Why Fewer Young Adults Are Getting Married: The Data and Reasons

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2017-11-21.

Why Marriage Patterns Change Across Generations

Young adults today are marrying later, and fewer are married at any given age, but not because they have given up on commitment or are busier with casual sex than their parents were. The best evidence points to a mix of causes: more years in education, economic uncertainty, the rise of living together before or instead of marriage, changing roles for women, and, quite possibly, the pressure that comes with having more choice than any generation before. Much of the change is delay rather than rejection: many people simply want to be sure first.

Below we look at what the numbers actually show, test some popular explanations against research, and offer a few practical thoughts for anyone who feels stuck between wanting a partner and wanting to keep every option open.

What the numbers show

The clearest snapshot comes from a 2011 Pew Research Center report based on U.S. Census data for 2010. It found that:

  • only 51% of American adults were married in 2010, a record low, compared with 72% in 1960;
  • among adults aged 18 to 29, just 20% were married, down from 59% in 1960;
  • the median age at first marriage had risen by roughly six years, from about 20 for women and 23 for men in 1960 to 26.5 for women and 28.7 for men;
  • marriage had fallen much less among college graduates than among people with less education.

An important caution: a lower share of married twenty-somethings does not automatically mean those people will never marry. Much of the change reflects delay. Someone who weds at 31 instead of 22 shows up as “unmarried” in the 18 to 29 statistics, even if they go on to a long marriage. The Pew report itself did not identify one single cause and described several possible contributors.

The usual suspects

Commentators have offered many explanations over the years. Each has some truth, and none explains everything.

Education and economics

More young people stay in college and training for longer, which pushes back the age at which they feel settled. Pew also noted that the recession of the late 2000s may have contributed to a dip in new marriages, though the link was not clear-cut. Many couples now see a stable income and a home as preconditions for marriage rather than things to build together afterwards.

Women's choices

Women today have far more economic independence than their grandmothers did. Marriage has become a choice rather than a financial necessity, and many women reasonably wait until they find a partner who shares the work of a household and supports their goals.

Cohabitation and changing norms

Living together, staying single and raising children outside marriage have all become more common and more socially accepted. For many couples, cohabiting is a step before marriage; for others it is a long-term alternative.

Is hookup culture to blame?

A popular theory says that dating apps and casual sex have made marriage seem pointless. The data do not support the idea that young adults are dramatically more promiscuous than earlier generations.

Sociologist Martin Monto and Anna Carey of the University of Portland compared nationally representative General Social Survey data for college-educated 18 to 25-year-olds in two periods: 1988 to 1996 and 2002 to 2010, the supposed “hookup era”. The share reporting more than one sexual partner in the previous year was virtually unchanged, 31.9% in the earlier group and 31.6% in the later one. The later group was actually slightly less likely to report having sex weekly or more. What had shifted was the type of relationship: more young people described a recent partner as a friend or casual date rather than a spouse or regular partner, which fits a world in which marriage comes later.

A separate 2015 study by psychologists Jean Twenge, Ryne Sherman and Brooke Wells in Archives of Sexual Behavior, also using General Social Survey data, estimated that Millennials had fewer lifetime sexual partners on average than Baby Boomers, roughly 8 compared with about 11.7, after controlling for age. Millennials were more accepting of premarital sex in their attitudes, but not more active in practice.

So if apps play a role in delayed marriage, it is probably not through a flood of one-night stands.

The paradox of too many options

A more convincing psychological explanation is choice itself. Dating apps put hundreds of potential partners a swipe away. That sounds like freedom, but it can also make commitment feel like a loss: settling on one person means closing the door on everyone else.

Psychologist Barry Schwartz popularised this idea in his 2004 book The Paradox of Choice. Building on the economist Herbert Simon's work, he distinguished between “maximisers”, who feel they must find the very best option, and “satisficers”, who set sensible standards and are content once those are met. Schwartz argued that maximisers, faced with endless options, tend to feel more anxious and less satisfied with what they choose.

Some caution is needed. Research on “choice overload” has produced mixed results: one 2010 meta-analysis found little overall effect, while a 2015 analysis of 99 studies found the effect does appear under certain conditions, such as complex choices and uncertain preferences. Choosing a life partner arguably ticks both boxes. Writers on Millennial stress, including Caroline Beaton, have made a similar point: keeping one eye on alternatives can quietly undermine contentment with the person in front of you.

Stanford economist Paul Oyer, who has written about online dating through the lens of economics, has suggested that people searching online may do better if they widen their criteria rather than hold out for a perfect match. Kristen Dombek, reviewing books on modern romance for The New York Times, made a related observation: people tend to find what they want once they stop treating dates like data to sort and rank.

