
During the 2019 measles outbreak, New York ended religious exemptions from vaccination requirements for school and child-care attendance.
The law responded to concern about vaccination coverage during the 2019 measles outbreak. Its practical effect concerned school-entry requirements and the removal of religious exemptions.
The transition rules required timely first doses and scheduled follow-up appointments for affected children; failure to meet the requirements could prevent attendance. As the transition deadlines approached, some parents opposed the change and challenged its effect on attendance.
Attendance depended on meeting the applicable immunization requirements or qualifying for a medical exemption. State health officials said that 26,217 unvaccinated New York kids in public schools, private schools, parochial schools, daycare centers, and prekindergarten programs obtained religious exemptions during the 2017–2018 school year.
The measles outbreak, which prompted the new law, is easing. Mayor Bill de Blasio previously declared an end to the measles outbreak in its epicenter, New York City. Since October 2018, there’ve been 654 measles cases in the city and 414 in other parts of the state, where transmission has also slowed. The CDC describes children under five as one of the groups at higher risk of measles complications. CDC guidance states that as many as one in twenty children with measles develop pneumonia; its clinical overview estimates one to three deaths per thousand infected children. Other complications include swelling of the brain (which can lead to deafness or disabilities).
What are your thoughts? Comment below and don't forget to share.
















Here's what people had to say:





Additional sources: New York State Health Department: August 2019 exemption and transition guidance; CDC: measles complications; CDC: measles symptoms and pneumonia risk.
The 2019 change retained medical exemptions
New York’s June 2019 law removed nonmedical exemptions while retaining documented medical exemptions. State guidance allowed affected children fourteen days from the start of school to receive the first age-appropriate doses and thirty days to schedule follow-up doses. That timetable mattered to families preparing for the new school year: completing a vaccination series could involve subsequent appointments, while the transition rules set deadlines for beginning and arranging that process.
Update, 2025: the law back in the courts
The 2019 law has faced continuing legal challenges. In March 2025 the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit upheld it against a challenge brought by Amish schools and parents in Miller v. McDonald. On 8 December 2025 the Supreme Court, without ruling on the merits, ordered the appeals court to reconsider the case in light of its June 2025 decision in Mahmoud v. Taylor on parents’ religious objections in schools. Check current court rulings and state guidance before relying on any description of the rules.

COMMENTS