Originally published 2020-06-19.

Bryce Casavant was a British Columbia conservation officer who, in 2015, refused an order to kill two orphaned black bear cubs near Port Hardy on Vancouver Island and took them to a vet instead. The cubs were rehabilitated and released, but Casavant was suspended and taken out of his conservation officer job. In June 2020 the B.C. Court of Appeal ruled in his favour, finding that his case had been handled under the wrong legal process. That win was celebrated around the world, yet it did not get him his old badge back: later rulings upheld the settlement that had moved him to another job.
Here is the full story, from the trailer park call-out to the courtroom, and what it says about how bears and people share space in British Columbia.
The call-out at Port Hardy
The incident took place in 2015 at a mobile home park near Port Hardy, at the northern end of Vancouver Island. A mother black bear had repeatedly broken into a freezer of food, and conservation officers were called. As is common when a bear has learned to seek human food, the mother was put down.
Her two cubs were found nearby. Casavant was ordered to kill them too, but he judged that the young bears had not become habituated to human food and posed no danger to people or property. Instead, he took them to a veterinary hospital. From there they went to the North Island Wildlife Recovery Centre, which cared for them and later released them into the wild.
The story spread quickly. Many people rallied behind him online, and the case drew attention from well-known figures, including the comedian Ricky Gervais.
"It took a lot of guts to do what he did”
— Nguyen #fbpe #fbr (@haaohaoo) June 14, 2020
“In the bigger picture, the ruling sets a precedent that conservation officers could stand up to supervisors against kill orders when it is appropriate to do so” https://t.co/2WfsRT7qWw
Suspended, then moved out of the job
Casavant was suspended for disobeying the order. His employment dispute was then handled through the usual labour channels for public servants. He ended up in a settlement that transferred him to a different ministry as a natural resource officer, a senior compliance and enforcement role at the same pay, but without his status as a conservation officer.
He challenged that outcome at B.C.'s Labour Relations Board, which rejected his application. Supporters described the result as being fired for showing mercy; the province saw it as a disciplinary matter over a refused order.
What the Court of Appeal decided in 2020
In June 2020 the B.C. Court of Appeal overturned the Labour Relations Board decision. The key point was legal rather than moral: B.C. conservation officers hold special provincial constable status under the Police Act, and the court found that discipline of an officer in that role should have gone through the Police Act process, not through labour arbitration and the board.
The ruling did not declare that the cubs should have lived or that bear policy was wrong. It said the process used against him was the wrong one. Even so, Casavant felt vindicated, telling The Guardian that his firing "should have never happened in the first place." Supporters argued the ruling would help other officers who question kill orders.
The fight did not end there
The B.C. Government and Service Employees' Union asked the Supreme Court of Canada to hear an appeal of the 2020 ruling, and the court declined. Negotiations between Casavant and the province then broke down.
He went back to court, seeking a judicial review. This time a B.C. Supreme Court judge found that the original settlement moving him to the natural resource officer job was valid. In a second appeal, Justice John Hunter of the Court of Appeal agreed that the lower court had analysed the settlement correctly. That exhausted his options in British Columbia; only the Supreme Court of Canada remained.
Casavant said he was disappointed but respected the decision, adding that the case had become about the rights of conservation officers in environmental policing rather than about him alone. A former Canadian Forces soldier who served in Afghanistan, he went on to lecture on humanitarian studies and the environment at Royal Roads University.
How many bears are killed in British Columbia?
The case reopened a long debate about how often B.C. kills bears in conflict with people. The conservation group Pacific Wild, citing provincial figures, said that more than 4,500 black bears were killed by the Conservation Officer Service over about eight years, roughly one every two days. Casavant argued it was unreasonable to call so many deaths, including cubs, a last resort. Critics have also questioned how many cubs are killed compared with how many are sent to rehabilitation.
Officers face a hard reality. A bear that learns to raid freezers, bins or bird feeders can become bold and dangerous, and relocated bears often return or struggle in unfamiliar territory. Rehabilitation centres can take orphaned cubs, but space is limited and success depends on the cubs not having learned to link people with food.
Myths and facts
- Myth: the court ordered his job restored. Fact: the 2020 ruling concerned the legal process; later rulings upheld his transfer.
- Myth: he refused to kill any bear. Fact: the dispute was about the orphaned cubs, not the mother.
- Myth: orphaned cubs cannot survive. Fact: young cubs raised carefully, with little human contact, can be released, as these two were.
How communities can prevent bear deaths
Most bears killed in conflict are lured in by food that people leave available. The saying "a fed bear is a dead bear" is popular in Canada for a reason. Simple steps make a real difference:
- Lock up attractants: use bear-resistant bins, keep freezers and garbage indoors or in sturdy sheds, and put rubbish out only on collection morning.
- Remove easy meals: pick ripe fruit, clean barbecues and take down bird feeders when bears are active.
- Report early: call the local wildlife line about bears getting into food before the situation escalates.
- Support rehabilitation: wildlife recovery centres rely on donations and volunteers to give orphaned cubs a second chance.
The two cubs from Port Hardy got that chance because one officer made a judgement call. The legal story that followed was long and, for him, bittersweet.
Sources: Prince George Citizen/Glacier Media: Ex-conservation officer who saved B.C. bear cubs loses another appeal; Wikipedia: British Columbia Conservation Officer Service; The Guardian, 11 June 2020; Pacific Wild bear-kill figures as reported at the time.

COMMENTS