
Yes, cats bond with their people. A 2019 study from Oregon State University found that about two-thirds of the cats it tested were securely attached to their owners, a share very close to that seen in human babies and in dogs. What the study did not show is that cats bond more strongly than dogs. Headlines claiming that went further than the evidence, and the difference matters for anyone trying to understand their cat.
Here is how the experiment worked, what it found, what it leaves open and what it suggests for everyday life with a cat.
The study in brief
The research was led by animal behaviour scientist Kristyn Vitale, working with Monique Udell and Alexandra Behnke in Oregon State University's Human-Animal Interaction Lab. It was published in Current Biology on 23 September 2019.
The team tested 79 kittens and 38 adult cats, aged one year or older. Nine kittens could not be classified, leaving 70. Of those, 64.3% were rated securely attached and 35.7% insecurely attached. The adults were almost identical: 65.8% secure and 34.2% insecure. For comparison, roughly 65% of human infants are classed as securely attached to a caregiver.
How a "secure base" test works
Attachment research grew out of work on human infants, and earlier still out of Harry Harlow's controversial experiments of the 1950s, in which infant rhesus monkeys clung to a soft cloth "mother" rather than a wire one that supplied milk. Psychologists later developed standard tests in which a child is briefly separated from a parent in an unfamiliar room and then reunited. Similar tests have since been used with dogs.
The cat version was short. Each cat spent two minutes in a new room with its owner, who sat inside a marked circle and could interact with the cat if it came close. The owner then left for two minutes, and finally returned for a two-minute reunion. Sessions were filmed and later scored by experts using criteria drawn from infant and dog research.
Secure and insecure, in practice
A securely attached cat greeted its returning owner, settled and then went back to exploring, splitting its attention between the person and the room. The owner acted as a safe base.
Insecurely attached cats showed signs of stress such as tail twitching and lip licking. Some avoided the owner; others clung, for instance jumping into the owner's lap and refusing to move. Clinginess, in other words, is not always a sign of a strong healthy bond. It can be a sign of anxiety.
Why "more than dogs" overstates it
The comparison with dogs came from setting the cat results beside an earlier dog study, in which about 61% of 59 companion dogs were reportedly classed as securely attached. Cats scored a few points higher, which led some outlets to announce that cats bond more strongly than dogs.
That conclusion does not hold up. The two figures come from different studies, with different animals, owners and settings, and the gap is small. Samples of a few dozen animals are too small to rank species reliably on a difference of a few percentage points. And the test measures the style of an attachment, secure or insecure, not its strength or depth. A dog and a cat can both be securely attached in very different ways.
The more accurate message is that cats show the same main attachment patterns as dogs and babies. Vitale's team described this as the first time those patterns had been demonstrated empirically in cats.
Does training change a cat's attachment?
The kittens were tested twice. Between the two tests, 39 of them took a six-week training and socialisation course while 31 did not. The course made no significant difference to the share of secure and insecure kittens.
Vitale summed up the finding by saying attachment "appears to remain relatively stable over time, even after a training and socialization intervention." That is a careful claim. It covers one course over a couple of months in one group of kittens. It does not prove that an individual cat's attachment style is fixed for life, and research in children and dogs suggests that relationships can shift as circumstances change.
The myth of the aloof cat
The idea that cats are independent loners runs deep. Part of it comes from their history: cats were never bred for close cooperation with people in the way many dog breeds were, and their ancestor, the African wildcat, lives mostly alone.
Research from the same lab has challenged that picture. Earlier work led by Vitale found that many cats, given a choice, prefer interacting with a person over food or toys, and that cats tend to match the amount of attention people give them. As Vitale put it, "There's long been a biased way of thinking that all cats behave this way." The 2019 study adds that cats, like dogs, may treat their owners as a source of security, an adaptation of the bond between young animals and those who care for them.
What this means for cat owners
The study is not a test to try at home. Briefly leaving the room and watching your cat's reaction will not tell you its attachment style, because the experiment relied on a new environment, trained observers and set criteria.
A few practical points do follow from it:
- Your cat may rely on you when stressed. New places, vet visits and moves are moments when a calm, familiar person matters.
- Let the cat set the pace. Cats that approach on their own terms and then wander off may be showing exactly the confident, secure pattern the researchers described.
- Clinging or hiding can signal stress. A sudden change in behaviour is worth noticing, and if it lasts, talk to a vet, since pain and illness can also change how cats behave.
- Every cat is an individual. About a third of cats in the study were insecurely attached, so a cat that seems distant is not a failure of care, and patience often helps.
The bigger lesson is simply to take cats seriously as social animals. They may show it more quietly than dogs, but the bond is real.
Sources: Oregon State University: Cats, like children and dogs, develop attachments to their caregivers; Vitale, Behnke & Udell (2019), Current Biology.

COMMENTS