Originally published 2020-07-15.

In July 2020, a group of 83 very wealthy people from seven countries published an open letter with an unusual request: raise our taxes. Calling themselves Millionaires for Humanity, they asked governments to put a permanent tax increase on the richest people in the world to help pay for recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic. Their short answer to how it should happen was blunt: "Tax us. Tax us. Tax us."
The signatories included Ben & Jerry's co-founder Jerry Greenfield, filmmaker and Disney heir Abigail Disney, her brother Tim Disney, British writer and director Richard Curtis, and New Zealand businessman Sir Stephen Tindall, founder of The Warehouse Group. Most of the signers lived in the United States, with others from countries including the United Kingdom, Germany and New Zealand.
Below is what the letter actually asked for, why it appeared when it did, who organised it, and what the debate around taxing great wealth looks like when you set the headlines aside.
What the letter asked governments to do
The letter was addressed to "fellow global citizens" and to the leaders who would decide how the bill for the pandemic would be paid. Its central argument was that the scale of the crisis was too large for charity. Health systems, schools, unemployment support and public safety measures all needed money for years to come, and the signers said the fairest place to find it was at the very top of the wealth ladder.
The authors were careful to say what they were not. They were not nurses in intensive care units, not ambulance drivers, not the people stacking supermarket shelves or delivering food to quarantined homes. What they did have, they wrote, was a great deal of money. CNBC reported that the letter described essential workers as "grossly underpaid for the burden they carry" and argued that the problems ahead could not be solved through philanthropy, however generous.
Their proposed fix was not a one-off donation or a temporary emergency levy. They wanted a lasting change in how the wealthiest people are taxed, and they summed up the timing and size they had in mind in three words: "Immediately. Substantially. Permanently."
Why July 2020?
The timing was deliberate. The letter was released just before a virtual meeting of G20 finance ministers and central bank governors, and as European leaders prepared for a special summit in Brussels on the EU's recovery package. Campaigners hoped to put wealth taxation on the agenda while governments were working out how to fund record spending.
The economic background was grim. Lockdowns had shut whole sectors, tens of millions of people had lost work, and the downturn was widely compared to the Great Depression of the 1930s. The World Bank warned that the pandemic could push tens of millions more people into extreme poverty, while half of the world's workforce was in insecure jobs with little protection.
At the same time, the fortunes of the richest people were growing. Global Citizen, which covered the launch, noted that Jeff Bezos alone had added around $31 billion to his wealth during 2020, and Oxfam estimated that the world's 2,150 billionaires held more wealth than the poorest 4.6 billion people combined. That contrast is exactly what the letter's authors wanted to highlight.
Who organised it and who signed
Millionaires for Humanity was not a spontaneous gathering of strangers. The letter was circulated by a coalition of campaign groups: Patriotic Millionaires, Oxfam, Human Act, Tax Justice UK, the Club of Rome, Resource Justice and Bridging Ventures. Several of these groups had already been pushing for higher taxes on top incomes and large fortunes before the pandemic.
Among the best-known names:
- Jerry Greenfield, who co-founded Ben & Jerry's ice cream with Ben Cohen in Vermont in 1978.
- Abigail Disney, a documentary filmmaker and grandniece of Walt Disney, who has spoken often about executive pay and inequality.
- Tim Disney, her brother, a film producer.
- Richard Curtis, the British screenwriter behind Four Weddings and a Funeral and Love Actually, and a co-founder of Comic Relief.
- Sir Stephen Tindall, founder of New Zealand's The Warehouse Group and one of that country's richest people.
Some members of the same network had made similar appeals before. In January 2020, at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Patriotic Millionaires and others signed a letter often summarised as "Millionaires Against Pitchforks", warning that extreme inequality threatens social stability.
😱 does this mean I have to stop blaming the rich for everything?
— Darth Hadenoughious (@Chrispy29851) July 13, 2020
Nah ill just specify billionaires https://t.co/ubVqoYwD9c
(This post is no longer available on X.)
Not everyone online was won over. One widely shared reply joked that the letter would make it harder to blame "the rich" for everything, and suggested simply switching the target to billionaires. That quip, now deleted, captured a real distinction in the debate: a household with a few million dollars and a billionaire are in very different positions.
Does taxing the very rich actually work?
The letter made a moral argument, but whether a wealth tax works in practice depends on design. Economists who support such taxes, such as Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman, argue that a small annual levy on fortunes above a high threshold could raise significant revenue and slow the concentration of wealth. Critics point to practical problems.
The arguments in favour
- Much of the wealth of the very richest sits in shares and property that rise in value without ever being taxed as income.
- Even a low rate on a very narrow group can raise meaningful sums because so much wealth is concentrated at the top.
- Supporters say it would make the tax system fairer at a time when ordinary workers carried the heaviest burden of the crisis.
The arguments against
- Valuing private businesses, art and other assets every year is difficult and costly.
- Several European countries, including France and Sweden, abolished their wealth taxes after concerns about capital flight and low revenue.
- The wealthy can move assets or residence, so many economists say international cooperation, such as the OECD's global minimum corporate tax, matters as much as national laws.
In other words, the number of millionaires who sign a letter does not decide whether a tax raises money. The threshold, the rate, enforcement and what the revenue is spent on make the difference.
What happened next
Governments did not respond with sweeping new wealth taxes in 2020. Most funded their pandemic spending through borrowing, and the G20 focused on debt relief for poorer countries and broader recovery plans. Several countries did debate new measures in the following years, Argentina introduced a one-off "solidarity contribution" on large fortunes in December 2020, and international talks on a minimum tax for multinational companies moved forward.
The Millionaires for Humanity group and its allies kept campaigning. Patriotic Millionaires returned to Davos in 2022 with a new call for wealth taxes, and the theme has come up again at each major economic summit since.
Why the letter still matters
The value of a letter like this is not that it changes the law overnight. It changes who is speaking. When people who would pay the tax argue for it, they weaken the common claim that higher taxes on wealth are simply envy or an attack on success.
For readers, the useful takeaways are simple:
- A "wealth tax" is different from higher income tax rates: it targets what people own, not what they earn in a year.
- Proposals usually apply only to very large fortunes, often tens of millions of dollars and above, not to ordinary savers or homeowners.
- Whether such a tax succeeds depends on detailed design and international cooperation, which is why it remains a live debate.
The signers knew their letter would not settle the argument. Their aim was to make sure that, when governments decided who would pay for the pandemic, the richest people's own offer to pay more was on the table.
Sources: Global Citizen: Millionaires for Humanity; CNBC, 13 July 2020; Oxfam New Zealand, 14 July 2020.

COMMENTS