Why Boston Removed the Lincoln Emancipation Statue

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-07-04.

Boston Votes to Remove Statue of Lincoln With a Kneeling Freed Man

The Emancipation Group in Park Square, Boston, before its removal: Abraham Lincoln stands with one hand raised over a kneeling freed man whose face was modelled on Archer Alexander.

At the end of June 2020 the Boston Art Commission voted unanimously to remove the Emancipation Group, a bronze statue showing Abraham Lincoln standing over a kneeling, shirtless Black man whose broken shackles lie at his wrists. The statue had stood in Park Square since 1879. Critics, including a petition with more than 12,000 signatures, argued that it presented a freed man as passive and grateful rather than as someone who had helped win his own freedom. Crews lifted it from its pedestal on 29 December 2020, and it went into storage.

The decision surprised many people, because the statue honours the president who led the Union through the Civil War and signed the Emancipation Proclamation. To understand why it came down, it helps to know where it came from and who the kneeling man really was.

The statue’s origins in Washington, D.C.

The Boston statue is a copy. The original, often called the Emancipation Memorial or Freedom’s Memorial, was designed by the American sculptor Thomas Ball, who made a small marble version after Lincoln’s assassination in 1865. The full-size bronze was cast in Munich and dedicated in Lincoln Park, Washington, D.C., on 14 April 1876, the eleventh anniversary of Lincoln’s death, with President Ulysses S. Grant in attendance.

Its funding story is remarkable. The campaign began with a five-dollar gift from Charlotte Scott, a formerly enslaved woman living in Marietta, Ohio, who gave the money on the day she heard that Lincoln had been killed. The Western Sanitary Commission, a St. Louis relief charity, took up the cause, and according to the National Park Service the money came only from freed people, most of them African American Union veterans.

Three years later, in 1879, the Boston showman and museum owner Moses Kimball, for whom Ball had once worked, paid for a copy and donated it to his city. The base carried the words “A race set free and the country at peace, Lincoln rests from his labors.”

Who was Archer Alexander?

The kneeling figure is not an anonymous symbol. Ball reworked its face from a photograph of Archer Alexander, a real man who had escaped slavery in Missouri.

Alexander was born around 1816 near Lexington, Virginia, and taken to Missouri as a young man. In February 1863 he overheard local slaveholders planning to sabotage a railroad bridge over Peruque Creek used by Union forces. He secretly warned Union soldiers, and when suspicion fell on him he fled. He was briefly recaptured, broke free, and reached St. Louis, where the minister and educator William Greenleaf Eliot sheltered and employed him and helped secure his freedom. His wife and daughters later escaped and joined him. Eliot later wrote his story, and it was Eliot who gave Ball the photograph in 1869.

Alexander died in St. Louis on 8 December 1879, the same year the Boston copy was unveiled. Genealogical research has since linked him to the boxer Muhammad Ali, reportedly his great-great-great-grandson. In other words, the man shown kneeling was someone who had risked his life to help the Union, which is exactly why critics felt the pose undersold him.

Criticism from the very beginning

Objections to the design are as old as the statue. Frederick Douglass gave the main speech at the 1876 dedication, offering a famously balanced judgement of Lincoln. A few days later he wrote to a Washington newspaper that the monument did not show the whole truth, and that he would like to see a Black man depicted standing “erect on his feet like a man.”

In Boston the modern campaign was led by local actor and activist Tory Bullock, who launched an online petition in 2020. He said he was inspired by the Black Lives Matter protests that followed the killing of George Floyd, and pointed out that the change had been won through a public, largely digital process rather than street protest.

The Art Commission agreed. In its statement it said: “For generations, Bostonians have called for its removal due to its racist depiction of a Black person.” It added that many people felt the statue suggested one man alone had ended slavery, ignoring the role of enslaved people, abolitionists and Black soldiers. Then-Mayor Martin Walsh supported the decision, saying residents and visitors had been uncomfortable with how the statue reduced the Black role in the abolitionist movement.

The case for keeping it

Not everyone welcomed the move. Some argued that removing a tribute to Lincoln, rather than to Confederate leaders, blurred an important distinction. Lincoln led the Union through a war in which Union deaths are commonly estimated at around 360,000, and he was assassinated days after its main armies surrendered.

Others pointed out that the original monument was paid for by freed people themselves, and that taking it down could erase that part of the story too. Historians Jonathan White and Scott Sandage have suggested another path for the Washington original: adding statues of Charlotte Scott and Frederick Douglass beside it to create a fuller “Emancipation Group” that puts Black Americans at the centre.

Where the statues are now

The Boston copy was lifted out of Park Square by crane on 29 December 2020 and placed in storage. The Art Commission said it hoped to find a new home where the statue could be shown with proper historical context, such as a museum, but no final location had been announced at the time of the most recent reports.

The Washington original still stands in Lincoln Park. In June 2020 Delegate Eleanor Holmes Norton announced plans for legislation to move it to a museum, and she reintroduced the bill in February 2021. Protesters at one point vowed to pull it down, and a temporary fence went up around it before being removed.

Why this statue matters

The Emancipation Group debate is less about Lincoln than about how a nation remembers emancipation. A sculpture made in the 1870s reflected the attitudes of its time, even when it was paid for by the very people it portrayed. Today many Americans want public art to show formerly enslaved people as active participants in their own liberation, men and women like Archer Alexander and Charlotte Scott, rather than as recipients of a gift.

Whether the statue returns to public view in a museum or stays in storage, its story is now better known than ever, and that may be its most useful legacy.

Sources: Wikipedia: Emancipation Memorial; Wikipedia: Archer Alexander; CNN: Boston votes to remove Lincoln statue; WBUR: Lincoln Emancipation statue removed in Boston; TheBlaze: Boston votes on Lincoln statue removal. Statue by Thomas Ball (1876; Boston copy 1879).

COMMENTS