Thomas Lane's Bail and Conviction in the George Floyd Case

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-12.

Thomas Lane's Release on Bail in June 2020

Thomas Lane, one of the four Minneapolis police officers charged after the death of George Floyd, walked out of the Hennepin County jail on the afternoon of 10 June 2020 after posting bail of $750,000 with conditions. He was the first of the four to be released. His release followed a public online appeal, set up in his name, asking supporters to donate towards his bail and legal costs.

Bail only meant that Lane could wait for trial at home. It was not a finding on guilt. Two years later he was convicted in federal court of violating Floyd's civil rights and pleaded guilty in state court to aiding and abetting manslaughter. Here is how his case unfolded, from the fundraiser to the final sentence.

Who Thomas Lane is and what he did on 25 May 2020

Lane was 37 at the time and very new to policing. He had joined the Minneapolis Police Department as a cadet in February 2019 and became a sworn officer in December 2019; reports described the day of Floyd's arrest as falling in his first week working without a field-training officer.

On 25 May 2020 Lane and fellow rookie J. Alexander Kueng answered a call about a suspected counterfeit $20 bill outside a corner shop. Lane drew his gun when he first approached Floyd in his car. During the restraint that followed, Lane held Floyd's legs while Derek Chauvin knelt on his neck for more than nine minutes.

According to the criminal complaint, Lane twice asked Chauvin whether they should roll Floyd onto his side. Chauvin said no. Prosecutors accepted that Lane raised the question, but argued that he then did nothing to change Floyd's position or reduce the force being used. His lawyer, Earl Gray, told reporters that Lane was a rookie who only held Floyd's feet and later helped perform CPR in the ambulance.

The bail amount and the online fundraiser

All four officers were fired the day after Floyd's death. Lane, Kueng and Tou Thao were charged in early June with aiding and abetting second-degree murder and aiding and abetting second-degree manslaughter, while Chauvin faced murder charges. Press reports at the time said that, like Chauvin, the three were offered bail of $1 million without conditions or $750,000 with conditions attached.

A website supporting Lane argued that his bail was unfair because it matched the amount set for Chauvin, the senior officer who had knelt on Floyd's neck. It insisted Lane had tried to help Floyd and asked visitors to donate. Lane posted the conditional $750,000 bail on 10 June. The fundraiser drew strong criticism online, where many people saw it as asking the public to pay for the freedom of a man charged over a killing that had sparked protests around the world.

Thomas Lane's Release on Bail in June 2020

Thomas Lane's booking photograph, released by the Hennepin County Sheriff's Office in Minnesota after his arrest in June 2020.

Questions about his past record

Around the time of his release, several outlets reported that court records showed Lane had more than a dozen earlier minor offences, mostly traffic violations. The reports also said he had been charged in 2001 with offences including obstructing legal process and property damage, and had a 2007 misdemeanour linked to a noisy party. These records were reported in the press but did not form part of the case against him over Floyd's death, and we have not been able to check them against the original court files.

What bail does and does not mean

Bail is often misunderstood, and the reaction to Lane's release showed it. In the American system, bail is money or a bond used to secure a defendant's return to court while their case is pending. It is not a penalty and says nothing about whether the person is guilty.

Minnesota courts commonly offer two figures, as happened here: a higher amount with no conditions and a lower amount with conditions attached. Defendants who cannot afford either figure stay in jail until trial, which is why public fundraisers, bail funds and bail bond companies play such a large part in American criminal justice. Fundraisers for defendants in high-profile cases are legal, though they often attract fierce debate.

The convictions and sentences

Lane was first tried in federal court. In February 2022 a jury in St. Paul found him, Kueng and Thao guilty of willfully depriving Floyd of his civil rights. In Lane's case, the conviction was for failing to give Floyd medical care when he lost his pulse. He was sentenced in July 2022 to two and a half years.

In the state case, Lane chose a plea deal. On 18 May 2022 he pleaded guilty to aiding and abetting second-degree manslaughter, and the murder charge was dismissed. On 21 September 2022 Judge Peter Cahill sentenced him to three years, to be served at the same time as his federal sentence and in a federal prison. Lane appeared by video from a federal correctional institution in Colorado and made no statement. The judge called his decision to accept responsibility "a very wise decision". Lane was released from prison in August 2024.

What happened to the other officers

  • Derek Chauvin was convicted of murder and manslaughter on 20 April 2021 and sentenced to 22½ years. He later pleaded guilty to federal civil rights charges and received 21 years, to run at the same time.
  • J. Alexander Kueng was convicted in the federal case and sentenced to three years, then pleaded guilty to aiding and abetting manslaughter in state court and received 3½ years, served concurrently.
  • Tou Thao was convicted in the federal case and sentenced to 3½ years. In the state case he waived a jury trial and was found guilty of aiding and abetting manslaughter in 2023, receiving 4¾ years.

Lane's case is often seen as the clearest example of the "duty to intervene" question raised by Floyd's death: whether a junior officer who voices concern, but then defers to a senior colleague, shares responsibility for what happens. In his case, the courts decided that he did.

Sources: CBS News: Former officer charged in George Floyd's death leaves jail after posting bail (June 2020); Al Jazeera: Former US police officer gets 3 years in George Floyd killing (21 September 2022); Wikipedia: Murder of George Floyd; booking photo: Hennepin County Sheriff's Office.

COMMENTS