Why Thousands of Songbirds Died in New Mexico in 2020

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
The Southwest’s 2020 Bird Die-Off: What Investigators Found Later

In late August and September 2020, people across New Mexico and southern Colorado began finding dead songbirds on trails, roads, yards and military land. Early reports talked of "millions" of birds and blamed everything from wildfire smoke to a mystery illness. The answer that came back from the lab a few months later was more ordinary and more worrying: most of the birds had starved, and a sudden early-September cold snap finished off many that were already weak.

This is what happened, what the examinations found, how many birds probably died, and why the event matters for a bird population that was already shrinking.

What people saw in the Southwest in 2020

The first alarms came from places such as White Sands Missile Range in southern New Mexico, where wildlife biologist Patricia (Trish) Cutler and colleagues started picking up carcasses in large numbers. Reports soon spread north. In mid-September, journalist Austin Fisher filmed dead birds along a trail in Rio Arriba County in northern New Mexico and posted that he had never seen anything like it.

The victims were mostly small migratory insect-eaters heading south for the winter: warblers, flycatchers, swallows, sparrows and similar species. Researchers eventually counted 59 species among carcasses collected in southern New Mexico. Witnesses described living birds behaving strangely, sitting on the ground, sluggish and easy to approach, which is typical of animals running out of energy.

One detail stood out to Cutler early on: resident birds that live in the desert all year, such as roadrunners, quail and doves, were not turning up among the dead. That pointed to something specific to birds on migration rather than a local poison or disease.

The early theories: smoke, drought and cold

Because the event coincided with the record 2020 wildfire season in California, Oregon and Washington, many people suspected smoke. The idea was that ash and fumes could damage the delicate lungs of birds, or that fires had forced them to leave their breeding grounds before they had built up enough fat for the trip.

Martha Desmond, a wildlife ecologist at New Mexico State University who helped coordinate the research response, pointed to the drought as well. "It's been extremely dry here this year, so seed production is low and insect numbers are low," she told Audubon. For birds that refuel on insects during stopovers, a dry year means fewer meals on a journey that already pushes their bodies to the limit.

Then came the weather. Around Labor Day, an unusually early winter storm swept through the region with freezing temperatures, strong winds and snow, days after a spell of heat.

What the laboratory found

New Mexico Department of Game and Fish sent representative birds to the U.S. Geological Survey's National Wildlife Health Center in Madison, Wisconsin. Its findings, announced by the state on 4 December 2020, were consistent across almost every bird examined.

  • Nearly all were in poor to severely emaciated condition, with fat reserves used up and breast muscles badly wasted.
  • Stomachs and intestines were empty, and many intestines held small amounts of blood linked to starvation.
  • Many showed signs of kidney failure.
  • Some lungs were irritated, but there was no evidence of smoke poisoning.
  • Bacterial and viral diseases, including avian influenza and Newcastle disease, were ruled out, as were parasites and pesticide poisoning.

State wildlife disease specialist Kerry Mower summed up the limits honestly: "The laboratory results are very informative but did not identify a single definitive cause of mortality." The agency's conclusion was that many birds entered New Mexico already in poor shape, and the storm then disoriented and chilled them. Some flew low and hit buildings or vehicles; many landed on the ground, where cold, snow and predators killed them.

How many birds actually died?

The "millions" figure that circulated in September 2020 was never a count. It was a rough guess made while reports were pouring in. Cutler, who personally collected more than 400 dead birds, later estimated that statewide losses probably ran into the tens of thousands and possibly the hundreds of thousands. That is still a very large mortality event, but it is an order of magnitude below the early headlines.

Counting dead migrants is hard. Small birds are quickly eaten by scavengers, many die far from people, and reporting depends on who happens to be out walking. To help, New Mexico State University set up a citizen-science project on the iNaturalist app, and hundreds of reports came in by phone, email and photo. Reports dropped off by late September as the migration moved on.

What about wildfire smoke?

Smoke was the most popular theory, and the lab results did not support it as a direct cause. There was no sign that smoke had poisoned the birds. Officials and ornithologists have kept one indirect possibility open: fires and smoke may have pushed some migrants off their usual routes or timing, forcing them to burn extra energy and steering them into the path of the storm. That remains a hypothesis rather than a finding.

Later research has added weight to the drought explanation. Scientists at Los Alamos National Laboratory and federal agencies, led by Jenna Stanek, looked at 11 years of bird-banding data and found that birds were more likely to have very low fat reserves in severe drought years. Young insect-eating birds were the least likely to carry enough fuel for migration.

A single die-off and the long-term decline of birds

It is tempting to read a mass die-off as the cause of falling bird numbers, but the two are separate stories that point in the same direction. In 2019 a major study in the journal Science estimated that the United States and Canada had about 2.9 billion fewer breeding birds than in 1970, a loss of roughly 30 percent. Grassland birds were hit hardest, falling by more than half, and much of the loss came from common families such as sparrows, warblers, blackbirds and finches.

The main drivers identified by researchers are habitat loss, free-roaming cats, collisions with glass, pesticides and the decline of insects that many birds eat, with climate change expected to make several of these worse. The 2020 event fits that pattern: a hot, dry year cut the insect supply, and extreme weather then hit birds with no reserves left. Audubon Southwest's Jon Hayes described changing weather patterns in the West as the underlying driver.

What people can do to help migrating birds

Individual actions will not stop a drought, but they do reduce the everyday pressures that leave birds less able to cope with one.

  • Report dead or sick birds to your state wildlife agency or a citizen-science platform; those reports are how investigations like this one begin.
  • Make windows safer with screens, decals or patterns, since glass collisions kill huge numbers of birds each year.
  • Keep cats indoors, especially during spring and autumn migration.
  • Plant native shrubs and flowers and cut back on pesticides, which supports the insects that migrating songbirds depend on.
  • Turn off unnecessary outdoor lights at night during migration seasons, when many songbirds travel in the dark.

The 2020 die-off began as a mystery and ended as a case study in how science works: early guesses, careful examination, and an explanation that was less dramatic than the rumours but more useful for protecting birds in the future.

Sources: New Mexico Department of Game and Fish, findings release (4 December 2020); Audubon, "Study: Starvation and a Freak Snow Storm Caused the Southwest's Mass Bird Die-Off" (2020); Source NM, follow-up research (2022); Cornell Lab of Ornithology, 3 billion birds study and actions. Video by Austin Fisher via YouTube.

COMMENTS