
Portland Place, St. Louis, Missouri, 28 June 2020. Photo: Reuters/Lawrence Bryant
On the evening of 28 June 2020, Mark and Patricia McCloskey, two St. Louis personal injury lawyers, stood outside their mansion and pointed guns at Black Lives Matter protesters marching along their private street. He held an AR-15-style rifle; she held a handgun. No shots were fired and nobody was hurt, but photos and videos of the confrontation went around the world within hours. The couple were later charged, pleaded guilty to misdemeanours in 2021, and were pardoned by Missouri's governor a few weeks after that.
Here is what happened that evening, why the protesters were there, how the legal case unfolded, and why the images became one of the defining moments of the summer of 2020.
Why the protesters were on Portland Place
The march was part of the wave of protests that followed the killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis in May 2020. Around 500 demonstrators were heading for the home of St. Louis Mayor Lyda Krewson, who lived on a street nearby, to call for her resignation.
A few days earlier, during a Facebook Live update, Krewson had read out the names and addresses of residents who had handed her letters calling for cuts to police funding. Critics said she had exposed private citizens to harassment. She removed the video and apologised, saying she had been answering routine questions and had not meant to harm or distress anyone.
I’d like to apologize for identifying individuals who presented letters to me at City Hall today. This was during one of my Facebook updates as I was answering routine questions. Never did I intend to harm anyone or cause distress. The update is removed and again, I apologize.
— Mayor Lyda Krewson (@LydaKrewson) June 27, 2020
The route to the mayor's house passed through Portland Place, a gated private street in the Central West End, one of the city's wealthiest neighbourhoods.
The confrontation outside the mansion
Photos and videos show the McCloskeys on the lawn and terrace of their house as the crowd walked past on the street. Patricia McCloskey can be seen pointing her pistol towards marchers, at times with her finger near or on the trigger, while her husband held the rifle. Some marchers shouted back; some carried signs, and footage shows the crowd continuing towards the mayor's home.
A couple has come out of their house and is pointing guns at protesters in their neighborhood #StLouis #lydakrewson pic.twitter.com/ZJ8a553PAU
— Daniel Shular (@xshularx) June 29, 2020
(This post is no longer available on X.)
God the other angle didn’t even do couple in St. Louis justice. She came down looking for an excuse to shoot someone.pic.twitter.com/EZ1KH6HvlD
— Joshua Potash (@JoshuaPotash) June 29, 2020
Accounts of what happened at the gate differ. Mark McCloskey said the protesters broke through the gate and that he feared for his life and his property. Video, however, showed the first marchers walking in through a gate that a man was holding open, and it remained unclear who damaged the gate. Protesters said they posed no threat to the couple and were simply passing through on their way to the mayor's house; no one entered the house or attacked the McCloskeys.
Rich white folx in CWE big mad when you come by unannounced.
— The #2 Rude Boy (@AaronWBanks) June 29, 2020
I’m not supposed to be used to people pointing guns at me. I would waste time debating the legality of all this but she would never get prosecuted anyway. #ResignLyda #STL #Sunday #StandYourGround #CastleDoctrine pic.twitter.com/YuFisV47Dt
The house behind the headlines
The McCloskeys' home is a large historic mansion, and pictures from an earlier professional photoshoot by photographer Alise O'Brien quickly resurfaced online. They showed the white façade, manicured lawns and an ornate interior with painted ceilings and a curving staircase, where the couple had posed for a portrait.


For many viewers, the contrast between the grand house and the crowd on the street turned the incident into a symbol of the tensions of 2020: wealth and race, property and protest, fear on one side and anger on the other.
What the law says: "castle doctrine" and stand your ground
Supporters of the couple pointed to Missouri's self-defence laws. Missouri's "castle doctrine" allows people to use force, including deadly force in some circumstances, against someone who unlawfully enters their home or property, and in 2016 the state also adopted a "stand your ground" rule that removes the duty to retreat in places where a person has a right to be. Critics replied that these laws apply when someone reasonably believes they face an imminent threat, and that pointing guns at people walking past on a street, without a clear threat, could itself be a crime.
That disagreement is at the heart of why the case divided people so sharply. Some saw a couple defending their home from a crowd; others saw armed homeowners threatening peaceful marchers. For some reading on that summer's protests, see our story about women who formed a line between protesters and police in Louisville, and our report on armed protesters with guns in a North Carolina Subway.
Charges, guilty pleas and a pardon
The legal story unfolded over more than a year:
- July 2020: Police seized Mark McCloskey's rifle, and on 20 July St. Louis Circuit Attorney Kimberly Gardner charged both spouses with felony unlawful use of a weapon.
- August 2020: The couple spoke at the Republican National Convention, defending the Second Amendment and criticising the protests.
- December 2020: A judge removed Gardner from the case over fundraising emails that mentioned it; a special prosecutor took over in early 2021.
- June 2021: Mark McCloskey pleaded guilty to misdemeanour fourth-degree assault and was fined $750; Patricia McCloskey pleaded guilty to misdemeanour harassment and was fined $2,000. They gave up the weapons used that night.
- August 2021: Missouri Governor Mike Parson pardoned both of them.
Mark McCloskey ran for the US Senate as a Republican in 2022 and won about 3% of the primary vote. In February 2022 the Missouri Supreme Court suspended both lawyers' licences indefinitely but stayed the suspension and placed them on a year's probation. Their later efforts to clear their records and recover the rifle continued in the courts for years afterwards.
From viral moment to meme
Online, the images became memes almost immediately. Many played on "Karen", the slang label for a person, usually a white woman, seen as acting entitled or overbearing. One mock film poster, titled "Ken & Karen", put the couple's photo under the tagline of an "election year production".
Behind the jokes, the case raised serious questions that are still debated: how far self-defence laws reach, how protesters and residents should behave when marches pass private homes, and whether officials who expose protesters' details should face consequences. Whatever your view, the safest outcome that evening was the one that actually happened: no one fired a shot.
Sources: Main photo by Lawrence Bryant (Reuters); house photos by Alise O'Brien; tweets by @xshularx, @JoshuaPotash, @AaronWBanks and @LydaKrewson; Wikipedia: St. Louis gun-toting controversy.

COMMENTS