Do Redheads Feel More Pain? What the MC1R Research Shows

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-07-28.

Red Hair and Research on Pain Responses

Short answer: red-haired people do not simply feel “more” pain, and they are not tougher than everyone else. What research shows is that the gene behind most red hair, MC1R, also seems to influence how the body handles some kinds of pain and some drugs. In several studies redheads needed more anaesthetic, were more sensitive to heat and cold pain, and responded differently to certain painkillers. Other studies found little difference at all. The picture is real but uneven, and worth knowing about if you have red hair and are heading for surgery or a dental appointment.

Why red hair and pain are linked at all

Red hair is uncommon worldwide. It is usually estimated at 1–2% of people overall and about 2–6% of people with north-western European ancestry. Scotland and Ireland have the highest shares: one estimate puts Scotland at around 13%, while a much older survey of more than half a million people found about 5%, and Ireland is generally placed close behind.

Most natural redheads carry two copies of a recessive variant of the MC1R gene on chromosome 16. That gene makes the melanocortin 1 receptor, which tells pigment cells whether to produce dark eumelanin or reddish pheomelanin. When the receptor works less well, the cells lean towards the red pigment, which is why two dark-haired parents who both carry the variant can have a red-haired child.

The receptor belongs to a family of melanocortin receptors that respond to hormones made from the same precursor molecule, POMC. That precursor is cut into pigment-signalling hormones and into beta-endorphin, one of the body’s own painkillers. Because pigment and pain chemistry share building blocks, scientists suspected early on that a change in MC1R might ripple into pain responses too.

Anaesthesia: the best-known finding

Anaesthetists had swapped stories about red-haired patients for years before anyone measured it. In 2004 a team led by Edwin Liem published a small study in Anesthesiology comparing red-haired and dark-haired women. To reach the same level of anaesthesia, the redheads needed roughly 19–20% more of the inhaled anaesthetic desflurane. Most of them carried MC1R variants.

A follow-up from the same group in 2005 found that red-haired women were slightly more sensitive to heat pain and that the local anaesthetic lidocaine, injected under the skin, worked less well for them. That fits with dental surveys in which red-haired patients reported more anxiety about treatment and were more likely to avoid it, possibly because injections had failed to numb them properly in the past.

Painkillers and pain thresholds

The story is not one-directional. Work by Jeffrey Mogil and colleagues in the early 2000s found that women with red-hair gene variants got a stronger pain-relieving effect from pentazocine, a kappa-opioid drug, than other women or men. Later studies suggested people with MC1R variants also respond more strongly to some mu-opioids, the family that includes morphine. Some experiments with electrical pain found redheads less sensitive, not more.

In 2021 a team led by David Fisher at Massachusetts General Hospital offered a possible mechanism in Science Advances. In red-haired mice, pigment cells released less POMC. That reduced a hormone that heightens pain through the melanocortin 4 receptor, while the pain-blocking opioid signalling stayed about the same. The result was a higher threshold before pain registered. The effect held even in albino mice that made no pigment, pointing to the receptor itself rather than hair colour. These were mouse experiments, and the authors did not show the same pathway in people.

What the studies do not show

Not every study agrees. A 2012 study of 468 surgical patients led by Paul Myles found no meaningful difference between redheads and dark-haired patients in recovery times or pain scores after surgery. Other work has found no difference in responses to anaesthetic or pain medication. As one review author put it to Live Science, the overall picture is “somewhat fuzzy”, partly because each study tested a different kind of pain.

Some of the common claims online therefore need correcting:

  • “Redheads feel more pain.” Only for some stimuli, such as heat and cold, and only in some studies. For other kinds of pain they may feel less.
  • “Redheads are tougher.” No study measures toughness. Different sensitivity is not the same as greater endurance or courage.
  • “Every redhead needs 20% more anaesthetic.” That figure comes from a small group of women. Dosing in real operations is adjusted to each patient by monitoring, whatever their hair colour.
  • “Dyed red hair counts.” The effect, if any, comes from the gene, not the colour. Some dark-haired people carry one copy of the variant too.

Sunlight, vitamin D and the spread of red hair

Why did a variant that weakens pigment become common in north-western Europe? A long-standing idea, proposed in the 1970s, is that pale skin helps the body make vitamin D in places with weak sunlight, where darker skin would raise the risk of deficiency and rickets. Red hair often comes with very fair skin, so it may have travelled alongside that advantage, or simply drifted to high frequencies in small, isolated populations.

Low vitamin D has been studied as one of several possible contributors to multiple sclerosis, which is unusually common in Scotland. The causes of MS are not fully understood, and red hair itself has not been shown to cause it. The same fair skin does carry a higher risk of sunburn and skin cancer where ultraviolet light is strong, which matters far more day to day than any pain difference.

A long history of prejudice

Red hair has drawn suspicion for centuries. Medieval writers linked it to witches and werewolves, European painters often gave Judas red hair, and the Spanish Inquisition is recorded as treating it as a sign of Jewish ancestry. On stage, Shylock was traditionally played in a red wig, and Dickens gave Fagin red hair. In the nineteenth century pseudo-scientists even claimed a link with criminality.

The teasing has continued into modern times, from greeting cards withdrawn after complaints to schoolyard jokes. Today red hair is also widely admired for its rarity, as in these portraits of redheads, but it remains one of the few physical traits people still feel free to mock.

Practical takeaways if you have red hair

  • Mention your natural hair colour, or any past experience of anaesthetic not working well, to your anaesthetist, surgeon or dentist before a procedure. They can take it into account.
  • If a local anaesthetic has not fully numbed you during dental work, say so straight away. Waiting longer or adding more is routine.
  • Do not change the dose of any painkiller on your own because of hair colour. If you have questions about pain relief, talk to a doctor or pharmacist.
  • Protect fair skin from strong sun with shade, clothing and sunscreen, and have new or changing moles checked.

Sources: PubMed: Liem EB et al., Anesthetic requirement is increased in redheads, Anesthesiology 2004; NIH Research Matters, 20 April 2021: Study finds link between red hair and pain threshold; Live Science: Do redheads really need more anesthesia?; Wikipedia: Red hair

COMMENTS