36 Alien Civilisations in Our Galaxy? What the 2020 Study Estimated

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

“Thirty-six alien civilizations” sounds like the result of a remarkable census. It was actually an estimate from a model. A 2020 study explored how many communicating civilizations might exist in the Milky Way if life elsewhere followed particular assumptions drawn from Earth’s history.

A person silhouetted beneath the Milky Way
Night-sky photograph used as an illustration; it does not identify any extraterrestrial civilization. Source.

The authors’ words—and the conditions attached

Christopher Conselice stated the assumption directly in the original announcement:

“There should be at least a few dozen active civilizations in our Galaxy under the assumption that it takes 5 billion years for intelligent life to form on other planets, as on Earth.”

The paper’s strict scenario uses a development interval of 4.5–5.5 billion years, along with other requirements including metallicity and a communicating lifetime. Its illustrative distance estimate near 17,000 light-years also depends on assumptions about how civilizations are distributed. These are conditional model outputs, not measurements of neighbors already found.

Conselice also described a broader motivation for the search:

“Our new research suggests that searches for extra-terrestrial intelligent civilizations not only reveals the existence of how life forms, but also gives us clues for how long our own civilization will last … If we find that intelligent life is common then this would reveal that our civilization could exist for much longer than a few hundred years, alternatively if we find that there are no active civilizations in our Galaxy it is a bad sign for our own long-term existence. By searching for extra-terrestrial intelligent life — even if we find nothing — we are discovering our own future and fate.”

That final passage expresses an interpretation of what future searches might mean. A non-detection alone cannot establish humanity’s fate: it may reflect limited sensitivity, incomplete coverage, different signal choices or a short overlap in time. Preserving the author’s speculation alongside those limits keeps the original discussion open without presenting a forecast of our civilization’s survival.

The paper distinguishes two ways of applying its Earth-based assumption. Under the weak condition, communicating intelligent life may develop at any time after roughly five billion years. Under the strong condition, development falls within the narrower 4.5–5.5-billion-year interval. The familiar figure of 36 comes from the strong scenario with additional assumptions; it should not be attached indiscriminately to every version of the model.

Where the number came from

In their paper on Astrobiological Copernican limits, Tom Westby and Christopher Conselice combined astronomical information with alternative assumptions about the development of intelligent life.

One strict scenario assumed that communicating life develops after roughly the same timespan as on Earth, and that a civilization’s communicating lifetime is about 100 years. Under those conditions, the calculation produced the widely reported figure of 36, with a broad uncertainty range.

Why the assumptions matter so much

The result depends on how often suitable planets develop such life and how long its signals remain detectable. Change the conditions, and the answer changes. The model did not identify 36 locations, detect 36 signals or establish a universal minimum number of civilizations.

Earth provides a real example, but one example cannot tell us how representative its history is. That gap is exactly why an apparently precise answer needs its conditions attached.

What the study is useful for

A model can make uncertainties explicit and organize questions for future research. The useful takeaway is not a count to memorize, but an understanding of which unknowns control the estimate.

Related planet counts need similar care: estimates of Earth-sized worlds do not count inhabited worlds. And a possible signal would still need the kind of evaluation discussed in frameworks for reporting evidence of extraterrestrial life.

Video and posts

More from the archive:

Original feature credits and references: said in relation to this limit · Professor Conselice remarked.

COMMENTS