Trump Towers Istanbul and Questions Over Trump's 2019 Syria Pullout

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-27.

When President Donald Trump pulled US troops back from northern Syria in October 2019, opening the way for a Turkish offensive against Kurdish-led forces, critics asked a pointed question: did his business ties to Turkey play any part?

The honest answer is that no investigation has shown the decision was driven by personal profit. What is documented is that Trump earned licensing income from a high-profile property in Istanbul, that he once described this himself as a conflict of interest, and that members of Congress and a former senior adviser raised concerns about how he handled Turkey. This article sets out what is known, what is alleged, and what remains unproven.

Trump Accused Of Retreating From Syria As A Result Of His Turkish Business Interests

The Syria withdrawal that sparked the questions

US troops had been working with the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), a Kurdish-led alliance, against the Islamic State group since 2015. After a phone call with Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, the White House announced on 6 October 2019 that American personnel would withdraw from the border area.

Turkish airstrikes began three days later, followed by a ground offensive with allied Syrian factions under the name Operation Peace Spring. Turkey regards the main Kurdish militia in the SDF as an extension of the PKK, which it has fought for decades, and wanted a buffer zone along its border.

The consequences were serious. Monitoring groups reported more than 300,000 people displaced. The SDF turned to the Syrian government and Russia for protection, and Russian and Turkish forces agreed joint patrols at a summit in Sochi on 22 October. Hundreds of people linked to Islamic State were reported to have escaped from a camp near Ayn Issa during the chaos. Many in both US parties saw the move as abandoning an ally and handing advantages to Russia and the Syrian government.

Trump Towers Istanbul

The business link at the centre of the debate is Trump Towers Istanbul, two connected skyscrapers in the Mecidiyeköy area of Şişli, one for offices and one residential, above a shopping mall. The complex opened in 2012.

Trump does not own the buildings. They were developed by the Doğan group, controlled by Turkish billionaire Aydın Doğan, under a licensing deal: the owner pays the Trump Organization to use the Trump brand. Erdoğan, then prime minister, attended the April 2012 launch. Ivanka Trump thanked him on Twitter the next day:

Mehmet Ali Yalçındağ, Doğan’s son-in-law, later became head of the Turkish-American Business Council and was described as having a business relationship with the Trump Organization. He spoke publicly about business leaders helping to ease tensions between Ankara and Washington.

Trump’s own words about a conflict of interest

In a 2015 radio interview on Breitbart News Daily, hosted by Steve Bannon, Trump was asked about Turkey and answered candidly: “I have a little conflict of interest because I have a major, major building in Istanbul.” He went on to praise the project as a great success, noting that it had two towers rather than one.

The clip resurfaced in April 2017, after Trump congratulated Erdoğan on winning a referendum that greatly expanded presidential powers. Trump argued during his presidency that conflict-of-interest laws covering the executive branch did not apply to the president. He handed day-to-day management of his company to his sons but did not divest, so the Trump Organization continued to earn money for him.

What critics alleged

Democratic Senator Chris Murphy of Connecticut was among the most outspoken. He told Business Insider in October 2019: “It’s hard to explain Trump’s actions in Syria through the prism of what’s best for American national security.” With that explanation missing, he said, people were looking for others, and the president’s business interests in Turkey were a known fact.

Murphy pushed for any Turkey sanctions bill to require the president to disclose his tax returns, arguing that Americans needed to know whether foreign policy was being made in the national interest or in the family’s interest. He also said Congress had a responsibility to find out why Trump made such a sudden decision.

Other connections drew attention too. Jared Kushner, Trump’s son-in-law and senior adviser, was reported to have a direct channel to Berat Albayrak, Erdoğan’s son-in-law and at the time Turkey’s finance minister. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross visited Turkey in 2019 to promote a target of $100 billion a year in bilateral trade, while some lawmakers were calling for sanctions over Turkey’s purchase of the Russian S-400 missile system.

John Bolton and the Halkbank case

The strongest claims came from John Bolton, Trump’s national security adviser from April 2018 to September 2019. He is sometimes wrongly described as defence secretary, a post he never held. His memoir, The Room Where It Happened, was published on 23 June 2020 after the administration tried and failed to block it in court.

Bolton wrote that Trump told Erdoğan he would take care of a US prosecution of Halkbank, a Turkish state-owned bank accused of helping Iran evade sanctions through billions of dollars in transactions. Bolton also described wider concerns that Trump was willing to intervene in Justice Department cases involving companies in Turkey and China. In interviews promoting the book, Bolton reportedly suggested Trump’s approach to Turkey might be tied to personal or business relationships. Turkey rejected the book’s accounts as misleading, and Trump’s supporters dismissed Bolton as a disgruntled former aide.

What we can and cannot conclude

It is important to separate three things. First, the facts: Trump had a financial stake in a Turkish property, and he said publicly that it created a conflict of interest. Second, the allegations: senators and a former adviser suggested those ties might have shaped policy. Third, the missing link: no court, inspector general or congressional investigation has established that the Syria withdrawal was made for business reasons.

There are also other explanations. Trump had long promised to bring troops home from what he called endless wars, and he had tried to withdraw from Syria once before, in December 2018, prompting the resignation of Defense Secretary Jim Mattis.

Trump’s tax returns, which critics hoped would clarify his foreign income, were eventually released by the House Ways and Means Committee in December 2022. They did not settle the question of motive either way.

Turkey’s direction under Erdoğan

The debate also played out against concern about Turkey itself. The Committee to Protect Journalists repeatedly ranked Turkey among the world’s leading jailers of journalists, and in 2019 it was second only to China. Critics at home and abroad describe Erdoğan’s rule as increasingly authoritarian, while his supporters credit him with economic growth and a more assertive foreign policy.

For readers trying to make sense of the 2019 withdrawal, the takeaway is to treat business conflicts as a legitimate reason for scrutiny and transparency, while keeping in mind that a possible conflict is not proof of motive.

Sources: Time, 19 April 2017; Office of Sen. Chris Murphy (HuffPost, 15 October 2019); Wikipedia: Trump Towers Istanbul; Wikipedia: 2019 Turkish offensive into north-eastern Syria; Wikipedia: The Room Where It Happened; Murphy interview as reported by Business Insider.

COMMENTS