Why Greece, Russia and the US Opposed Hagia Sophia's Conversion

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-07-07.

International Objections to Turning Hagia Sophia Into a Mosque

In the summer of 2020, Turkey moved to turn Hagia Sophia in Istanbul from a museum back into a mosque, and governments and church leaders around the world objected. Greece and the Ecumenical Patriarch of Constantinople led the criticism, the Russian Orthodox Church called the plan a threat to Christian civilisation, and the United States urged Turkey to keep the building as a museum open to all. Turkey went ahead anyway: on 10 July 2020 a court cleared the way, and President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan ordered the building reopened for Muslim worship.

To understand why a single building drew such strong reactions, it helps to know its history, the legal steps Turkey took, and what each objecting party actually said.

Fifteen centuries in one building

The Hagia Sophia that stands today was built on the orders of the Byzantine emperor Justinian I between 532 and 537, after an earlier church on the site burned during the Nika riots. Its architects, Anthemius of Tralles and Isidore of Miletus, crowned it with a vast dome that seemed to float above the nave. When part of the dome collapsed after an earthquake in 558, it was rebuilt higher, giving the interior a height of about 55 metres.

For more than 900 years it was the cathedral of Constantinople and the heart of Orthodox Christianity. The only break came after the Fourth Crusade sacked the city in 1204, when Latin crusaders used it as a Catholic cathedral until the Byzantines retook the city in 1261.

When the Ottoman sultan Mehmed II captured Constantinople on 29 May 1453, he converted the cathedral into a mosque, and the first Friday prayer was held there days later. Minarets were added over time, and for almost five centuries it served as one of the most important mosques of the Ottoman Empire.

After the founding of the Turkish Republic, a government decision in 1934 turned it into a museum, which opened to visitors in 1935. In 1985 UNESCO inscribed the Historic Areas of Istanbul on the World Heritage List, citing Hagia Sophia as a unique architectural masterpiece and a model for a whole family of later churches and mosques. By 2019 it was Turkey's most visited tourist attraction.

How the 2020 conversion unfolded

Calls to restore Hagia Sophia as a mosque had circulated among Turkish nationalist and Islamist groups for decades, and Erdoğan had supported symbolic steps in that direction for several years. On 29 May 2020, the 567th anniversary of the Ottoman conquest, he announced that the Al-Fath surah, the Quran's chapter known as "The Victory", would be recited inside the building along with prayers as part of the annual conquest commemorations. The recitation went ahead and was broadcast.

The decisive step came on 10 July 2020, when Turkey's highest administrative court, the Council of State, annulled the 1934 decision that had made the building a museum. Within hours Erdoğan signed a decree handing it to the country's religious affairs authority. The first Friday prayers took place on 24 July 2020.

Turkish officials said the building would stay open to visitors of all faiths outside prayer times and that Christian mosaics would be screened during prayers rather than removed. Since 15 January 2024, foreign visitors have had to pay an entrance fee, and women are asked to cover their hair inside.

Greece and the Ecumenical Patriarch

For Greeks, Hagia Sophia is not just a monument but a symbol of Byzantine and Orthodox identity, and the fall of Constantinople is still remembered as a national tragedy. After the May 2020 recitation, Greece's Foreign Ministry called it "an unacceptable attempt to alter its monumental character" and urged Turkey to honour its obligations under the World Heritage Convention and as a UNESCO member.

Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew, the spiritual leader of the world's Orthodox Christians, whose seat is in Istanbul, spoke out on 30 June 2020. He warned that converting the building would turn "millions of Christians around the world against Islam" and said he hoped wisdom and reason would prevail. In an interview a few weeks earlier he had said he was saddened that a heritage meant to unite people was instead dividing them.

Russia and the Russian Orthodox Church

Russia's response came on two levels. The Kremlin was cautious: spokesman Dmitry Peskov said the matter was an internal Turkish affair, while expressing hope that the building's World Heritage status would be respected. Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Vershinin made a similar point about its global significance.

The Russian Orthodox Church was far more forceful. On 6 July 2020 Patriarch Kirill said he was deeply concerned, describing Hagia Sophia as one of the greatest monuments of Christian culture. "A threat to Hagia Sophia is a threat to the whole of Christian civilization," he said, adding that changing its neutral status would cause deep pain in Russia.

The United States, UNESCO and others

The U.S. State Department, in a statement issued by Secretary of State Mike Pompeo at the start of July 2020, praised Turkey for running the building as a museum for nearly a century and urged it to keep that status, so that Hagia Sophia would remain accessible to everyone and reflect the diverse history of the Turkish Republic. It was a rare moment when Washington and Moscow found themselves on the same side of an argument.

After the decision, UNESCO condemned the change and asked Turkey to explain how it would preserve the site's universal value. The World Council of Churches, the International Association of Byzantine Studies and Turkey's own secular opposition also criticised the move. Several Muslim leaders in Turkey and abroad welcomed it.

Why the conversion mattered so much

Supporters in Turkey framed the decision as a question of national sovereignty and the reversal of a decision they saw as imposed by the secular founders of the republic. Critics, including many Turks, saw it as a political move aimed at a religious-nationalist voter base at a time of economic strain and the pandemic.

Internationally, the change raised several distinct questions that often got blended together. One is religious use: mosques and churches around the world are active places of worship. Another is heritage protection: UNESCO status brings obligations to preserve a site's value, which Turkey said it would respect. A third is symbolism: for Orthodox Christians and for Greece, turning the museum, a space shared by all faiths, back into a mosque felt like a reassertion of the 1453 conquest itself.

The building is still open to tourists, and its mosaics survive. But its status as a neutral museum, which had stood for 85 years, ended in July 2020, and the episode added to the strain in Turkey's relations with Greece, with Orthodox churches and with many Western governments.

Sources: Wikipedia: Hagia Sophia; UNESCO World Heritage Centre: Historic Areas of Istanbul; Middle East Eye: Quran recitation at Hagia Sophia (29 May 2020); Greek City Times: Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew warns (30 June 2020); Arab News: Russian reactions (6 July 2020); Africanews: Hagia Sophia reopens for first Muslim Friday prayers (24 July 2020).

COMMENTS