What Killed 350 Elephants in Botswana in 2020?

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-07-04.

Botswana Investigated Hundreds of Elephant Deaths in 2020

Aerial view of elephant carcasses in Botswana's Okavango Delta region, 2020. Photo credit: The Guardian.

Between roughly March and June 2020, more than 350 African elephants died in northern Botswana, most of them near seasonal waterholes in the Seronga area at the edge of the Okavango Delta. At first no one could explain it. In September 2020 Botswana's wildlife department said the most likely cause was a nerve toxin produced by cyanobacteria, often called blue-green algae, growing in those water pans. A satellite study published in late 2024 strengthened that conclusion and linked the toxic bloom to an unusual swing from drought to heavy rain.

Here is what happened, how investigators narrowed down the cause, and what the event means for elephants in a warming climate.

What conservationists saw in 2020

The deaths came to wide attention in early July 2020, after aerial surveys counted large numbers of carcasses across a relatively small area. Reports at the time put the total at about 170 by the end of May and well over 350 by late June. Roughly seven in ten carcasses were found near waterholes. Males and females of every age were affected, and the tusks were still in place, which pointed away from poaching.

Witnesses described elephants walking in circles, appearing weak or disoriented, and some collapsing suddenly, sometimes face first. Those signs suggested something was attacking the nervous system.

Dr Niall McCann of the UK charity National Park Rescue, one of the first to raise the alarm, said of the scale:

"Outside of drought, I don't know of a die-off that has been this significant." (Niall McCann, National Park Rescue, July 2020)

Theories and the delay in testing

Several explanations were floated in the first weeks:

  • Poaching or deliberate poisoning. Cyanide is sometimes used by poachers, and farmers in conflict with elephants have used poison. But the tusks were intact, and vultures and hyenas feeding on carcasses did not appear to fall ill, which made a classic poisoning less likely.
  • Anthrax, which had reportedly killed around 100 elephants in Botswana the year before. Tests ruled it out.
  • Other infections, such as encephalomyocarditis virus, were considered and judged unlikely from the field evidence.
  • Something in the water, which fitted the clustering around waterholes.

Conservation groups criticised the time it took to get samples to accredited laboratories. Mary Rice of the Environmental Investigation Agency in London said publicly that the delay and the lack of urgency were a real concern, given repeated offers of help. Part of the problem was practical: the COVID-19 pandemic disrupted flights and lab work just as the deaths peaked. Samples were reportedly sent on to laboratories in several other countries. Officials also stated that the coronavirus itself played no role.

What the official investigation found

On 21 September 2020, Cyril Taolo, acting director of the Department of Wildlife and National Parks, announced that about 330 elephants in the Seronga area had most likely died from neurotoxic cyanobacteria. According to AP, the conclusion rested on the pattern of deaths and on field, clinical, post-mortem and laboratory findings.

Key points from that announcement:

  • The deaths were concentrated near seasonal pans and did not spread beyond the first affected area.
  • The only clinical signs were neurological, consistent with a toxin that paralyses and kills mainly by respiratory failure.
  • In one elephant given a drug during field immobilisation, the neurological signs reversed, a clue that the toxin acted on nerve receptors.
  • The deaths stopped once the pans dried up.
  • Anthrax, poaching and sabotage were ruled out.

Officials could not explain why other animals drinking the same water were not affected. One possibility is behaviour: elephants drink very large volumes and often wade into the middle of pans, where blooms can be densest. That remains a hypothesis rather than a finding.

How satellites filled in the picture

Because the evidence in 2020 was partly circumstantial, researchers kept working. In November 2024, a team led by Davide Lomeo, a PhD researcher at King's College London, Plymouth Marine Laboratory and the Natural History Museum, published a study in Science of the Total Environment with partners including the University of Botswana.

The team combined the locations of carcasses from an aerial survey with satellite records of around 3,000 waterholes in the region. They found that 20 waterholes near fresh carcasses showed dense cyanobacteria blooms in 2020, and that blooms during the die-off were more extensive than at any time in the previous nine years. Carcasses were strongly clustered around waterholes with poor water quality.

The likely trigger was weather. 2019 was extremely dry; 2020 was extremely wet. Heavy rain washing nutrients into newly filled pans created ideal conditions for a massive bloom.

Why this matters for elephants and climate

Botswana holds about 130,000 elephants, the largest population of any country, and they are central to its tourism economy. Losing 350 animals is not a threat to that population on its own, but the event was a warning.

Climate models predict that southern Africa will see more intense droughts and more extreme rainfall. Those are exactly the swings that seem to have set off the 2020 bloom. The researchers described the die-off as part of a wider pattern of sudden, climate-linked disease events in large mammals. The mass death of saiga antelope in Kazakhstan in 2015 is another well-known example of how quickly such events can unfold.

The practical lessons are clear enough. Botswana announced regular monitoring of seasonal pans and new capacity to test for cyanobacterial toxins. Scientists have argued for using satellite data to flag dangerous blooms early, so that rangers can respond before animals die.

Blue-green algae: a risk closer to home

Toxic cyanobacteria are not only a problem in Africa. They grow in lakes, ponds and reservoirs worldwide, especially in warm, still, nutrient-rich water, and they regularly kill dogs and livestock. Some blooms look like green paint or scum; others are hard to spot.

Simple precautions help: keep pets and children out of water that looks discoloured or scummy, follow local warning signs, and rinse a dog that has been in questionable water. If a person or animal becomes unwell after contact, talk to a doctor or a vet promptly.

For more on threats to elephants in this period, see our report on a pregnant elephant killed in Kerala.

Sources: AP via ClickOnDetroit: 330 elephants in Botswana may have died from toxic algae; Plymouth Marine Laboratory: New paper reveals unprecedented algal bloom linked to the 2020 elephant deaths; The Guardian, July 2020 (photo).

COMMENTS