Originally published 2020-06-26.
In June 2020 NATO opened an inquiry after France accused Turkish warships of acting aggressively toward a French frigate in the Mediterranean. France said that on 10 June its ship, the Courbet, was trying to check a cargo vessel suspected of carrying weapons to Libya in breach of a UN arms embargo when escorting Turkish frigates locked their fire-control radar on it three times. Turkey denied the account. The NATO investigation did not publicly settle the dispute, and France responded by suspending its part in a NATO naval mission.

The episode was unusual because it set two NATO allies against each other at sea, and because it exposed how deeply foreign powers were involved in Libya's civil war. Below is a clear account of what each side said, why the arms embargo mattered, and how the row played out over the following months.
What happened at sea on 10 June 2020
The ship at the centre of the incident was the Çirkin, a Tanzanian-flagged cargo vessel sailing toward Libya under the escort of Turkish navy frigates. It was suspected of carrying military equipment to forces in western Libya.
Earlier that same day, according to the European Union, the Greek frigate Spetsai, working for the EU's arms-embargo mission Operation Irini, had tried to inspect the Çirkin and backed off after warnings from the Turkish escort. Later, the French frigate Courbet, operating under NATO's Sea Guardian maritime mission, approached the cargo ship.
French Armed Forces Minister Florence Parly gave France's version to NATO defence ministers. She said the Turkish ships turned off their identification transponders, refused to say where the convoy was heading, and illuminated the Courbet with targeting radar, a step that signals readiness to fire. Parly called the act "extremely aggressive" and said eight European allies supported France's concerns.
How NATO responded
France raised the incident at a meeting of NATO defence ministers in mid-June. Afterwards Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg told reporters that several allies had discussed it, and that NATO military authorities were investigating to bring full clarity to what happened.
NATO Secretary General @jensstoltenberg: “The incident in the Mediterranean was addressed in the meeting by several Allies. My message is that we have made sure that NATO military authorities are investigating the incident to bring full clarity into what happened.” https://t.co/gVz9hd8w5b
— Ryan Browne (@rabrowne75) June 19, 2020
(This post is no longer available on X.)
It is worth being precise about what that meant. Opening an inquiry was a procedural response to a complaint from a member state. It did not mean NATO had concluded that Turkey was smuggling arms, and NATO never published a finding to that effect. The question of what the Çirkin carried was handled separately by the EU.
The war in Libya and the arms embargo
To understand the stakes, it helps to know the conflict. Since 2014 Libya had been split between rival authorities. By 2020 the main contest was between the UN-recognised Government of National Accord (GNA) in Tripoli and the Libyan National Army (LNA) of commander Khalifa Haftar, based in the east.
Outside powers took sides. Turkey and Qatar backed the GNA, and in early 2020 Turkey openly sent military advisers, drones and equipment to help it. The United Arab Emirates, Egypt and, according to many reports, Russian private military contractors supported Haftar. The GNA accused France of favouring Haftar too, which Paris denied.
In April 2019 Haftar launched an offensive on Tripoli. With Turkish help, the GNA pushed his forces back in spring 2020 and began eyeing the coastal city of Sirte. Egypt's President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi warned in June 2020 that Egypt had the right to intervene if GNA forces advanced further, raising fears of a wider regional war.
All of this took place under a UN arms embargo on Libya in force since 2011. The EU launched Operation Irini on 31 March 2020 specifically to enforce it at sea. Any shipment of weapons to either side, whoever sent it, would breach the embargo.
Turkey's side of the story
Turkey rejected France's account from the start. Turkish officials denied that their frigates had locked radar on the Courbet, and said the French ship had behaved aggressively. Ankara described the Çirkin's cargo as humanitarian aid. Turkey's ambassador in Paris, Ismail Hakki Musa, later told French senators that the NATO investigation had been inconclusive and did not support France's claims.
More broadly, Turkey argued that Operation Irini was biased, since it focused on sea routes used to supply the GNA while much of the support for Haftar arrived by land or air. Turkey has repeatedly refused permission for inspections of Turkish-flagged ships under the mission.
France steps back, and the EU acts
Unhappy with the outcome, France told NATO on 1 July 2020 that it was temporarily suspending its participation in Sea Guardian. It set out four demands: a renewed commitment by allies to the Libya embargo, an end to the use of NATO call signs during national operations, better coordination between NATO and EU missions, and measures to prevent similar incidents.
The EU moved separately. In September 2020 it imposed sanctions on Avrasya Shipping, the Turkish operator of the Çirkin, for breaching the arms embargo. In November 2020 tensions flared again when the German frigate Hamburg, serving with Irini, boarded the Turkish freighter Rosalina-A north of Benghazi; the team withdrew after Turkey protested, and Germany said nothing suspicious had been found.
The fighting itself eased later that year. A permanent ceasefire was signed on 23 October 2020, and an interim Government of National Unity took office in March 2021, although planned elections have repeatedly been postponed.
Turkey's place in NATO
The Courbet incident was one of several strains between Turkey and its allies at the time. In October 2019 Turkey launched an offensive in northern Syria against Kurdish-led forces that had been the West's main ground partner against the Islamic State group, drawing strong criticism from European governments. Turkey had also bought Russia's S-400 air-defence system, which led to its removal from the US F-35 programme.
Critics of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, at home and abroad, accuse his government of eroding democratic institutions and press freedom. One figure is often quoted inaccurately: Turkey did not have the most imprisoned journalists in the world in 2019. The Committee to Protect Journalists counted 47 in Turkey that December, second only to China with 48. Turkey had been the world's worst jailer of journalists before China overtook it that year.
For readers following the eastern Mediterranean, the takeaway is that NATO membership does not prevent sharp clashes of interest between allies. Arguments over Libya, Syria, maritime borders and energy exploration have kept Turkey at odds with France, Greece and Cyprus in particular.
Sources: Al Jazeera: France suspends role in NATO naval mission after Turkey tensions; Wikipedia: Operation Irini; Wikipedia: French frigate Courbet; Wikipedia: Second Libyan Civil War; Al Jazeera: China trumps Turkey as worst jailer of journalists in 2019. Original reporting credited: Reuters via National Post; tweet by Ryan Browne.

COMMENTS