Originally published 2020-09-18.
In September 2020, eight people caught without face masks in Cerme district, part of Gresik regency in East Java, Indonesia, were ordered to help dig graves for people who had died of Covid-19. The order came from the district head, Suyono, who said the cemetery had only three gravediggers and that the work should deter others from breaking the rules. It was a local decision by one district official, not a national Indonesian law, but it made headlines around the world as one of the most unusual pandemic punishments. This is what happened, why officials reached for shock tactics, and what the evidence says about masks and about shaming as enforcement.
What happened in Cerme
The Jakarta Post reported on 10 September 2020 that the eight violators were sent to a public cemetery in Ngabetan village. They worked in pairs at each grave: one person dug the hole, while the other placed the wooden boards that support the body inside the grave. Officials said the group would not take part in the burials themselves.
Suyono explained his reasoning simply. With only three gravediggers available, he decided the rule-breakers could help them, and he said he hoped the work would have a deterrent effect. The thinking behind the order was that standing beside a fresh grave for a Covid-19 victim would make the danger feel far more real than a fine.
The legal basis and other penalties
Gresik had its own health protocol rules. Under Regent Regulation No. 22 of 2020, people who ignored mask requirements could be fined or given community service, and local leaders had some freedom in choosing what that service would be. Grave digging was framed as community service.
Police and soldiers also took part in enforcement. The local police chief said officers would work with the military to break up crowds and urged residents to wear masks in line with the health protocols. Cases had been rising in Cerme, which is why the village tightened its measures.
Gresik was not alone in trying fear as a teaching tool. The Jakarta Post linked the story to another case in Probolinggo, also in East Java, where violators were reportedly made to sit inside a hearse beside a coffin. Because penalties were set locally, enforcement varied widely from one regency to the next.
Indonesia's pandemic at the time
Indonesia confirmed its first Covid-19 cases on 2 March 2020. By mid-September 2020 the country had reported around 230,000 confirmed cases and more than 9,000 deaths, figures widely believed to understate the true toll because testing was limited. Worldwide, confirmed cases had passed 30 million and deaths were approaching one million.
Later estimates suggest the real impact was far larger. Analyses of excess deaths put Indonesia's pandemic toll at one million or more, many of them during the severe Delta wave of mid-2021. Vaccination began on 13 January 2021, when President Joko Widodo received the first shot at the presidential palace, and Indonesia lifted its last nationwide social restrictions at the end of December 2022.
What the science says about masks
In 2020 the World Health Organization and most national health agencies advised wearing masks to reduce the spread of the virus, especially indoors, in crowds and where distancing was impossible. Covid-19 spreads mainly through respiratory droplets and smaller airborne particles, and masks act as a barrier for both the wearer and the people around them.
Research since then has added nuance. Laboratory studies consistently show that masks filter respiratory particles, and well-fitted respirators such as N95 or FFP2 masks perform better than cloth. Large real-world trials are harder to run and their results vary, partly because people do not always wear masks properly or consistently. The general picture is that masks help, particularly high-quality ones worn correctly in crowded indoor spaces, but they work best alongside ventilation, vaccination and staying home when sick.
Does shaming work as enforcement?
The Cerme punishment drew both praise and criticism. Supporters saw it as a creative way to make people face reality at a time when many still dismissed the virus. Critics argued that using graves and coffins as props was disrespectful to the dead and their families, and that frightening or humiliating people builds resentment rather than trust.
Public health experts generally favour clear information, free or cheap masks, and trusted community messengers such as religious leaders and local doctors. Penalties can play a role, but compliance tends to last longer when people understand the reasons and feel protected rather than punished. Spectacular sanctions also attract attention to a few individuals while the bigger issue, whether enough masks and tests are available, stays in the background.
Why the story still resonates
Years later, the image of mask violators standing in a cemetery remains a vivid reminder of how frightened and improvised pandemic responses could be, especially in places where hospitals and gravediggers were overwhelmed. It also shows the tension every community faced: how to protect the vulnerable without losing sight of dignity and fairness. Local officials in Cerme were dealing with rising infections, few workers and limited tools, and they chose a punishment designed to be remembered. Whether it changed behaviour in the village was never measured. For anyone thinking about future outbreaks, the lesson is that rules work best when they are explained clearly, applied fairly and backed by practical help.
Sources: The Jakarta Post (10 September 2020); Wikipedia: COVID-19 pandemic in Indonesia.

COMMENTS