Michigan's 2020 Bill Against Forced Workplace Microchip Implants

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-29.

Michigan House Passed a Bill Against Forced Workplace Microchips in 2020

On 24 June 2020 the Michigan House of Representatives voted 104 to 2 for House Bill 5672, the Microchip Protection Act. The bill would stop employers from requiring workers or job applicants to have a microchip or similar device implanted in their bodies, and would protect anyone who refuses. It was not the first protection of its kind in the United States, and it did not become law simply by passing the House: it still needed the state Senate and Governor Gretchen Whitmer's signature.

The bill drew wide attention, and also a wave of misleading social media posts claiming the opposite of what it did. Here is what the bill actually said, why lawmakers worried about workplace implants, and where the law stands across the country.

What HB 5672 would do

The bill was short, about three pages. According to the House Fiscal Agency's analysis, it would bar an employer, or anyone acting for one, from requiring an employee or prospective employee to have a device implanted, injected, ingested, inhaled or otherwise placed into their body. That applied whether the chip was a condition of getting the job, holding a particular position, or receiving extra pay or benefits.

It also banned discrimination against people who say no, in pay, benefits or any other condition of work. Workers could sue a violating employer for actual damages, court costs and reasonable attorney fees, and courts could order the employer to stop. Existing rights under other state and federal laws were left untouched.

There was one exception: an employer could require compliance with a court order, for example where a court directs monitoring of someone on probation or parole. Some experts criticised that clause as a weakness.

Why a Michigan lawmaker proposed it

The sponsor, Republican Representative Bronna Kahle, admitted there was no known case of a Michigan employer forcing implants on staff. Her argument was that the technology was spreading and the law should get ahead of it. She told reporters she would not be surprised if microchipping became standard business practice in the state within a few years.

The bill had unusually broad support. The Michigan Department of Civil Rights, the public-sector union AFSCME Council 25 and the ACLU of Michigan all backed it, and nobody testified against it in committee.

How workplace implants work

The chips involved are tiny RFID or NFC devices, often about the size of a grain of rice, encased in glass and injected under the skin, usually in the hand. They have no battery and do not contain GPS. When a reader is held close, the chip answers with a unique ID number, which a computer system links to whatever it has been set up to do: open a door, unlock a printer or computer, or pay at a canteen.

A few companies have offered them to staff on a voluntary basis. At the Epicenter office complex in Stockholm, employees have used implants to open doors and pay for lunch. In 2017 Three Square Market in Wisconsin made headlines in the US by offering implants to its employees, and dozens took up the offer.

The same RFID technology is everywhere in non-implanted form: in library books, shop inventory tags, contactless cards and the ID badges most office workers already carry.

The privacy and health concerns

Because an implant cannot be left at home, critics say it blurs the line between work and private life. A chip itself only reports an ID number at close range, but each scan can be logged, building a record of where a worker went and when. Supporters of the Michigan bill raised examples such as secretly tracking bathroom breaks or a worker's location.

Security is another worry. Researchers have shown that the ID numbers on some implant chips can be copied with a handheld reader, and a 2007 report from the American Medical Association warned that there was no guarantee the information linked to a chip would stay protected.

Health questions are smaller but real. Reported problems include infection, rejection of the implant and difficulties with MRI scans. Anyone considering an implant should talk to a doctor about the medical side.

The wider backdrop is the growth of workplace monitoring in general. Amazon, for example, drew criticism in 2018 for patents describing wristbands that could track warehouse workers' hand movements, and privacy campaigners warned during the Covid-19 pandemic that distancing and contact-tracing tools could be used to justify more intrusive tracking. A badge or app can usually do the same job as an implant without putting a device inside someone's body, which is why many argue an implant should never be a condition of employment.

The false claims that followed

Soon after the vote, posts on Facebook and elsewhere claimed Michigan had created a "framework" for microchipping people or given employers permission to chip workers. Fact-checkers at PolitiFact and Snopes both rated those claims Mostly False. The House had indeed passed a microchip bill, but its purpose was to protect workers who decline an implant, not to authorise implants.

Some early news stories made the opposite mistake, describing Michigan as the first state to make forced microchipping illegal. That was not accurate either, as other states had acted years earlier.

Where US law stands

Wisconsin passed the first law against forced implants in 2006, followed by North Dakota (2007), California (2007), Oklahoma (2008) and Georgia (2010). Virginia passed a law in 2010 barring employers from forcing staff to receive implanted tracking devices. Indiana's law, written by Republican Representative Alan Morrison, took effect on 1 July 2020, a week after Michigan's House vote. In most of these states, legislators said they knew of no actual cases; the laws were preventive. More recently, Washington state's House Bill 2303, signed in March 2026, bars companies from requesting or requiring microchip implants.

When fact-checkers reviewed the Michigan bill in July 2020, it was still waiting for the Senate. In Michigan, bills that do not complete both chambers before the end of a two-year session must be reintroduced to proceed. Whatever its final fate, the bill reflected a clear and widely shared principle: an implant at work should be a free choice, and saying no should not cost anyone their job.

Sources: Snopes, July 2020: Michigan microchips bill; PolitiFact, 27 July 2020: No, Michigan lawmakers didn't create a framework for microchipping; Michigan House Fiscal Agency: analysis of HB 5672; Wikipedia: Microchip implant (human); Futurism: Bronna Kahle on the bill; The Guardian, 2018: Amazon wristband patents; MIT Technology Review, 2018: a company that implants its employees.

COMMENTS