Originally published 2020-07-28.
Do men really look more attractive when they already have a partner? Research suggests there is something to it, though less than the internet claims. Scientists call the effect mate-choice copying: our judgement of a potential partner shifts depending on whether other people seem to have chosen them. A 2018 review of human studies found that women, on average, rated men as more desirable when the men were pictured alongside a woman. For men rating women the effect was unclear, and the studies varied a great deal.
Here is where the idea came from, what the evidence in people actually shows, and why it is a poor basis for dating strategy.
What mate-choice copying means
Most of us like to think our tastes are entirely our own. Mate-choice copying, also called non-independent mate choice, describes something different: an individual’s preferences moving towards the choices made by others. It is a form of social learning, the same broad family of behaviour that leads animals to copy where others feed or which foods they avoid.
The logic is simple. Judging a potential mate takes time and carries risk. If you can watch someone else’s choice, you get information for free. A male who has already been accepted by one female has, in effect, passed a test. Biologists suggest copying may be especially useful for inexperienced individuals and when time is short, for example at the end of a breeding season.
It started with guppies
The modern study of copying grew out of experiments with guppies, the small tropical fish familiar from home aquariums. In work led by the biologist Lee Dugatkin in the early 1990s, female guppies, which normally favour the most orange males, could be persuaded to pick a duller male if they had just watched another female appear to choose him. Social information was strong enough to override a visible preference.
Later research found similar behaviour in a surprising range of animals: fruit flies, sailfin and Atlantic mollies, the ocellated wrasse, black grouse, Gouldian finches, Norway rats and mice. Guppy studies also showed that copying has rules. Females copy larger, presumably more experienced females more readily than small ones, so the reputation of the “model” matters, not just the act of choosing.
Animal work has uncovered some of the biology, too. Experiments in mice point to a role for the hormone oxytocin: females lacking it struggled to recognise the demonstrators and showed less interest in males they had seen mating.
What studies with people show
Testing this in humans is trickier, because people can’t simply be released into a tank. Most experiments show participants photographs of a potential partner, sometimes on his or her own and sometimes next to someone of the opposite sex, then ask how attractive or desirable that person seems.
The most useful summary is a systematic review and meta-analysis published in 2018 in Adaptive Human Behavior and Physiology by Amany Gouda-Vossos, Shinichi Nakagawa, Barnaby Dixson and Robert Brooks. Pooling the available experiments, they found:
- Women tended to rate men higher when the man was shown with a woman.
- There was no clear effect when men rated women in the same kind of set-up.
- When studies instead made the partner look more desirable, both sexes rated the target higher. In other words, a man or a woman can seem more appealing next to an attractive companion.
- Results varied widely between studies, and the authors detected moderate publication bias in favour of positive findings.
A 2010 study in Evolution and Human Behavior by Skyler Place, Peter Todd, Lars Penke and Jens Asendorpf tried something closer to real life. Participants watched videos of actual speed dates. Both men and women reported more interest in people whose dates appeared to go well, and the relative attractiveness of the watcher and the watched affected who copied whom.
Why it might happen
Researchers offer several overlapping explanations:
- Information shortcut. A partner is a signal of qualities that are hard to judge from a photo, such as kindness, reliability or social skill. If someone has chosen him, he has probably passed a few tests.
- Quality of the chooser. A desirable partner is a stronger endorsement, which may be why the attractiveness of the companion matters in the studies.
- Social learning in general. Humans copy one another constantly, from fashion to food. Attraction may simply follow the same habit.
Biologists also warn that some apparent copying has simpler causes, such as shared environment, related individuals having similar genetic preferences, or a person being drawn to where others gather rather than to a specific individual. Separating real copying from these alternatives is one of the field’s ongoing challenges.
Myths and overstatements
“Women always want taken men.” No. The human effect is modest on average, inconsistent across studies and measured mostly through ratings of photographs, not real choices. Rating a picture is very different from pursuing a relationship.
“It is all evolution.” Evolutionary explanations are plausible but hard to test directly in people. Culture, personal experience and simple curiosity can produce similar results.
“Celebrity crushes prove it.” It is tempting to link copying to fans adoring the same pop stars, and the idea is often repeated. It has not been tested directly, and fame involves many other factors, from exposure to marketing.
“It only works on women.” The speed-dating study found copying in both sexes, and the meta-analysis found that a desirable companion boosted ratings for men and women alike.
What to take from it
The research is interesting because it shows that attraction is partly social. We look to others for clues, often without realising it. That is worth knowing if you have ever wondered why a friend suddenly seemed more appealing once someone else showed interest.
It is not a recipe for dating. You can’t usefully “borrow” a partner to look desirable, and the qualities that make the effect work, being liked and trusted by people who know you, are better built honestly. Being kind, socially engaged and well regarded by friends sends the same kind of signal, with none of the drawbacks. And existing relationships deserve respect, whatever a laboratory rating might suggest.
Sources: Gouda-Vossos et al., Adaptive Human Behavior and Physiology (2018); Place et al., Evolution and Human Behavior (2010); Mate choice copying (Wikipedia); Science News: Do people flirt like guppies?

COMMENTS