Hagia Sophia's Mosque Conversion and European Human Rights Law

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published July 27, 2020.

Athens Law Professor Challenged Hagia Sophia's Mosque Conversion in 2020

In July 2020 Turkey turned Hagia Sophia in Istanbul from a museum back into a mosque. Days later Spyros Vlachopoulos, a professor of constitutional law at the National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, argued in the Greek newspaper Kathimerini that the move clashed with European human rights law and urged Europe's human rights court to respond more firmly. His piece, published on 21 July 2020, was one of the more detailed legal arguments made against the conversion.

This article explains what happened to Hagia Sophia, what the professor argued, where the legal argument is strong and where it is weaker, and what the building is like for visitors today.

What Turkey decided in July 2020

On 10 July 2020 Turkey's highest administrative court, the Council of State, annulled the 1934 cabinet decision that had made Hagia Sophia a museum, ruling that the building could be used only as a mosque. The same day President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan signed a decree handing it to the state religious authority, the Diyanet. Muslim Friday prayers were held there on 24 July 2020 for the first time in 86 years.

The government said the building would stay open to visitors of all faiths and that its Christian mosaics would be protected. Critics at home and abroad saw the decision as a move to rally Erdoğan's religious-conservative supporters at a time of economic trouble, and as a symbolic break with the secular republic founded by Atatürk. Greece, the United States, Russia, the World Council of Churches, the International Association of Byzantine Studies and UNESCO all criticised it, and the Turkish novelist Orhan Pamuk publicly denounced it.

A short history of Hagia Sophia

  • 537: The Byzantine emperor Justinian I completed the present building, designed by Isidore of Miletus and Anthemius of Tralles. For nearly a thousand years it was the cathedral of Constantinople and the heart of Eastern Orthodox Christianity.
  • 1453: After the Ottoman conquest of Constantinople on 29 May, Sultan Mehmed II converted it into a mosque and attended Friday prayers there on 1 June. Minarets were added, and many mosaics were later plastered over. (Some accounts wrongly date the conversion to the 1500s.)
  • 1934–35: The government of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk turned it into a museum, which opened in 1935. Restorers uncovered many of the Byzantine mosaics.
  • 1985: UNESCO inscribed the "Historic Areas of Istanbul", which include Hagia Sophia, on the World Heritage List.
  • 2020: Reconverted into a mosque.

A common error is to say Hagia Sophia was a "UNESCO site since the 1920s" or that UNESCO "managed" it. It became a museum in the mid-1930s, its World Heritage listing came in 1985, and management has always been Turkey's responsibility. Museum status and World Heritage status are separate things.

What Professor Vlachopoulos argued

Vlachopoulos's case rested on the European Convention on Human Rights, which Turkey has signed as a member of the Council of Europe. In his reading, removing museum status from a site of world cultural heritage could violate rights protected by the Convention, including Article 8 on respect for private life, which the European Court of Human Rights has sometimes interpreted broadly to include aspects of cultural identity. He also said the case raised questions about the rights of Turkey's Christian minority.

He acknowledged that the Strasbourg court's past case law did not clearly support such a claim, and he presented the conversion as an opportunity for the court to rethink its precedent. His sharpest point was about credibility: he wrote that the court "cannot cower when faced with an offense on sites of cultural heritage" if it wants to keep its image as a guardian of human rights.

He ended with a broader principle. Human rights usually protect minorities against majorities, he argued, but sometimes they must also protect the rights of future generations to unobstructed access to sites of global cultural heritage.

How strong is the legal argument?

The professor's piece is an opinion about how the law should develop, not a description of settled law, and it is worth being clear about that:

  • No museum clause. The European Convention on Human Rights does not mention museums or UNESCO and contains no rule requiring UNESCO's consent before a building's use changes. Some early English-language summaries of the professor's letter garbled this point.
  • UNESCO is a UN agency, not a private organisation, and it does not run Hagia Sophia. What it does have is the 1972 World Heritage Convention, under which states must notify UNESCO in advance of changes that could affect a listed site. On 10 July 2020 UNESCO said Turkey had made the change without prior dialogue and asked it to avoid harming the site's universal value.
  • Hard cases for Strasbourg. Cultural-heritage claims are difficult to bring under the Convention, which mostly protects identifiable individuals, and the court generally gives states wide discretion over religious matters. No judgment from the European Court of Human Rights on the conversion has been reported.

That does not make the argument pointless. Legal scholars often use high-profile cases to push courts toward new interpretations, and the professor's case for a right of access to shared heritage connects with a real debate in international law about who heritage belongs to.

Why it matters to Greece and Orthodox Christians

For Greeks and for Orthodox Christians worldwide, Hagia Sophia is not just a monument. It is the "Great Church" of Byzantium, where the city's last Christian liturgy was held on the eve of its fall in 1453, and it remains a symbol of a civilisation and of the Greek communities that lived in Constantinople for centuries. The 2020 decision came amid other tensions between Athens and Ankara that summer, including disputes over maritime boundaries in the eastern Mediterranean.

In August 2020 Turkey also converted the Chora Church, another Byzantine monument famous for its mosaics and frescoes, from a museum into a mosque. Our related article covers how UN experts urged that Hagia Sophia remain a meeting place of cultures.

Visiting Hagia Sophia today

Hagia Sophia remains open to visitors outside prayer times. Since 2024 the main ground floor has been largely reserved for worshippers, while foreign tourists enter the upper galleries, where many of the finest mosaics are. Since 15 January 2024 foreign visitors have paid an entrance fee, women are asked to cover their hair, and modest dress is expected. Some mosaics are screened or lit differently during prayers, so a visit outside prayer hours gives the best view.

The legal debate has not been resolved, and for many people the question is less about law than about whether a building that belonged to so many cultures can be shared fairly.

Sources: Spyros Vlachopoulos in Kathimerini, 21 July 2020; UNESCO statement on Hagia Sophia, 10 July 2020; UNESCO: Historic Areas of Istanbul; Wikipedia: Hagia Sophia.

COMMENTS