need two doses, the figure doubled to around 500,000. The group also suggested that if immunity faded and yearly boosters were needed, the toll could recur every year.

The group's founder, Stefanie Brendl, stressed in interviews with the British press that Shark Allies did not want to delay a vaccine. Its request was narrower: test non-animal squalene alongside the shark-derived kind so that it could replace it as soon as possible. In her words to the Daily Mail, "Harvesting something from a wild animal is never going to be sustainable."

Shark Allies also said that around 3 million sharks are already killed each year for squalene, much of it destined for cosmetics. That figure comes from the campaign group and is difficult to check independently, but it reflects a genuine trade in deep-sea shark liver oil.

What squalene is and why sharks have so much

Squalene is a natural oil that most plants, animals and fungi make as a building block for sterols such as cholesterol. Humans make it too; a notable share of it ends up in the skin's natural oils. The name comes from Squalus, a genus of dogfish sharks.

Certain deep-water sharks living below about 500 metres store huge amounts of it in their oversized livers, which help keep them buoyant. Their liver oil can be 50 to 80% squalene, which is why it became the cheapest concentrated source. The problem is that many deep-sea sharks grow slowly, mature late and have few young, so populations recover poorly from heavy fishing.

Shark liver is not the only option. Plant oils contain squalene too: amaranth seed oil has the highest share among plant oils (about 1 to 7%), and olive oil contains smaller amounts that can be concentrated. Squalene can also be made synthetically or produced by genetically engineered microbes. The catch has historically been cost and the scale of supply, not chemistry.

Why some vaccines use squalene

Squalene is not an active ingredient against a virus. It is used in adjuvants, substances that help the immune system respond more strongly to a vaccine, which can mean a smaller dose of antigen per shot. In these adjuvants, tiny droplets of squalene are mixed with water and stabilisers to form an emulsion.

Two well-known examples are:

  • MF59, made by Seqirus, used in some seasonal flu vaccines for older adults, such as Fluad.
  • AS03, made by GSK, which combines squalene with vitamin E and polysorbate 80. It was used in the Pandemrix vaccine during the 2009 H1N1 flu pandemic.

In 2020, GSK offered AS03 to several Covid-19 vaccine developers, which is what prompted the shark warnings.

What actually happened with Covid-19 vaccines

The vaccines that dominated the rollout did not use squalene. The mRNA vaccines from Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna and the viral-vector vaccines from Oxford-AstraZeneca and Johnson & Johnson have no adjuvant of this kind. Novavax's protein vaccine uses Matrix-M, an adjuvant made from saponins extracted from the soapbark tree (Quillaja saponaria), not from sharks.

A few AS03-adjuvanted Covid-19 vaccines did reach approval, but late and in small volumes. Medicago's plant-based Covifenz was authorised in Canada in February 2022, and Medicago was shut down a year later. The Sanofi-GSK vaccine, sold in the EU as VidPrevtyn Beta, was authorised in November 2022 and withdrawn at the company's request in 2024 for commercial reasons.

So the half-million figure never came close to reality, and there is no reliable count of sharks killed specifically for Covid-19 vaccines. Russia's Sputnik V and China's inactivated vaccines, both mentioned in news coverage at the time, also did not depend on shark squalene for their supply.

Myths about squalene and vaccine safety

"Squalene in vaccines is dangerous." According to the World Health Organization, more than 22 million doses of squalene-containing flu vaccine had been given in Europe since 1997 without significant vaccine-related safety problems. A 2009 analysis of 64 trials of MF59 flu vaccines found no rise in autoimmune disease.

"Squalene caused Gulf War syndrome." This claim has been investigated and rejected; squalene was not an ingredient of the vaccines in question.

"The Pandemrix narcolepsy cases prove squalene is harmful." Pandemrix was linked to a small rise in narcolepsy in some European countries, mostly among people with a particular genetic variant. Researchers have looked at several possible causes, including the vitamin E component and the virus protein itself, and the mechanism is still not settled. It is not a reason to fear the squalene that occurs naturally in food and skin.

"Every vaccine contains shark oil." Most vaccines contain no squalene at all. If you have questions about a specific vaccine's ingredients, the product information leaflet lists them, and a doctor or pharmacist can explain.

Why the shark question still matters

The Covid-19 case turned out smaller than feared, but the underlying issue has not gone away. Squalene remains in demand for cosmetics, supplements and some vaccines, and deep-sea sharks remain vulnerable. Brendl's point was that a medicine needed in billions of doses should not depend on a wild animal that cannot be farmed, adding that "it is not a reliable supply chain."

The practical answers are already available: plant-based or synthetic squalene for manufacturers, adjuvants that do not use squalene at all, and labelling that lets shoppers choose shark-free cosmetics. Shark Allies backed a petition asking regulators and drug makers to move in that direction, and other conservation groups have run similar campaigns against shark liver oil in beauty products.

Sources: Shark Allies' estimate and Stefanie Brendl's comments as reported by the Daily Mail (September 2020); Wikipedia: Squalene; Wikipedia: AS03; Wikipedia: CoVLP (Covifenz); Wikipedia: Sanofi–GSK COVID-19 vaccine; Wikipedia: Novavax COVID-19 vaccine.

COMMENTS