Moria Camp Fire: An Activist’s NGO Claims vs. What Courts Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-16.

Activist’s Unproven Claims That NGOs Started the Moria Camp Fire

No evidence has ever shown that aid workers set the fire that destroyed the Moria refugee camp on the Greek island of Lesbos in September 2020. That idea came from a German activist in a phone interview published while the camp was still smouldering. Greek police arrested six young Afghan residents instead, and courts later jailed all six for arson, although their lawyers and independent investigators have raised serious doubts about that case as well.

Here is what the activist actually said, what is known about how the fire began and spread, and why the claim travelled so far so fast.

What happened at Moria in September 2020

Moria opened in January 2013 as a reception and identification centre with room for roughly 3,000 people. After the 2015 arrivals from Turkey it never recovered its intended size. By the summer of 2020 around 20,000 people lived in and around it, including an estimated 6,000 to 7,000 children, many of them in an olive grove next to the official site, under shelters built from wooden pallets and tarpaulin.

Coronavirus made a tense place tenser. Cases were found in the camp, a lockdown was imposed and movement was restricted while the rest of Greece was opening up for the tourist season. On the evening of 8 September, staff and police tried to locate eight residents who had tested positive so they could be isolated. A protest followed, and shortly after 11:30 pm the first fires broke out. Further fires the next day finished the job: by 10 September the camp was almost entirely gone.

Nobody died, which surprised many observers given the density of the site. Around 13,000 people, among them families, pregnant women and people with disabilities, slept on roadsides and in car parks for about a week. Police used tear gas on residents protesting for evacuation, and a temporary tent camp was set up at Kara Tepe.

Fire itself was nothing new at Moria. Researchers later counted at least 246 earlier fire incidents there, 112 of them between January and August 2020 alone. A container fire in March 2020 killed a six-year-old child, and a blaze in September 2019 killed a woman.

What Rebecca Sommer claimed in the interview

The activist was Rebecca Sommer, a German artist and photographer who had been working on refugee issues; her surname is often misspelled “Somer” in English-language copies of the story. On 10 September 2020 the German opinion website Tichys Einblick published a telephone interview with her from Lesbos.

Sommer said the blaze was deliberate, calling it, in translation, “a coordinated action with the aim of setting this entire camp on fire.” Many retellings went further than she did. In the interview she blamed camp residents for the fires and rejected the idea that islanders had started them. Her NGO claim was narrower and secondhand: contacts inside the camp, she said, had seen a German man and a German woman from aid organisations alongside a group of residents who were lighting fires. She did not name the people or the organisations, and the magazine itself presented this part as an allegation.

She also described residents as aggressive towards police and firefighters, spoke of iron bars, knives and even swords inside the camp, and repeated rumours that weapons had come from the Turkish army. She said she had been shown “Taliban” among the residents, identified by their clothing, and claimed that very few Syrians were present compared with Afghans, most of them Hazara, and people from African countries.

A few of these points touch real facts. Afghans were widely reported to be the largest group in the camp in 2020, and clashes with police did happen during the lockdown. Others do not hold up. Clothing cannot tell anyone whether a man belongs to the Taliban, and the Hazara are a minority that has long been persecuted in Afghanistan, including by the Taliban. Sommer herself described the Turkish weapons story as a rumour, and no evidence for it emerged afterwards.

What investigators and the courts concluded

Within a week of the fire, police had arrested six young Afghan asylum seekers. Four were charged as adults on 16 September 2020. Two were accepted as minors and, in March 2021, received five-year sentences. On 12 June 2021 a court on the island of Chios sentenced the other four to ten years each for arson.

The defence called the trial unfair and appealed. Their main objection was that the prosecution relied heavily on a single witness, an ethnic Pashtun resident, who named the defendants by first name only and could not be found to testify in person. All six defendants are Hazara and said they had been framed. Three of them insisted they were minors, but the court relied on an X-ray of the hand to assess their age, a method their lawyers challenged. An appeal for four of them was heard in Mytilene in March 2023.

The research groups Forensic Architecture and Forensis later rebuilt the night minute by minute from hundreds of videos and satellite images. They found that one part of the camp the key witness described as burning early had not burned that night at all. The Mytilene fire service had already reported that strong winds carried embers south through the camp, creating new fires as they went, and the wider investigation pointed to improvised electrical connections inside flammable shelters as a likely source of ignition.

Whatever one thinks of the convictions, none of these official or independent accounts pointed to aid workers. The NGO claim was never part of the prosecution’s case.

The Turkey question and the 2020 border crisis

Suspicion of Ankara did not come from nowhere. On 28 February 2020, after 33 Turkish soldiers were killed in Idlib in Syria, Turkey announced it would no longer stop migrants heading for Europe. Thousands gathered at the Kastanies crossing on the Evros river. President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan declared, “We will not close the gates to refugees,” and his interior minister urged people to cross on foot.

Greece closed the border and pushed back crossings, and on 3 March the presidents of the European Commission, Council and Parliament visited Evros to back Athens. Even Angela Merkel, who did not condemn Turkey outright, said Erdoğan should not use refugees to express his displeasure. Turkey has also backed armed opposition factions in Syria and intervened militarily in Libya, which feeds Greek distrust.

That background explains why a story about Turkish weapons found a ready audience in Greece. It does not make the story true. Using migration as diplomatic leverage at a land border in February is a documented event; arming residents of a camp on Lesbos is an unsupported rumour.

Why the claim spread so quickly

The interview landed at the perfect moment for virality: the fire was global news, people wanted someone to blame, and the story offered villains to several audiences at once. Critics of aid groups saw proof that NGOs were stirring trouble. Critics of migration saw proof that residents were armed and dangerous. Critics of Turkey saw Ankara’s hand. Each group shared the part that suited it, and the details shifted as they went, until “NGO workers seen nearby” became “NGOs started the fire.”

When a dramatic claim like this appears during a breaking story, a few questions help:

  • Who saw it first-hand? A report of what someone else saw is weaker than direct testimony, photos or video.
  • Are names, places and times given? Vague accusations against unnamed groups cannot be checked or answered.
  • What did police, courts or later investigations find? Claims that never appear in any official or independent inquiry deserve scepticism.
  • Is the story still circulating after the facts came out? That usually means people are sharing it for what it says about their opponents, not for what it says about the event.

What came after Moria

The temporary camp at Kara Tepe held about 6,000 people by mid-2021. The European Union set aside around $336 million for new, more controlled centres on Lesbos, Chios, Samos, Kos and Leros. On Lesbos, a closed centre was planned at Vastria in the north-east of the island, but Greece’s Council of State revoked its building permit because no environmental study had been carried out.

For islanders, the fire capped years of strain on a small community that had borne a European problem largely alone. For residents of the camp, it ended one emergency and began another. Neither group is helped by stories that swap evidence for rumour, and that is the real lesson of the Sommer interview.

Sources: Tichys Einblick, interview with Rebecca Sommer (10 September 2020); Al Jazeera: Afghans jailed in Greece over Moria camp blaze (13 June 2021); Solomon: The fire at Moria, a disaster destined to happen; Wikipedia: Moria refugee camp; Wikipedia: 2020 Greek–Turkish border crisis.

COMMENTS