Oklahoma Woman Shot in the Back After Taking a Neighbour's Nazi Flag

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-07-04.

The Oklahoma Shooting After a Nazi-Flag Removal in 2020

In late June 2020 a 26-year-old woman was shot several times in the back in the small town of Hunter, Oklahoma, after she took a Nazi flag from the property of a neighbour who was known locally for displaying them. Alexander John Feaster, 44, was arrested and charged with shooting with intent to kill and assault and battery with a deadly weapon. The woman survived and was expected to recover.

The case drew national attention because it sat at the meeting point of several heated questions in the United States: hate symbols, free speech, the right to defend property, and the limits of deadly force.

What happened in Hunter

Hunter is a small farming town in Garfield County, about 90 miles north of Oklahoma City. According to NBC News, sheriff's deputies were called on a Sunday night and found the woman lying in a ditch with gunshot wounds to her back. She had been hit between three and five times by a rifle firing 5.56mm rounds, the calibre used in AR-15-style weapons. Earlier reports put the number of shots at four.

She was taken to OU Medical Center in Oklahoma City, where she was described as being in good condition. British newspapers identified her as Kyndal McVey.

Investigators said she had been at a party nearby and then removed one of the swastika flags from Feaster's property. Neighbours told reporters that she had run off with the flag and was shot as she fled.

What investigators and witnesses said

Garfield County Sheriff Jody Helm said it was not clear whether the woman meant to make a political statement or was acting on a dare, telling NBC News: "There's conflicting information." He added that young people in the area had tried to take the flags before and that the man was deeply unpopular in town.

According to a probable cause affidavit reported by the Independent, a deputy wrote that the woman did not appear to pose any threat, since she was running away from the house holding only a flag. The same reports said that footage from Feaster's own security cameras appeared to show him firing without warning, though that video was not made public.

Reports also described how a neighbour drove a red pickup truck into position to shield the wounded woman until deputies arrived, while keeping watch on Feaster's house with a weapon. Neighbours said he had flown Nazi-style flags for about a year and had reportedly been seen in Nazi-style uniforms on his property, though one said he had mostly kept to himself.

Charges, bail and the court process

Feaster was held in the Garfield County jail on charges of assault and battery with a deadly weapon and shooting with intent to kill. NBC News reported that bail was set at $500,000 and that he was due in court on 9 July 2020. He had asked for a lawyer and declined to speak to investigators.

As with any criminal case, he was presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty. The final outcome of the prosecution could not be confirmed from the sources available to us, so readers looking for the verdict should check Oklahoma court records or later local reporting.

Is it legal to fly a Nazi flag in the US?

Yes. The First Amendment to the US Constitution protects a very wide range of expression, including symbols most people find hateful. American courts have repeatedly held that the government cannot ban speech or displays simply because they are offensive, and the 1977 Skokie case, in which a neo-Nazi group was allowed to march through a Chicago suburb home to many Holocaust survivors, remains the best-known example.

That protection has limits. It covers expression, not threats, harassment or violence. And it applies in both directions: a hateful flag on private property is lawful, but taking it is still theft, however understandable the anger behind the act. Many other democracies, including Germany and Austria, take a different approach and restrict the public display of Nazi symbols.

Can you shoot someone for stealing your property?

This is the question at the heart of the case. Like many US states, Oklahoma has laws that let people use force, including deadly force in some situations, against an intruder who unlawfully enters their home or occupied vehicle. These are often called "stand your ground" or castle doctrine laws.

In general, though, American law does not allow deadly force simply to protect property, and force used in self-defence must be reasonable in relation to the threat. A person running away across a yard with a flag in her hand poses no obvious danger to anyone. Firing at someone's back in that situation would be very hard to present as self-defence, which helps explain why prosecutors charged Feaster with shooting with intent to kill.

Why the case still resonates

The shooting happened weeks into the nationwide protests that followed the killing of George Floyd, at a time of intense debate about racism and extremist symbols in public life. For many people it was a stark reminder of how quickly a confrontation over a symbol can turn lethal when firearms are involved.

It also illustrates a simple point that holds whatever one thinks of the flag or of the young woman's choice: in the United States the answer to offensive speech, under the law, is more speech or a call to the police, and the answer to a petty theft is never a volley of rifle fire at someone running away.

Sources: NBC News: Oklahoma woman shot in back while trying to steal man's Nazi flag. Affidavit, footage and neighbour details as reported by the Independent in July 2020.

COMMENTS