2020 Holocaust Knowledge Survey: What Young Americans Got Wrong

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published September 17, 2020.

2020 Holocaust Knowledge Survey Revealed Serious Gaps

Left: the electrified fences of Auschwitz-Birkenau, the largest Nazi killing centre. Right: child prisoners photographed after the camp's liberation by the Soviet army in January 1945. Images like these are the evidence that surveys of Holocaust knowledge are, in the end, measuring.

In September 2020 the Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany, usually called the Claims Conference, released what it described as the first 50-state survey of Holocaust knowledge among Millennials and Gen Z. The headline result: 63% of Americans aged 18 to 39 did not know that about six million Jews were murdered, and more than half of that group guessed the toll was under two million. Nearly half could not name a single concentration camp or ghetto, and 11% said Jews caused the Holocaust.

Here is what the survey found, what critics said about it, the historical facts it tested, and what helps people learn this history well.

The key findings at a glance

The survey questioned a nationally representative sample of 1,000 young adults, with additional state samples of around 200 people each, by phone and online. As reported by NBC News and others:

  • The death toll: 63% did not know that six million Jews were killed; over half of those thought the number was below two million.
  • Camps and ghettos: almost half could not name one. About 44% named Auschwitz without prompting.
  • Basic awareness: more than one in ten did not recall hearing the word "Holocaust" before.
  • Belief and denial: 90% said the Holocaust happened, 7% were unsure and 3% denied it.
  • Blame: 11% nationally, and 19% in New York, said Jews caused the Holocaust.
  • Online exposure: about half had seen Holocaust denial or distortion on social media, and 56% had seen Nazi symbols online or in their community in the previous five years.
  • Education: a majority wanted Holocaust education to be compulsory, and about 80% agreed that learning about it helps prevent it happening again.

Wisconsin, Minnesota and Massachusetts scored highest. In New York, Indiana and California, more than 20% of respondents described the Holocaust as a myth or exaggerated. Notably, several states with mandatory Holocaust education did not score better than states without it.

How to read these numbers fairly

A survey is only as good as its questions. Writing in J. The Jewish News of Northern California, UC Berkeley sociologist Samuel Lucas pointed out that a "not sure" answer can mean ignorance, hesitation or a lapse of memory, so it does not neatly measure what people know. Some questions could also be read in more than one way, such as asking which countries the Holocaust "took place" in.

Lucas also noted the opposite risk. On a charged subject, some respondents soften their answers to avoid looking prejudiced, which means real levels of denial could be higher than reported. And he found some results encouraging: 44% naming Auschwitz with no prompting, and nine in ten affirming the Holocaust happened.

Two other cautions are worth keeping in mind:

  • Not knowing is not the same as denying. Someone who guesses the wrong death toll has a knowledge gap, not necessarily a hostile view.
  • Do not invert percentages. If a majority supports compulsory Holocaust education, it does not follow that everyone else opposes it; some are unsure or chose other answers. The same applies to questions about extremist views. Reading "the rest" as the opposite position overstates the problem.

Even with those caveats, the gaps are real, and teachers and historians who work with young people were not surprised by them.

The facts the survey was testing

The Holocaust was the systematic, state-organised murder of about six million European Jews by Nazi Germany and its collaborators, mainly between 1941 and 1945. That was roughly two-thirds of Europe's Jewish population.

How the killing was carried out

After Germany invaded the Soviet Union in June 1941, mobile killing units known as Einsatzgruppen, along with police battalions and local collaborators, shot Jews in mass executions across occupied territory. Between 1.5 and 2 million Jews were murdered this way, often called the "Holocaust by bullets".

At the Wannsee Conference on 20 January 1942, senior Nazi officials coordinated the deportation of Jews from across Europe. Most were sent to six extermination camps in occupied Poland: Chełmno, Bełżec, Sobibór, Treblinka, Majdanek and Auschwitz-Birkenau. At Auschwitz-Birkenau alone, between 900,000 and one million Jews were killed.

Other victims of Nazi persecution

Historians generally use "the Holocaust" for the genocide of the Jews, while recognising that Nazi Germany also murdered other groups. Roma and Sinti were targeted for genocide; about 3.3 million Soviet prisoners of war died in German captivity, mostly from deliberate starvation; tens of thousands of disabled people were murdered in the so-called T4 programme and many more in later killings; and Polish elites, political opponents and others were persecuted and killed. Counting all victims of Nazi persecution produces a total far larger than six million.

Responsibility lies with the perpetrators. The belief that Jews somehow caused their own destruction, held by 11% of respondents, is a classic antisemitic myth with no basis in history.

Why the gaps matter now

The Claims Conference's president, Gideon Taylor, called the results "shocking and saddening" and urged action while survivors are still alive to tell their own stories. Fewer survivors remain each year, and their testimony has been one of the most powerful tools for teaching this history.

At the same time, much of what young people encounter about the Holocaust now arrives through social media, where denial, jokes and distortions spread easily. The survey's finding that half of respondents had seen such content online helps explain why factual knowledge alone may not be enough.

What helps people learn this history

Educators interviewed after the survey stressed understanding over memorising. Knowing why ordinary institutions and neighbours took part matters as much as naming camps. Practical approaches that work well include:

  • Survivor testimony. Recorded interviews, such as those held by major Holocaust museums and archives, give a human scale to numbers that can feel abstract.
  • Local connections. Many towns have survivors, liberators or refugees in their history; tracing those links makes events concrete.
  • Primary sources. Photographs, letters, deportation lists and Nazi documents show how persecution escalated step by step, from laws and exclusion to murder.
  • Media literacy. Teaching students how denial and distortion work online helps them recognise it when they see it.
  • Visiting memorials and museums. In person or online, institutions such as the US Holocaust Memorial Museum and Yad Vashem offer reliable, free educational material.

The bottom line

The 2020 survey did not show that young Americans approve of the Holocaust or of neo-Nazism. It showed something quieter and still serious: many have only a hazy idea of what happened, how large it was, or where it took place, at the very moment first-hand witnesses are disappearing. Closing that gap is a task for schools, families and anyone who shares history online.

Sources: NBC News: Survey finds 'shocking' lack of Holocaust knowledge among millennials and Gen Z (September 2020); J. The Jewish News of Northern California: a closer look at the survey (22 September 2020); Wikipedia: The Holocaust; Claims Conference survey release (September 2020).

COMMENTS