Arkansas Hunter Died After a Wounded Deer He Shot Attacked Him

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-12-04.

Arkansas Hunter Died After a Reported Encounter With a Wounded Deer

In October 2019, a 66-year-old hunter named Thomas Alexander died in north Arkansas after a buck he had shot, and believed was down, got back up and attacked him. He suffered puncture wounds from the animal's antlers, managed to phone his wife for help, and was pronounced dead at a hospital later that evening. Officials did not establish a precise medical cause of death.

The case drew attention around the world because it is so rare. It also carries a practical lesson that hunter-education instructors repeat every season: a deer that has fallen is not necessarily a dead deer.

What happened near Yellville

Alexander was hunting alone near Yellville, a small town in Marion County in the Ozarks, roughly 100 miles east of Fayetteville. The incident took place at about 6:30 p.m. on Tuesday, 22 October 2019, a few days into the deer season; he was using a muzzleloader.

According to the Arkansas Game and Fish Commission (AGFC), he shot a buck with his muzzleloader and then walked up to it. The deer was still alive. It rose and went for him, and its antlers left him with several puncture wounds.

Despite his injuries, Alexander was able to call his wife. Emergency crews reached him and, some time after 8 p.m., were moving him toward a medical helicopter when he stopped breathing. The plan changed and he was taken by ground ambulance to Baxter Regional Medical Center in Mountain Home, where he was pronounced dead.

What is known, and not known, about the cause of death

Early headlines said the deer "killed" the hunter. The reporting at the time was more careful than that. The puncture wounds were confirmed, but the exact cause of death was not released, and officials said an autopsy was unlikely. A heart attack or other complications brought on by the injuries and the shock of the encounter were mentioned as possibilities.

That uncertainty matters. It is accurate to say that Alexander died after being attacked by a wounded buck. It is not established whether the wounds themselves, a cardiac event, or a combination was the direct cause. For a 66-year-old alone in the woods, all of those are plausible, and none needs to be dramatised.

How rare are deer attacks on hunters?

Very rare. AGFC spokesman Keith Stephens told reporters that the commission knew of only one comparable case in the state, in Ashley County in south-east Arkansas, about four years earlier. In that case a hunter was struck by a buck's antlers and survived.

To put that in context, the Quality Deer Management Association (now the National Deer Association) reported that US hunters took 2,878,998 antlered bucks in the 2017–18 season, plus more than 2.8 million antlerless deer in the Midwest, Northeast and Southeast alone. Millions of deer are approached by hunters every year, and serious attacks on them are almost unheard of.

National figures for hunters killed by the game they pursue are not routinely collected. The causes of hunting deaths that do show up in safety data are far more ordinary: falls from tree stands, firearm accidents, and heart attacks brought on by exertion such as dragging a heavy deer out of the woods.

"Deer kill more people than sharks": true, but read the fine print

Stories like this one often repeat the claim that deer are deadlier to Americans than sharks, bears and alligators put together. Vox made that point in 2016, and it is broadly correct. The reason, though, is cars: collisions with deer kill at least 440 people a year in the United States. The great majority of deer-related deaths in the United States come from vehicle collisions, not from deer attacking people.

So the comparison says a lot about road safety in deer country and very little about the risk of a hunter being charged. Mixing the two categories makes deer sound far more aggressive than they are. Direct attacks do happen, mostly involving bucks during the autumn rut or deer that are cornered, injured or used to people, but they remain uncommon.

Why a wounded buck can be dangerous

A buck in late October is close to, or in, the rut. Testosterone is high, the neck is swollen, and the antlers are hardened and sharp. An animal in that condition that is also wounded, frightened and suddenly approached has every reason to fight rather than flee.

Hunters also know that a deer can drop at the shot and still be alive. A hit that stuns the animal or strikes the spine, rather than the heart and lungs, may knock it down for a while. When a person walks up, adrenaline can carry it back to its feet. A buck weighing well over 100 pounds, with a rack of tines, can do serious harm in seconds.

Practical safety advice for approaching a downed deer

After Alexander's death, Stephens advised hunters to wait about half an hour after shooting before going to the animal, because, in his words, "it may not be dead." Hunter-education guides add several similar points:

  • Wait and watch. Stay in place, reload if your firearm allows, and keep the deer in sight for a while before moving in.
  • Approach from behind. Come in from the back of the animal, away from the antlers and legs, rather than walking straight up to its head.
  • Look for signs of life. Many guides say a deer whose eyes are open and fixed is usually dead, while closed eyes or visible breathing can mean it is still alive. If in doubt, a careful touch to the eye with a long stick from a safe distance is the standard check.
  • Be ready for a follow-up shot, taken safely and legally, rather than trying to finish the animal by hand.
  • Let someone know your plan. Hunting alone is common, but tell a friend or family member where you will be and when to expect you, and carry a charged phone.
  • Know your limits. Dragging and field-dressing a deer is hard work. Hunters with heart conditions or other health concerns should talk to a doctor about what is safe for them.

Remembering the person behind the headline

A lot of the early coverage treated this as a strange "revenge of nature" story. For Alexander's family it was a sudden loss of a husband who was doing something he enjoyed, in country he knew. The most useful thing to take from it is not the shock value but a simple habit: give every downed animal time, and approach with care.

Sources: KTVU, October 2019: Arkansas hunter dead after deer he shot apparently gets up, attacks him; Fox News, October 2019; KY3, October 2019; Realtree: QDMA 2019 Whitetail Report, buck harvest figures; QDMA 2019 Whitetail Report (PDF); Wikipedia: Deer–vehicle collisions; Vox, 2016: deer, sharks and bears.

COMMENTS