UN Experts Urged Turkey to Keep Hagia Sophia Open to All in 2020

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-08-07.

UN Experts Urged Protection of Hagia Sophia's Shared Cultural Role in 2020

In July 2020 Turkey turned Hagia Sophia in Istanbul from a museum back into a working mosque. At the end of that month, two independent human rights experts appointed by the United Nations Human Rights Council publicly urged the Turkish government to keep the building what it had been for most of the previous century: a place where people of every faith and none could meet and share a common heritage. They warned that the change risked dividing communities and asked Ankara to consult everyone with a stake in the site.

The experts could not overturn the decision, and Turkey did not reverse it. But their statement remains a clear summary of why the conversion worried heritage specialists, Christian communities and many governments. Below is what they said, who they are, and the long history that explains why this one building stirs such strong feelings.

What the UN experts said

The statement came from Karima Bennoune, the UN Special Rapporteur in the field of cultural rights, and Ahmed Shaheed, the Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief. They described the monument as having "outstanding universal value" and asked that it be kept as an inter-cultural space "reflecting the diversity and complexity of Turkey and its history."

Their concerns fell into a few groups:

  • Division instead of unity. Bennoune and Shaheed said that "it would be an historic mistake at this difficult global moment" to take steps that split religious and cultural groups in Turkey and abroad.
  • One story told over many. They feared that turning a site with layered Christian, Muslim and secular meaning into a single-faith monument could reflect a supremacist view of history.
  • Access and minorities. They worried about whether people of all faiths, and non-believers, would still be able to visit and enjoy the site, and about the safety and equal treatment of religious minorities, including Christians.
  • Conservation and process. They said the decision had been carried out hastily, with no proper prior consultation, and pointed to conflicting reports about how the building and its art would be cared for.

They added that symbolism at the first Friday prayers, including conquest-themed language and a sword displayed during the service, had heightened their concern. They also echoed UNESCO, which had said that changing a site with World Heritage status requires notice to the organisation and consultation with all stakeholders.

Who are UN special rapporteurs?

Special rapporteurs belong to what the UN calls its "special procedures." They are independent experts appointed by the Human Rights Council to monitor particular themes or countries. They serve in a personal capacity, are not employees of the UN or of any government, and are not paid for this work.

That independence is both their strength and their limit. Their statements carry moral and legal weight because they interpret international human rights standards, but they are not decisions of the Council as a whole, and they cannot force a government to act. When headlines said "the UN Human Rights Council" had spoken out, it was more accurate to say that two of its appointed experts had.

From Byzantine cathedral to Ottoman mosque

Hagia Sophia, Greek for "Holy Wisdom," was built between 532 and 537 on the orders of the Byzantine emperor Justinian I, designed by the mathematicians and architects Anthemius of Tralles and Isidore of Miletus. Its enormous dome, carried on curved triangular supports called pendentives, made it the largest interior space in the world at the time and influenced church and mosque design for centuries.

For more than 900 years it was the cathedral of Constantinople and the heart of Eastern Christianity, where emperors were crowned. During the Fourth Crusade in 1204 western crusaders sacked the city and turned the church into a Latin Catholic cathedral for several decades. Many Orthodox Christians still remember that episode bitterly.

An older version of this story sometimes says the building became a mosque "in the 1500s." In fact the change came in 1453, immediately after Sultan Mehmed II conquered Constantinople. The Ottomans added minarets, a mihrab and other Islamic features, and later sultans covered many of the Christian mosaics with plaster. For nearly five centuries it served as one of the empire's most important mosques.

The museum years, 1934 to 2020

After the fall of the Ottoman Empire, the new secular Turkish Republic under Mustafa Kemal Atatürk took the building out of religious use. A government decision in 1934 made it a museum, and it opened to visitors in 1935. Restorers uncovered many of the Byzantine mosaics, so visitors could see Christian and Islamic art side by side.

It is sometimes said that from the 1930s the building was "a place for all religions." More precisely, it was a museum for everyone: not a site of regular worship for any faith, but a shared monument. In 1985 UNESCO listed it as part of the Historic Areas of Istanbul World Heritage Site, and by 2019 it was Turkey's most visited tourist attraction.

How the 2020 conversion happened

Calls by Turkish nationalist and religious groups to reopen Hagia Sophia for Muslim prayer had grown for years. On 10 July 2020 Turkey's highest administrative court, the Council of State, annulled the 1934 decision that had created the museum. The same day President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan signed a decree handing the building to the country's religious affairs directorate. The first Friday prayers took place on 24 July 2020, the first Muslim prayers there in nearly a century, with Erdoğan among those taking part.

The Turkish government said the building would stay open to visitors of all faiths outside prayer times and that its Christian images would be preserved, reportedly with some covered by curtains or special lighting during prayers. It argued that the decision was a matter of national sovereignty.

Other countries and institutions disagreed. Greece, the United States and Russia were among the governments that criticised the move, along with UNESCO, the World Council of Churches, the International Association of Byzantine Studies and the Ecumenical Patriarch of Constantinople. Within Turkey the opposition and novelist Orhan Pamuk also objected, while several Muslim leaders in Turkey and abroad welcomed the decision. Critics described it as an appeal to Erdoğan's conservative religious supporters; the government rejected that view.

Some responses were symbolic. In Syria, a smaller replica of Hagia Sophia was planned with Russian support as a gesture of solidarity between faiths.

Hagia Sophia today

Hagia Sophia remains a mosque and is still open to tourists outside prayer times. In 2024 Turkish authorities reorganised visits: the upper galleries reopened to visitors, and since 15 January 2024 foreign tourists have had to pay an entrance fee, while worshippers continue to use the prayer hall.

The debate the UN experts described has not gone away. For many Orthodox Christians, and for Greeks in particular, Hagia Sophia is the spiritual centre of their tradition. For many Turkish Muslims it is a symbol of the 1453 conquest and of Ottoman heritage. The experts' central request was that a monument with both histories should be managed in a way that respects both, through dialogue rather than a decision taken by one side alone.

Sources: UN News, July 2020: Keep Turkey's Hagia Sophia "a space for meeting of cultures", UN rights experts urge; Wikipedia: Hagia Sophia; The New Daily / AAP, 24 July 2020.

COMMENTS