Did George Floyd and Derek Chauvin Know Each Other?

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-12.

Did George Floyd and Derek Chauvin Know Each Other?

There is no reliable evidence that George Floyd and Derek Chauvin knew each other before 25 May 2020. Both men had worked security at the same Minneapolis nightclub, El Nuevo Rodeo, but the club's former owner said she was not sure they ever met. In June 2020 a former co-worker told CBS News the two had bumped heads. Four days later he withdrew that claim, saying he had mixed Floyd up with another employee.

The question went viral because people hoped a past conflict would explain what happened on Chicago Avenue. Here is what was actually known, why the claim fell apart, and why it made no difference to the court cases that followed.

The nightclub connection

Days after Floyd's death, Maya Santamaria, the former owner of El Nuevo Rodeo, told the Minneapolis TV station KSTP that both men had worked at her club. The Latin music venue on Lake Street had been open for about 17 years before it burned down during the unrest that followed Floyd's killing.

Santamaria said Chauvin had worked there as an off-duty police officer for most of those years, mostly outside the building. Floyd worked inside as a bouncer, with overlapping shifts reported as recently as 2019. Asked whether they knew each other, she said she could not be sure. They might have crossed paths at work, but security staff inside and the officer outside did different jobs, often at different ends of a large venue.

She was much clearer about Chauvin's behaviour. She described him as having a real short fuse and said that when trouble broke out he often reached for mace or pepper spray, even when she did not think it was needed. Many readers asked why she kept employing him. She did not give a public answer to that.

The "bumped heads" claim and the correction

On 6 June 2020, David Pinney, who had also worked security at the club, gave CBS News a long interview. Parts of it aired a few days later. He said Floyd and Chauvin knew each other well, that Chauvin was very aggressive with some customers, and that the two men had clashed.

On 10 June, Pinney emailed CBS News to take that back. There has been a mix up between George and another fellow co-worker, he wrote, explaining that he had confused Floyd with another Black employee. He apologised for not checking more carefully, while standing by his description of Chauvin as aggressive. According to Pinney, the mix-up happened partly because Santamaria had pointed reporters to him as someone who knew Floyd better than she did.

By then the original claim had already spread widely, including in early versions of stories like this one. The correction travelled much less far, which is a common pattern with fast-moving news.

Why a prior connection would have mattered legally

At the time, commentators argued that a past feud could suggest Chauvin acted on purpose, which might mean a harsher charge. That needs some correction. In Minnesota, planning a killing in advance (premeditation) is part of first-degree murder. Chauvin was never charged with that, and prosecutors never claimed he intended to kill Floyd.

His charges were second-degree unintentional murder, which in Minnesota covers causing a death while committing a felony such as assault; third-degree murder; and second-degree manslaughter. Early reports that the unintentional charge carried a fixed 12½ years, and an intentional one 25, mixed up two different things. Twelve and a half years is the sentencing guideline's starting point for unintentional second-degree murder by someone with no criminal record. It is not a fixed penalty, and the legal maximum for second-degree murder in Minnesota is 40 years.

A personal history between the two men could still have been relevant as evidence of motive. But since no such history was ever shown, it never became part of the case.

What the trials decided

The case went to trial in March 2021 without any claim of a prior relationship. On 20 April 2021 the jury found Chauvin guilty on all three counts. On 25 June 2021 Judge Peter Cahill sentenced him to 22½ years in prison, ten years above the guideline starting point. He cited aggravating factors: Chauvin abused his position of authority, treated Floyd with particular cruelty, and committed the crime in front of children.

The other three officers at the scene, Thomas Lane, J. Alexander Kueng and Tou Thao, were convicted in federal court in February 2022 of violating Floyd's civil rights. They received sentences of 2½ years (Lane), 3 years (Kueng) and 3½ years (Thao). Lane, who had been released on $750,000 bail in June 2020, also pleaded guilty to a state charge of aiding and abetting second-degree manslaughter. Chauvin himself pleaded guilty to federal civil rights charges and received 21 years, served at the same time as his state sentence. In November 2023 the US Supreme Court declined to hear his appeal.

How to read claims like this in breaking news

The Floyd and Chauvin story is a useful example of how news goes wrong in the first days after a major event. A single witness made a striking claim, it fitted what many people wanted to hear, and it spread faster than anyone could check it. A few points help when you see a story like this:

  • Count the sources. "A former co-worker says" is one person's memory. Look for a second, independent confirmation.
  • Look for the correction. Reputable outlets update their stories. CBS News changed its headline and published Pinney's retraction.
  • Separate the proven facts from the theory. That both men worked at the same club was confirmed. That they knew or disliked each other was never shown.

The answer, then, is that the two men may have been in the same building on the same nights, but there is no evidence they knew each other. Chauvin was convicted because of what the world saw on video on 25 May 2020, not because of any history between them.

Sources: CBS News: Former co-worker changes story about Floyd and Chauvin; NPR via WYPR: Floyd and Chauvin were once co-workers, ex-club owner says (May 2020); Wikipedia: Trial of Derek Chauvin; WABE/NPR: Two former officers sentenced for violating George Floyd's civil rights (July 2022).

COMMENTS