Phosphine on Venus: What Was Found and Why It Isn’t Proof of Life

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Illustrated Venus landscape beside a molecular graphic

An artist’s concept of Venus beside a molecule graphic. Neither shows real evidence of life; no living thing has ever been seen on Venus.

In September 2020 a team of astronomers announced that they had found signs of phosphine gas in the clouds of Venus, a molecule that on Earth is linked to microbes living without oxygen. The claim made headlines as possible evidence of life. It was never proof of life, and within months other scientists questioned whether the gas had been detected at all. Years later the question is still open, and the most cautious reading is that Venus has an interesting chemistry puzzle, not a confirmed biosphere.

Here is what the researchers actually reported, why their result was challenged, what makes Venus such a hard place for life, and how scientists plan to settle the matter.

What the 2020 study reported

The study, led by Jane Greaves of Cardiff University, was published in Nature Astronomy on 14 September 2020. The team used two radio telescopes: the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope (JCMT) in Hawaii, which observed Venus in 2017, and the ALMA array in Chile, which followed up in 2019. Both showed a dip in Venus’s spectrum at a frequency of about 266.94 GHz, where phosphine absorbs light.

From that dip the authors estimated around 20 parts per billion of phosphine, apparently in the cloud layer roughly 50 to 60 kilometres above the surface. They then tested every non-biological source they could think of, including volcanoes, lightning and meteorites, and found none that seemed able to produce that much. That is the step that turned a spectral line into a news story about possible life.

The authors themselves were careful. Greaves told the BBC that the team wanted other researchers to look for flaws: “Our paper and data are open access; this is how science works.”

Why phosphine got scientists excited

Phosphine is a small molecule made of one phosphorus atom and three hydrogen atoms. On Earth it is produced by some anaerobic microbes in places like swamps and animal guts, and by industry. It breaks down quickly when exposed to sunlight and oxygen-rich chemistry, so if it is present in a planet’s atmosphere, something has to keep making it.

That made phosphine a candidate “biosignature” in research on exoplanets: a gas that, on a rocky world, might be hard to explain without life. It is not a unique fingerprint, though. Jupiter and Saturn have phosphine produced without any biology, deep in their hot, high-pressure interiors. The real question for Venus was whether an unknown chemical process could be doing something similar.

How the detection was challenged

The response from other astronomers came quickly, and it hit the result on several fronts.

  • A data processing problem. In late 2020, ALMA’s operators found a calibration error in the data the team had used. After reprocessing, the signal was much weaker; the authors’ own revised estimate put the average amount several times lower than first reported, around 1 to a few parts per billion.
  • Independent reanalyses. Several groups, including teams led by Ignas Snellen and Geronimo Villanueva, examined the same data and reported no statistically significant detection.
  • A sulfur dioxide explanation. A University of Washington team led by Andrew Lincowski and Victoria Meadows argued in January 2021 that the line could come from ordinary sulfur dioxide, which absorbs at a very similar frequency. Their modelling placed the signal about 80 kilometres up, in the mesosphere, where phosphine would be destroyed within seconds.
  • Upper limits from other instruments. Infrared observations and later measurements from NASA’s SOFIA airborne observatory set limits well below the original 20 parts per billion.

The Greaves team has defended parts of its work, arguing that sulfur dioxide explains only part of the signal and that phosphine levels may change over time. Newer JCMT observations reported in 2024 were presented as support for phosphine, but they have not ended the debate. The honest summary is that the detection remains disputed.

Could anything live on Venus?

At ground level, almost certainly not. Venus’s surface averages about 462 °C (864 °F), hot enough to melt lead, and the pressure is roughly 92 times that on Earth. The atmosphere is about 96.5 per cent carbon dioxide, and the clouds are made of droplets of concentrated sulfuric acid.

Higher up the picture changes. Between roughly 50 and 60 kilometres, temperatures and pressures are surprisingly close to those at Earth’s surface. That is why the idea of life floating in Venus’s clouds is much older than the phosphine story. Harold Morowitz and Carl Sagan discussed it in Nature in 1967, and others had speculated even earlier.

Earth’s extremophiles show that life can cope with boiling vents, acidic springs and crushing ocean depths, which keeps the idea alive. But Venus’s clouds are extraordinarily dry and far more acidic than any place known to host life on Earth, so many researchers think cloud life faces very steep odds. Even optimists only ever talked about microbes, never complex or intelligent life.

Oxford’s Colin Wilson captured the mood in 2020 coverage, saying he thought “life in Venus’ clouds today is so unlikely that we’ll find other chemical pathways of creating phosphine.”

What earlier missions found

Venus was one of the first targets of the space age. The Soviet probe Venera 3 reached the planet in March 1966 and became the first spacecraft to strike another planet, though it had stopped transmitting before arrival. Later Venera landers survived on the surface for up to about two hours, and orbiters such as NASA’s Magellan mapped the ground by radar.

None of these missions saw any sign of life, but none was designed to look for it. That gap is one reason the phosphine debate mattered: it reminded planners how little we know about the chemistry of Venus’s cloud layer.

Venus is also the easiest planet to spot from Earth. It is the brightest natural object in the night sky after the Moon, and it is often mistaken for an unusually bright star low in the evening or morning sky.

How scientists plan to settle the question

Better data is the only way forward. In June 2021 NASA selected two Venus missions: DAVINCI, which will drop a probe through the atmosphere and sample its gases on the way down, and VERITAS, which will map the surface by radar. The European Space Agency is preparing its own orbiter, EnVision. These missions are not life-detection missions, but direct measurements of the atmosphere could confirm or rule out phosphine far more clearly than distant telescopes can.

The phosphine story is also a useful lesson in reading science news. A detection must first be shown to be real, then assigned to the right molecule, and only then can anyone ask what produced it. Skipping straight to “life” is how a careful paper becomes a misleading headline. That is why researchers have proposed frameworks for reporting evidence of extraterrestrial life step by step. The same caution applies to the suggested lakes beneath Mars’s polar ice, another intriguing result whose first interpretation was later questioned.

Whatever the final answer, the debate has already pushed scientists to study Venus’s atmosphere more closely than they had in decades. If life is ever found there, it will be because those measurements become far more convincing, not because of a single faint line in a spectrum.

Sources: Greaves et al., Nature Astronomy (2020); BBC News: Venus phosphine report (September 2020); University of Washington: phosphine signal likely sulfur dioxide (January 2021); Wikipedia: Life on Venus.

COMMENTS