
In early 2018, a Bank of America survey reported that 16% of American millennials, roughly one in six people then aged 23 to 37, had $100,000 or more in savings. CNBC shared the figure on Twitter, and the replies poured in, mostly disbelieving and often very funny. The number was real in the sense that people in the survey reported it, but it came with important limits: it relied on self-reported answers, it was much higher for older millennials than younger ones, and other large surveys painted a far thinner picture of young adults’ savings.
Where the one-in-six figure came from
The statistic came from Bank of America’s Better Money Habits Millennial Report, Winter 2018. According to a later analysis by NAPA-Net, the survey was conducted online with about 1,500 adults aged 18 to 71, around half of them millennials, and it asked people to report their own savings.
Several details shape the headline number:
- The age range changed. The 2018 report defined millennials as 23 to 37. The bank’s 2015 version had used 18 to 34. Dropping the youngest and adding older people naturally raises average savings.
- The rise was dramatic. The share reporting $100,000 or more doubled from 8% in 2015 to 16% in 2018.
- Older millennials drove the result. A bank representative said 21% of millennials aged 28 to 37 had reached $100,000, compared with only 5% of those aged 23 to 27.
- Other generations were ahead. The same report put the $100,000 share at 32% for Gen X and 48% for baby boomers.
The report also said 47% of millennials claimed savings of $15,000 or more. What exactly counted as "savings", whether retirement accounts were included and how answers were checked, are the questions any careful reader should ask before comparing themselves with the headline.
The tweet that started it
1 in 6 millennials have $100,000 saved — here's how much you should have at every age https://t.co/rUIyQ4vL00
— CNBC (@CNBC) February 11, 2018
CNBC posted the story on 11 February 2018 and, as the screenshot at the top of this page shows, shared it again in October 2019, which sent a second wave of people to the replies. The linked article paired the survey figure with savings targets by age. A widely quoted rule of thumb from Fidelity, for example, suggests aiming for retirement savings of about one year’s salary by 30, three times salary by 40 and ten times by 67. Set next to those targets, the headline felt to many readers less like news and more like a scolding.
How people reacted on Twitter
The replies below are a fair sample of the mood. Most were jokes; a few made sharp points about the survey itself.

The most popular kind of reply turned the statistic around. This one quipped that the real finding was how many millennials now felt inadequate, a reminder that "average" savings headlines can feel like personal judgements even when they describe only a slice of a generation.

This reply raised the most serious objection: the survey measured what people said they had. The writer pointed to average 401(k) balances, household income and student loan debt, and doubted even the oldest millennials reached one in six. Self-reported money figures are known to be unreliable, which is why researchers prefer surveys that check against records.

Another reader agreed with the doubters, saying they would struggle to believe even one in ten. Gut reactions are not evidence, but they do reflect real experience: many people who started work around the 2008 financial crisis faced weak wages for years.

A blunter version of the same doubt: the survey simply could not be accurate. It was one of the most common responses in the thread, repeated in many slightly different forms.

This joke suggested any millennial with a six-figure balance had ridden the cryptocurrency boom. The timing made it land: bitcoin had peaked near $20,000 in December 2017 and was falling sharply in the weeks before the tweet.

A play on the headline’s own format, claiming six out of six millennials did not know what saving was. It leans on an old stereotype about young people and money that surveys of actual saving habits do not really support.

This reply asked how the figure squared with low wages and guessed that baby boomer parents were doing the saving. Family help is a real factor: gifts and inheritances from parents can make a big difference to young adults’ wealth, and they are spread very unevenly.

Two words, no explanation needed. Short replies like this made up much of the thread and show how strongly the number clashed with people’s own lives.

A reaction GIF from reality television, captioned "THE LIES!!!", summed up the mood for a lot of readers. It is a joke, but it also shows how quickly a statistic can lose trust when it does not match everyday experience.

The last reply here pointed to another CNBC headline from a month earlier: US credit card debt had passed $1 trillion. Federal Reserve data did show revolving credit, mostly credit card balances, crossing that line around the end of 2017. The contrast between record debt and rosy savings is exactly what made people suspicious.
What other data said about young adults’ savings
The doubters had a point. Other surveys from the same period looked very different. In the 2017 Retirement Confidence Survey by the Employee Benefit Research Institute and Greenwald & Associates, 58% of workers aged 25 to 34 reported less than $10,000 in savings and investments, including 34% with less than $1,000. Yet 10% of that group reported between $100,000 and $249,999, so large balances did exist, just among a minority.
The Federal Reserve’s annual survey of household well-being found that in 2017 about four in ten American adults faced with an unexpected $400 expense would have to borrow, sell something or could not pay it at all. That figure covers all ages, but it puts the "one in six with $100,000" claim in context.
Why one number can mislead
A survey can be honest and still give a skewed impression. A few reasons the millennial figure felt wrong to so many people:
- Averages hide spread. A small group with large balances can sit alongside a majority with very little. The share above a line tells you nothing about the typical person.
- Self-reporting drifts upward. People round, guess and sometimes count things like home equity or retirement funds they cannot easily touch.
- Online panels are not perfect samples. Who signs up to answer a bank’s survey may differ from the population as a whole.
- A 14-year age span is wide. A 37-year-old with fifteen years of work behind them and a 23-year-old fresh from university live in different financial worlds.
What to take from it for your own money
If the headline made you feel behind, you were in very large company. Comparison with a survey average is less useful than a few simple habits: keep a small emergency fund, often suggested as three to six months of essential costs; take any employer retirement match on offer, since it is effectively part of your pay; pay down high-interest debt such as credit cards; and let time and compound growth do their work. Personal situations vary a lot, so a qualified financial adviser can help you set targets that fit your own life.
The internet’s reaction to the CNBC tweet was funny, but it was also a useful piece of collective fact-checking. Behind the jokes was a fair question: who exactly was surveyed, and does their answer describe me?
Sources: Bank of America, Better Money Habits Millennial Report, Winter 2018; NAPA-Net: Have 1 in 6 Millennials Really Saved More Than $100,000?; CNBC on Twitter, 11 February 2018; Federal Reserve: Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2017, Dealing with Unexpected Expenses. Screenshots: public replies to CNBC on Twitter.

COMMENTS