Originally published 2020-09-18.

Photo: Herbert Reul, interior minister of North Rhine-Westphalia, at the presentation of a police arrest and evidence unit in February 2019 (EPA).
In September 2020, the German state of North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW) suspended 29 serving police officers after investigators found far-right chat groups on WhatsApp in which officers had shared more than 100 neo-Nazi and racist images over several years. The pictures included portraits of Adolf Hitler, swastikas and a doctored image of a refugee inside a concentration camp gas chamber.
The officers were suspended and placed under disciplinary proceedings; 11 were treated as main suspects in a criminal inquiry and could face charges of incitement to hatred. A suspension is not a conviction, and the outcome differed from officer to officer. But the case became one of the clearest examples of a problem Germany was already struggling with: right-wing extremism inside the institutions meant to protect democracy.
How the chats were found
The groups reportedly came to light during a separate inquiry into one officer from a unit in Mülheim, when investigators examined his phone. On 16 September 2020, more than 200 police officers searched 34 police stations and private homes across the Ruhr region, linked to 11 main suspects. Most of the officers involved had worked at some point at the same station in Mülheim an der Ruhr, which belongs to the Essen police headquarters.
According to the Associated Press, the material was exchanged in at least five WhatsApp groups used entirely or largely by police. The oldest appears to have been created in 2012, the most active one in 2015, and the latest message was sent on 27 August 2020. Besides Nazi imagery, investigators found a picture mocking the shooting of Black people.
What officials said
Herbert Reul announced the findings at a press conference the same day. He called the chats a disgrace for the state police and said far-right extremists and neo-Nazis had no place in its ranks. His strongest line was widely quoted: the material was "the worst and most repulsive kind of hate-baiting."
He also asked the uncomfortable question at the centre of the case: why had nobody reported this for years, and who had tolerated it? Reul appointed a special commissioner to investigate extremist tendencies in the NRW police. In Berlin, a spokesman for the federal interior ministry called the reports highly alarming, and the Greens demanded a nationwide study of extremism in the police. Similar chat groups had already been found in police forces in other German states.
Why sharing these images is a crime in Germany
Germany treats Nazi symbols differently from most countries. Section 86a of the German Criminal Code makes it an offence to distribute or publicly use the symbols of banned unconstitutional organisations, including swastikas, SS runes and the Hitler salute. There are exceptions for education, art, science, research and reporting on history, which is why the symbols can appear in museums, school books and documentaries.
Chats between colleagues are not always "public" in the legal sense, so not every image in a private group automatically leads to a conviction. Separately, incitement to hatred (Volksverhetzung) is a crime under Section 130. For police officers, though, the bar is higher than for ordinary citizens: civil servants in Germany owe a duty of loyalty to the constitution, and disciplinary rules can lead to dismissal even when a criminal case fails.
Part of a wider pattern
The NRW case arrived in a year full of similar revelations, which is why it drew so much attention.
The NSU and "NSU 2.0"
The National Socialist Underground (NSU) was a neo-Nazi terror cell that murdered nine immigrants, eight of Turkish origin and one Greek, between 2000 and 2006, and killed police officer Michèle Kiesewetter in 2007. It was uncovered only in 2011, and Beate Zschäpe was sentenced to life in prison in 2018. From 2018, dozens of threatening messages signed "NSU 2.0" were sent to politicians, lawyers, journalists and entertainers, some containing personal data apparently retrieved from police computers. In July 2020, German media reported that a former police officer and his wife had been briefly detained in connection with such messages. In November 2022, a Frankfurt court sentenced a Berlin man, Alexander M., who was not a police officer, to five years and ten months for sending the letters.
The KSK commando force
On 1 July 2020, Defence Minister Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer ordered one of the four companies of the army's elite KSK special forces dissolved, because far-right extremism was most widespread there. Around 48,000 rounds of ammunition and 62 kg of explosives were found to be missing from the unit's stocks, and in May 2020 police had found military weapons and explosives at the home of a KSK soldier with far-right sympathies.
The armed forces more widely
In early 2020, Germany's military counter-intelligence service reported that it was examining roughly 600 soldiers on suspicion of far-right extremism. Earlier claims that 600 police officers were active neo-Nazis are not supported; the figure refers to soldiers under investigation, not proven members of any group.
What the case tells us
Extremist chat groups inside police forces are dangerous for two reasons. First, they undermine trust: people from minority backgrounds have to be able to believe that the officer answering their call does not share pictures mocking their deaths. Second, police have access to weapons, databases and personal data, which the NSU 2.0 affair showed can be abused.
The NRW case also shows the value of investigation that follows the evidence. A routine inquiry into a leak led to a network that had operated unnoticed for years. In the years since, several German states have commissioned studies of attitudes in the police and debated tighter screening of recruits. Whether those steps are enough is still debated, but the debate itself is now harder to avoid.
Sources: The Local, 16 September 2020; Associated Press via The Times of Israel; JURIST on the KSK partial dissolution; Wikipedia: National Socialist Underground; Associated Press via Fox News on the NSU 2.0 sentence; German Criminal Code (official English translation).

COMMENTS