If you feel stuck between options

None of this means everyone should marry, or marry sooner. Staying single, cohabiting long term or marrying late are all valid choices. But if you do want a committed relationship and find yourself always searching, a few ideas may help:

  • Define your priorities. Write down the few qualities that truly matter to you, such as kindness, shared values or how someone handles conflict, and separate them from preferences that are nice but negotiable.
  • Aim for “right for me”, not “best possible”. In Schwartz's terms, try satisficing: decide what is good enough on the things that matter, and stop scanning once you find it.
  • Limit the endless scroll. Fewer, deeper conversations tend to reveal more than a queue of matches.
  • Give people time. Many lasting couples did not feel fireworks on the first date. Substance often shows itself slowly.
  • Be honest about what you want. Whether that is marriage, a partnership without a wedding or freedom for now, saying so early saves everyone time.

Marriage is changing, not disappearing

The shift in marriage patterns says less about a generation that has rejected commitment and more about a society in which marriage is optional, later and more carefully chosen. People marry when they finish studying, when they feel financially stable, and when they are confident in the match, and many decide not to marry at all.

That freedom has real benefits. The challenge it brings is knowing what you want amid so many possibilities. The answer is not perfection, which no partner can offer, but clarity about your own priorities and the willingness to stop searching once you have found someone who meets them.

Sources: Pew Research Center, “Barely Half of U.S. Adults Are Married: A Record Low” (14 December 2011); ScienceDaily on Monto & Carey's General Social Survey study (2013); San Diego State University on Twenge, Sherman & Wells, Archives of Sexual Behavior (2015); The Paradox of Choice (Wikipedia); SFGate on Paul Oyer; Kristen Dombek, The New York Times Book Review (2015); earlier version via I Heart Intelligence.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1
  1. This article feels incomplete, but ultimately gives some good advice. Let me add a bit more. First, if you want to be in a successful marriage, you need to be happy with yourself individually. There is no one who "completes" you. This is not a movie - it's real life. Women and men who haven't sorted through their personal issues BEFORE getting married end up dragging all that baggage along with them, and they end up killing their relationship.

    One item mentioned in this article is to know what you're looking for, which is a great idea IF you are not making a list of superficial qualities. It really will not matter in ten years, twenty years, or beyond, if your spouse has six-pack abs, or blue eyes, or is really tall. If you can't bring yourself to look beyond physical attractiveness, then your relationships are doomed. Someone once said, "Show me the most beautiful woman in the world, and I'll show you a guy who's tired of her." Looks only take things so far. Sure, it's important to be attracted to a person, but it is even better if there is a mental connection, or a witty connection, or some aspect of the person's personality that turns you on because that is not likely to just disappear. Additionally, too many men and women completely overlook STRENGTH of character when choosing a mate. If a man has a list of "crazy" exes, HE IS THE PROBLEM. If a man lies, cheats, steals - those red flags exist for a reason. If he leaves the toilet seat up, or ogles other women when he's out with you, or puts his needs and well-being ahead of yours, then he is not the one for you. This is an area to go back to the true biblical roles of marriage. Yes, the bible says women should be submissive to their husbands. That just means he gets to be the majority vote in decisions (51/49), but it doesn't mean unilateral decision-making (at least not in my marriage) without respect or regard for the wife's point of view. Plus, the bible also says men should take care of women they way they take care of a part of their own body. Biblically speaking, the 1+1=1. A man should understand that the key to his own happiness is his wife's happiness, and the key to reducing his stress level is reducing her stress level. When a man and a woman work at this together for each other's benefit, there are enormous well-being benefits. These young people have no idea what they are missing out on!

    Being partnered, for life, means having someone take care of you when you are sick, having someone take a ride to the store with you at night when you don't want to go alone, or having someone agree to split up the chores so you can focus on your big work project. My husband and I have a very give-and-take relationship. Earlier in our marriage, I earned a bigger percentage of the family income (only slightly more than he) and our chore list was split fairly evenly. Now, he earns about 90% of the income and I work two low-paying, self employment jobs - both part time. I'm supposed to be handling a lot of the chores, but that's not possible because my two jobs together are more than a full-time job.I can't possibly do everything. But my husband knows I'm focused on my business and hopes one day it will pay off, so he does the laundry each week, which is a great help!

    I won't say we don't argue. We do! But we work it out because getting along with someone you've known for 20 year can take WORK! When you work to smooth out the rough spots in a relationship. That is the definition of LOVE. Love is a VERB, not a feeling. Remember that, roll up your sleeves, and find a partner to keep you company for life!

    ReplyDelete