First published July 28, 2020.

Do cat owners really have fewer heart attacks? The honest answer is: some studies have found that people who own or have owned a cat are less likely to die of a heart attack, but the evidence shows an association, not proof that cats protect the heart. The best-known cat study was smaller and narrower than many headlines suggested, and stronger data actually exists for dogs.
Below we look at what the research measured, where popular summaries went wrong, the likely reasons pet owners do better, and what this means if you are thinking about adopting an animal partly for your health.
The Minnesota cat study, in detail
The study usually behind the "cat owners have 30% fewer heart attacks" headline was led by Adnan Qureshi and colleagues at the Minnesota Stroke Institute and published in the Journal of Vascular and Interventional Neurology in January 2009.
It did not follow 4,000 cat owners for ten years, as is often repeated. Instead, the team used an existing US health survey, the second National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES II), carried out between 1976 and 1980, and its later mortality follow-up. The analysis included 4,435 adults, both pet owners and non-owners, and only those who had reported some kind of allergy and had been asked about pets. Participants were followed for a mean of about 13 years, with the abstract describing up to 20 years.
The key results were:
- People who had owned a cat in the past had a lower risk of dying from a heart attack (relative risk 0.63, roughly a third lower) than people who had never owned one.
- For people who owned a cat at the time of the survey, the difference was smaller and not statistically significant.
- For deaths from all cardiovascular disease, past cat ownership showed only a borderline trend.
- No protective link was seen for stroke, and dog ownership was not associated with fewer heart-attack deaths in this particular data set.
The authors themselves listed important limits. They had no measure of how long or how closely people lived with cats, the sample was restricted to people with allergies, heart-attack deaths came from death certificate codes, and the link might reflect the personalities of people who choose cats rather than anything the cats do. They called for better studies to confirm the finding.
What the dog research found
Two larger pieces of research published in October 2019 in Circulation: Cardiovascular Quality and Outcomes, a journal of the American Heart Association, are often blended together in news stories. They are worth separating.
A meta-analysis of nearly four million people
Caroline Kramer and colleagues pooled ten observational studies published between 1950 and 2019, covering about 3.8 million participants followed for an average of ten years. Dog owners had a 24% lower risk of death from any cause and a 31% lower risk of death from cardiovascular causes. Among people who had already had a heart attack or similar event, the reduction in all-cause mortality appeared even larger. The authors noted that their pooled estimates were not adjusted for other factors, so cause and effect cannot be established.
A Swedish registry study of heart attack and stroke survivors
Mwenya Mubanga, Tove Fall and colleagues used Swedish national registers to follow more than 180,000 heart-attack patients and more than 150,000 stroke patients aged 40 to 85. After a heart attack, dog owners living alone had a 33% lower risk of death than people living alone without a dog, and owners overall had a 21% lower risk. Results for stroke survivors were similar. The researchers stressed that unmeasured factors such as smoking could explain part of the difference.
Why pet owners might live longer
Researchers have suggested several plausible pathways, none of which is fully proven:
- Physical activity. Dogs need walking, which adds regular exercise. This helps explain dog findings but not cat findings.
- Stress and blood pressure. Stroking a calm animal can feel soothing, and lower everyday stress is linked to better heart health.
- Social connection. Pets give routine and companionship, which may matter most for people living alone, as the Swedish data hint.
- Purpose. Caring for an animal gives structure to the day, particularly for older people.
There is also a less romantic explanation: healthier, wealthier and more settled people are more able to take on a pet in the first place. Someone who is already seriously ill, frail or short of money is less likely to adopt a dog or cat. That kind of reverse causation can make pets look protective even if they are not.
Myths worth clearing up
- "Getting a cat cuts your heart-attack risk by 30%." No study shows that adopting a cat lowers an individual's risk by a set amount. The figure describes a group-level association in an older, allergy-limited sample.
- "Cats were never domesticated." Domestic cats are fully domesticated animals. They are thought to have largely tamed themselves by living near early farming communities and hunting rodents, which is why many of their behaviours still resemble those of wild cats.
- "Pet owners are more successful." A 2018 commercial survey of over-55s in the UK reportedly found pet owners more likely to call themselves successful or to have paid off a mortgage. Polls like this cannot show that pets cause success, and wealthier people are simply more likely to keep pets.
Should you get a pet for your heart?
For people who love animals, the research is encouraging: there is no sign that a cat or dog is bad for the heart, and plenty of reason to think companionship and routine are good for wellbeing. But a pet is a commitment of ten to twenty years, with costs for food, vet care and holidays, so the decision is better based on whether an animal fits your life than on a headline statistic.
A few practical points:
- If you have allergies, asthma or a weakened immune system, spend time with the type of animal first.
- Consider fostering or volunteering at a shelter before adopting, especially later in life.
- If you are recovering from a heart attack or stroke, or managing heart disease, talk to a doctor about exercise and lifestyle; a pet can be part of a healthy routine, not a replacement for treatment.
Cats and dogs will not replace medicine, but for many households they bring calm, laughter and a reason to get up in the morning. That alone makes them good company.
Sources: Qureshi et al., Journal of Vascular and Interventional Neurology, 2009; Kramer et al., Dog Ownership and Survival, 2019 (summary); Mubanga et al., Circulation: Cardiovascular Quality and Outcomes, 2019.

COMMENTS